Reconstruction Excess Profit Recapture Charges Begin Next Month with Banpo Hyundai; Average 110 Million Won per Member at 52 Seoul Complexes
Lawsuits and unpaid charges possible after imposition; potential changes to the system also a factor
As the imposition of reconstruction excess profit recapture charges gets underway in earnest, starting next month with Banpo Hyundai in Seocho-gu, Seoul (now Banpo Centreville Asterium), the average estimated charge per member at 52 affected complexes in Seoul has been found to exceed 110 million won.
Banpo Centerville Asterium in Seocho-gu, the first apartment complex in Seoul's Gangnam area subject to the recapture of reconstruction gains. Yonhap News Agency
View original imageAccording to data obtained from the Seoul Metropolitan Government and Gyeonggi Province by Kwon Young-jin of the People Power Party, a member of the National Assembly’s Public Administration and Security Committee, as of August this year, 52 reconstruction complexes in Seoul had been notified of their estimated charges under the reconstruction excess profit recapture system. The total estimated charges for these complexes amount to 2.3552 trillion won. Divided among the 20,940 association members, that comes to an average of about 110 million won per member.
Including the estimated charge recently notified by Gangnam-gu to Eunma Apartment in Daechi-dong on October 30—2.0044 trillion won in total, or an average of 463.34 million won per member—the charges that Seoul reconstruction complexes will have to bear will exceed 4.3 trillion won.
Among the 52 complexes included in the August tally, Banpo District 3 in Seocho-gu had the highest estimated total, at about 514.9 billion won. It was followed by Hangang Mansion in Yongsan-gu (472.3 billion won), Singil Complex 10 in Yeongdeungpo-gu (160.5 billion won), Yeouido Hanyang in Yeongdeungpo-gu (130 billion won), and Dogok Gaepo Hanshin in Gangnam-gu (106.7 billion won).
Hangang Mansion in Yongsan-gu had the highest estimated average charge per association member, at 720 million won. It was followed by Eunhasu in Gangnam-gu (380 million won), Banpo District 3 in Seocho-gu (350 million won), and Singil Complex 10 in Yeongdeungpo-gu (280 million won).
The complexes notified of estimated charges were not limited to the Gangnam area and neighborhoods along the Han River. By district, the tally was as follows: Seocho-gu (9 complexes); Yeongdeungpo-gu and Songpa-gu (8 each); Gangnam-gu (7); Gangseo-gu (5); Guro-gu (3); Yongsan-gu, Seongdong-gu, Gangdong-gu and Seodaemun-gu (2 each); and Geumcheon-gu, Dongdaemun-gu, Mapo-gu and Gangbuk-gu (1 each).
In Gyeonggi Province, Suwon Yeongtong District 2, Gwacheon Jugong Complexes 4, 5, 8 and 9, and Gwangmyeong Cheolsan Jugong Complexes 8 and 9 were also notified of estimated charges at the project implementation approval stage. First-generation new towns such as Bundang, Pyeongchon, Sanbon and Ilsan, where floor area ratios can be raised to as much as 450% under the Special Act on the Maintenance of Aging Planned Cities, could also become subject to the charges, as their land contribution rates are lower than Seoul’s.
In provincial areas, association estimates for projects such as Daejeon’s Yongmun-dong Districts 1, 2 and 3 (now Dunsan The Sharp Elif) and Beomeo Woobang Complex 1 in Suseong-gu, Daegu (now Beomeo I-Park Complex 1) range from tens of millions of won to around 100 million won.
Banpo Hyundai faces average charge of 220 million won per member; final charges due by December 30
Actual charges may be higher or lower than the amounts initially notified. This is because most of the estimates in the Seoul Metropolitan Government’s data were calculated before completion or based on property prices from before the December 2023 revision of the Reconstruction Excess Profit Recapture Act. The final amount will vary depending on housing prices at the time of completion, recognized development costs, whether the revised law applies, and individual reductions.
Banpo Hyundai was rebuilt as a complex of 108 households, with 80 association members subject to the charge calculation. On November 9, Seocho-gu gave the Banpo Hyundai association preliminary notice of an estimated charge totaling 17.9 billion won, or about 220 million won per member on average. That is an increase of around 80 million won from the approximately 140 million won per member initially notified when the charge was calculated in 2018.
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport recently issued an authoritative interpretation stating that “the special provisions in the supplementary clauses resulting from the revision of the law set a deadline for processing the backlog of work; they did not extend the exclusion period for imposing charges itself, which is five years from five months after the date of completion approval.” As a result, the final deadline for imposing a charge on Banpo Hyundai, completed in July 2021, was set as December 30. The association’s 50-day period from the date of preliminary notice to request a review before the charge notice is issued (an objection) ends on December 29, just one day before the deadline for imposing the charge.
A Seocho-gu official said, “Taking into account the statutory deadline of December 30, we issued preliminary notice 50 days in advance, on November 9,” adding, “We plan to coordinate with the association so that we can receive and review documents in advance concerning development costs and reductions based on residency periods.”
Lawsuits and unpaid charges possible after imposition; potential changes to the system also a factor
Apartments in the Banpo 3 District area of Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 22nd. Yonhap News
View original imageHowever, even after bills are sent, collection could be delayed if lawsuits over the calculated amounts or payment defaults occur. Complexes facing additional contributions due to a sharp rise in construction costs are also now saddled with reconstruction excess profit recapture charges of hundreds of millions of won or more, prompting them to take collective action, including lawsuits. While the Banpo Hyundai association is considering preparations for a lawsuit, the National Federation of Reconstruction and Redevelopment Associations, which comprises 82 associations nationwide, plans to hold a rally near the Blue House next month calling for the system’s abolition.
Disputes also dragged on in past cases. The reconstruction excess profit recapture system was introduced in 2006, suspended from the end of 2012 through 2017, and reinstated in 2018. As a result, only five small-scale row-house complexes whose projects were completed before the suspension were charged under the previous system. Banpo Hyundai, next month, will be the first general apartment complex subject to the charges since the system was reinstated in 2018.
In 2014, Doosan Row Houses in Cheongdam-dong, Gangnam-gu (now Cheongdam e-Pyeonhansesang 4th) was charged 431.17 million won, or 6.34 million won per member. After an administrative lawsuit, the Supreme Court last year issued a final ruling reducing the amount to 208.27 million won, less than half the original charge. A retrial is now underway, and collection of the charge has reportedly yet to be completed. Hannam Row Houses in Yongsan-gu (now Hannam Paragon), which was charged a total of 1.72 billion won in 2012, or 55.44 million won per member, only began paying after an administrative lawsuit and a constitutional complaint, following a 2019 ruling that the system was constitutional. However, two of its 31 association members are reportedly still in arrears.
There is also growing opposition over the perceived unfairness of imposing no charges on high-value redevelopment projects such as Yongsan’s Hannam New Town and Seongsu Strategic Redevelopment Zone, where villa shares are worth 4 billion to 5 billion won, and over how increases in normal housing prices—the increase in ordinary home prices unaffected by reconstruction-related benefits—are calculated and excluded from excess profits. Under current law, redevelopment projects are classified as public-interest projects and excluded from the charges because they improve areas with inadequate infrastructure and are required to build rental housing and compensate tenants.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Whether the National Assembly and the government move to revise the system is another factor. The Act on the Recovery of Reconstruction Gains, revised in December 2023 and enacted in March 2024, raised the exemption threshold for average excess profits per association member from 30 million won to 80 million won, introduced reductions of up to 70% for long-term owners of a single home, and established a deferral of payment for older people. Two bills to abolish the reconstruction excess profit recapture system, separately sponsored by People Power Party lawmakers Kim Eun-hye and Ko Dong-jin, are currently pending in the National Assembly. Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport Hong Ji-seon also said in the National Assembly on November 12, “The system clearly has an effect on stabilizing housing market prices, but it also infringes on individual property rights. I believe these matters need to be considered comprehensively.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.