Saudi Arabia and Russia Oppose Language on Phasing Out Fossil Fuels
Trump's Climate Cooperation Exit Exposes Rifts in International Cooperation

The 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) ended without adopting a final agreement after an intense standoff between oil-producing countries and the European Union (EU) over phasing out fossil fuels. It was the first time in 17 years, since the 2009 Copenhagen conference in Denmark, that a UN climate conference failed to adopt a final agreement.


With the Trump Administration’s withdrawal from international climate cooperation compounded by a sharp rise in energy prices due to the war in Iran, the international community’s response to the climate crisis is being put to the test, observers say.


Reuters-Yonhap News

Reuters-Yonhap News

View original image

According to The New York Times (NYT) and other media outlets on November 22 (local time), COP31, held in Antalya, Türkiye, failed to adopt a joint agreement that day after member states were unable to bridge their differences over reducing fossil fuel use and other issues. The conference was originally scheduled to close on November 20, but negotiations proved difficult, and even after the conference was extended by two days, no agreement was reached.


The biggest point of contention in the negotiations was whether the final agreement would explicitly call for a transition away from fossil fuels such as oil, natural gas, and coal. The EU and countries vulnerable to the effects of climate change called for concrete measures to reduce fossil fuel use. However, major oil-producing countries, including Saudi Arabia and Russia, strongly opposed the proposals.


The EU said that about 130 countries supported explicitly calling for a transition away from fossil fuels, but opposition from oil-producing countries prevented an agreement.


Darragh O'Brien, Ireland's Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment, who took part in the negotiations on behalf of the EU, criticized the outcome, saying, "It is unthinkable to conclude a climate agreement that does not even mention fossil fuels," and, "We cannot accept an agreement that makes fossil fuels appear environmentally friendly."


Russia, Saudi Arabia, and other countries countered that limiting fossil fuel use could lead to energy supply insecurity and sharp price increases. Russian representative Sergey Kononuchenko opposed language related to fossil fuels, saying, "If oil and gas supplies decline faster than demand, it could cause price shocks and energy poverty."


The confrontation between the two sides was also evident in the drafting of the agreement. Language on fossil fuels included in the initial draft was removed from a revised version following opposition from oil-producing countries. The final draft reaffirmed the agreement adopted at the 2023 conference in Dubai, United Arab Emirates (UAE), but omitted all references to "fossil fuels," "oil," "coal," and a "phaseout."


Rifts in international cooperation...Impact of Trump Administration's withdrawal and the war in Iran

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The breakdown in the negotiations is also linked to the Trump Administration's shift in climate policy. Critics say the United States' withdrawal from international climate cooperation has weakened the central force for reconciling the interests of major countries. The sharp rise in international oil prices due to the war in Iran also affected the negotiations, as governments shifted their policy priorities toward energy security and stabilizing the cost of living.


Citing the recent meeting in Shenzhen, China, between U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin, at which they agreed to expand oil production and supply, the NYT said it had become even more difficult to secure an international agreement to cut emissions as major greenhouse gas emitters moved to increase fossil fuel supplies.


At the 2023 conference in Dubai, countries reached a historic agreement that explicitly called for a transition away from fossil fuels for the first time. However, the three conferences held since then have failed to adopt final agreements that directly mention fossil fuels.


The UN climate conference operates on a consensus basis, with more than 190 countries participating. Because an agreement can be adopted only if there are no formal objections, opposition from just a few countries can derail negotiations.


Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany, said that a decision-making process requiring near-unanimity is the biggest weakness of international climate negotiations. Former U.S. Vice President Al Gore also criticized a system in which a small number of countries can block the entire negotiation process and proposed adopting a qualified majority voting system.



However, the failure of these negotiations does not invalidate climate agreements adopted at previous conferences. Some countries, including Denmark, Spain, and Portugal, are pursuing reductions in fossil fuel use separately from UN-level agreements.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing