"Is This the Bottom? ... The Real Danger Lies Elsewhere" ... A Chilling Warning for Samsung Electronics and SK hynix

"If memory prices fall, earnings forecasts will deteriorate sharply"
KB Securities forecasts DRAM prices will rise 40% next year.

As shares of Samsung Electronics and SK hynix weaken, views on the semiconductor industry outlook are divided. Some warn that share prices could fall further if earnings growth driven by rising memory prices hits a ceiling. Others say demand for AI memory remains strong and expect memory prices to continue rising next year.


The KOSPI plunged 3-4% at the opening on Nov. 20, falling below 5,000 in a single stroke. The KOSPI, KOSDAQ and won-dollar exchange rate are displayed in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. 2026.11.20 Photo by Cho Yongjun

The KOSPI plunged 3-4% at the opening on Nov. 20, falling below 5,000 in a single stroke. The KOSPI, KOSDAQ and won-dollar exchange rate are displayed in the dealing room at Hana Bank's headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. 2026.11.20 Photo by Cho Yongjun

View original image

According to the Korea Exchange, the KOSPI and KOSDAQ plunged more than 5% intraday on Nov. 20, triggering sell-sidecars in both markets.


As of 2:37 p.m. on Nov. 20, Samsung Electronics was down 7.66% from the previous day at 181,700 won, while SK hynix was down 6.84% from the previous trading day at 1,103,000 won.

"Production and shipments are the same as a year ago; the companies haven't grown"

Amid increased volatility in major semiconductor stocks, industry analyst Lee Juwan predicted that share prices could face a greater shock if memory prices begin to fall in earnest. Lee drew attention in October when he set fair value estimates of 70,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 200,000 won for SK hynix.


Appearing on the YouTube channel Jisik Hankkeut on Nov. 18, Lee said, "The full-fledged crash hasn't started yet," adding, "Memory companies' share prices will crash only when prices start to fall."


He argued that if news of falling memory prices starts to emerge at the end of this year or early next year, securities firms could sharply lower their earnings forecasts for related companies for next year and the following year.


On November 20, as the KOSPI opened down 3% to 4% and quickly fell below the 5,000 mark, the KOSPI, KOSDAQ, and won-dollar exchange rate were displayed in the dealing room at Hana Bank headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. 2026.11.20. Photo by Cho Yongjun

On November 20, as the KOSPI opened down 3% to 4% and quickly fell below the 5,000 mark, the KOSPI, KOSDAQ, and won-dollar exchange rate were displayed in the dealing room at Hana Bank headquarters in Jung-gu, Seoul. 2026.11.20. Photo by Cho Yongjun

View original image

He also cited as a problem the fact that semiconductor companies' current earnings growth depends much more on rising memory prices than on increased production. "Production and shipments are exactly the same as a year ago," Lee said. "For a manufacturer, the fact that production is unchanged means the company hasn't grown at all."


He added, "Right now, earnings have improved solely because prices have gone up," explaining that as production expansion gathers pace, increased supply could put greater downward pressure on prices.


He also expressed a critical view of Nvidia, which is leading the AI semiconductor market. "Companies can't create demand," he said, arguing, "The market has spent three years in a state where Nvidia has forcibly created demand among suppliers, and that's why there's a bubble now."

KB Securities: "External risks already reflected in share prices... Pessimism at its peak"

By contrast, some say market pessimism is excessive given the semiconductor industry's solid momentum. KB Securities forecast that next year the average selling price (ASP) of DRAM from Samsung Electronics and SK hynix will rise 40% year over year, while NAND prices will increase 30%.


Kim Dongwon, head of research at KB Securities, and researcher Lee Changmin said, "Global DRAM demand is expected to increase 25% year over year next year, led by server DRAM, significantly outpacing the 18% growth in supply."


On the recent sharp drop in semiconductor share prices, Kim and his colleagues said, "The decline reflects a combination of external factors, including changes in Nvidia's leadership and the U.S. Democratic Party's approach to AI regulation, as well as falling spot prices for memory."



They added, "What determines Samsung Electronics' and SK hynix's earnings is contract pricing, not spot pricing. With the gap between the two now exceeding 20%, they need to be viewed separately." They said, "As excessive concerns about external factors have already been substantially reflected in share prices, market pessimism toward both companies appears to be nearing its peak, despite their solid fundamentals."