IV. How to Protect Energy Sovereignty
Renewable Energy Expansion and Accelerated Electrification... New Challenges for Energy Security
"Electrification Without Securing Carbon-Free Power Could Increase Reliance on Fossil-Fuel Generation"
"Energy Policies Need Industrial Impact Assessments... Electricity Rates Must Become More Predictable"

Editor's NoteRecent supply chain crises caused by wars in the Middle East and the government's mega-projects have made energy more important than ever. With South Korea relying on overseas sources for most of its primary energy, it faces the difficult task of simultaneously achieving energy security, carbon neutrality and economic growth. In this series, reporters covering energy issues on the ground in government and industry examine a range of current challenges and seek solutions.
Before a roundtable discussion on energy sovereignty at The Asia Business Daily headquarters, the participating experts posed for a group photo. From left: Professor Kim Jinsu of the Department of Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Ahn Gukheon, director of sustainability management at the Korea Petroleum Association; Professor Yoo Seunghoon of the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Han Byunghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; and Kim Jaehun, head of external relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Photo by Heo Younghan

Before a roundtable discussion on energy sovereignty at The Asia Business Daily headquarters, the participating experts posed for a group photo. From left: Professor Kim Jinsu of the Department of Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Ahn Gukheon, director of sustainability management at the Korea Petroleum Association; Professor Yoo Seunghoon of the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Han Byunghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; and Kim Jaehun, head of external relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Photo by Heo Younghan

View original image

What is the purpose of the energy transition? Will reducing fossil fuel use and increasing electricity consumption strengthen energy security? Can expanding renewable energy achieve the twin goals of carbon neutrality and industrial competitiveness? Although the energy transition has become an irreversible trend, questions about how to carry it out and what role the government should play are growing more pressing.


As electric vehicles, artificial intelligence (AI) data centers and the electrification of industrial processes become more widespread, electricity has emerged as a pillar of the national economy. Energy security was once centered on how reliably the country could secure crude oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG). Going forward, industrial competitiveness will depend on how reliably and economically electricity can be generated and supplied.


Views on energy sovereignty are also changing. The traditional approach of diversifying sources of oil and gas imports and increasing stockpiles is no longer considered sufficient. Experts say that building an energy system resilient to external shocks requires solar and wind power facilities, battery and critical mineral supply chains, power grid operating technologies, and the ability to negotiate internationally.


These issues were a focus of a roundtable hosted by The Asia Business Daily on November 20 under the theme, "In the Era of the Energy Transition, How Can We Protect Energy Sovereignty and Economic Growth?" Participants included Yoo Seunghoon, professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Kim Jinsu, professor in the Department of Energy Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Han Byeonghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; Ahn Gukheon, director of sustainability management at the Korea Petroleum Association; and Kim Jaehun, head of external affairs at the Korea Chemical Industry Association.


The experts acknowledged the need for electrification and renewable energy expansion, while emphasizing that the pace of implementation, power supply capacity, transition costs and effects on industrial competitiveness must all be considered. They also argued that energy sovereignty should be redefined not simply as securing resources, but as a concept encompassing supply chain resilience, technological and manufacturing capabilities, international negotiating power and system operating capacity.


Reforming energy policy governance also emerged as a key issue. Participants said public discussion is needed on how to coordinate policy functions divided between the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy and the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment; how to improve the power market structure centered on Korea Electric Power Corporation; and how much of the transition costs the public and businesses can bear.


Here are the main points from the roundtable, presented in a Q&A format.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jinsoo, professor in the Department of Earth Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University. Heo Younghan, reporter

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jinsoo, professor in the Department of Earth Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University. Heo Younghan, reporter

View original image

-Electrification and renewable energy expansion can strengthen energy security, but dependence on overseas sources for critical minerals and power generation equipment poses new risks. How should these be addressed?


▲Professor Kim Jinsu=Securing supply chains for critical minerals and equipment is essential, and work is already underway on this. If production capacity is available, power generation equipment can to some extent help address short-term supply shocks, but critical minerals are a different matter. Dependence on China is particularly high in refining and processing. This may be less of a problem when markets operate freely, but the situation changes when such resources are used as economic security tools, such as through export controls.


It is impossible to produce every mineral and component domestically. What matters is building supply chains that can respond to disruptions from any one country. Given its manufacturing capabilities, South Korea can be an important alternative for countries seeking to build supply chains that exclude China. We should make active use of this position.


I would also like to emphasize resource recycling. Recovering and reusing resources from products and equipment already in the country could have an effect similar to having domestic mines. However, if recycling costs more than mining new minerals, an industrial ecosystem will be difficult to establish if left to the market alone. Policy support and an institutional foundation are needed in the early stages.


-What conditions are needed for renewable energy expansion to strengthen the competitiveness of domestic industries?


▲Director Han Byeonghwa=When evaluating supply chains, we need to distinguish between two things: whether a company actually possesses the technology and whether it can supply products at an economically viable price. We cannot say that domestic companies have lost all their technological competitiveness. Solar and wind power equipment manufacturers have also faced difficulties expanding their businesses because the domestic market has not grown enough.


South Korea has considerable technological and manufacturing capabilities in electrification-related industries, including solar and wind power, batteries and electric vehicles. Korean companies can play an important role in global markets seeking to build supply chains that exclude China. The problem is that these capabilities are not being fully utilized at home.


Growth in the domestic market would create conditions for companies to invest. They could improve their competitiveness by manufacturing equipment and advancing their technologies. Renewable energy expansion should not be viewed simply in terms of the amount of power generation capacity installed. We also need to consider how to develop the domestic industrial ecosystem.


-Electrification is a means of reducing carbon emissions. Given current power supply conditions, is it appropriate to accelerate electrification?


▲Professor Yoo Seunghoon=We first need to clarify the purpose of electrification. Ultimately, isn't it to reduce carbon emissions? But rapid electrification leads to a significant increase in electricity demand. What matters is which power sources will meet that demand.


Electrification advanced quickly in South Korea in the past because electricity prices were relatively low. The situation has changed recently, with industrial electricity rates rising sharply. If electrification extends to the heating sector, electricity demand will inevitably increase substantially.


The problem is the pace at which carbon-free power sources can be secured. Solar power faces challenges involving suitable sites and public acceptance, while wind power is difficult to deploy because of permitting and commercial viability issues. Nuclear power also takes considerable time to build. If electrification moves ahead under these circumstances, the increased electricity demand may have to be met with LNG or coal-fired power. If fossil fuel power plants are used more intensively as a result of electrification pursued in the name of carbon neutrality, it would be difficult to say that the policy is achieving its purpose. The point is not to reject electrification, but to consider it alongside the pace of carbon-free power expansion.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Han Byeonghwa, Director at Eugene Investment & Securities. Reporter Heo Younghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Han Byeonghwa, Director at Eugene Investment & Securities. Reporter Heo Younghan

View original image

-There are also concerns that slowing electrification could leave the country behind global industrial changes.


▲Director Han Byeonghwa=Electrification is not a trend being artificially created by governments; global industries are already moving in that direction. Rising electricity use due to electric vehicles, data centers and changes in manufacturing is a worldwide trend.


If renewable energy deployment falls short of its targets, the conclusion should not be to slow electrification, but to examine why deployment is lagging. Simply telling power producers to add capacity when they cannot secure profitability will not expand deployment. It is the government's role to lower costs and design policies that make projects viable.


South Korea has significant opportunities in the era of electrification. If the global market is changing rapidly but domestic policies are not working properly, the country could miss out on these industrial opportunities.


-As electrification expands, how should the energy mix of renewables, nuclear power and LNG be designed?


▲Professor Kim Jinsu=When designing an energy system, we need to decide which values to prioritize. The choices may differ depending on whether we prioritize economic efficiency, carbon reduction or the reliability of supply, and how much importance we attach to each. These values are interconnected.


An energy mix is not simply a matter of setting the share of each power source. We also need to consider what kind of industrial structure our economy will maintain, what level of energy costs it can bear, and how much of a burden the public can accept.


The issue of electrification connects back to this. A substantial portion of the energy we use today is consumed in forms other than electricity. Expanding electrification will change not only the power mix but also the overall structure of energy consumption. Expanding renewable energy also requires consideration of energy storage. Batteries alone cannot solve every problem, so we need a portfolio combining multiple storage technologies. Ultimately, the pace of electrification and the energy mix cannot be decided separately.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Professor Yoo Seung-hoon of the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology. Photo by Heo Younghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Professor Yoo Seung-hoon of the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology. Photo by Heo Younghan

View original image

-Changes in energy policy also have a major impact on industry. What improvements are needed in the policymaking process?


▲Head Kim Jaehun=The impact on industry should be assessed more systematically when energy or climate policies are formulated. The policy goals of carbon neutrality and the energy transition are important, but we also need to examine the costs companies will bear in pursuing them and how they will affect industrial competitiveness.


In particular, I hope industrial impact assessments will be conducted transparently when medium- and long-term policies are being developed. Rather than dealing with problems that companies find difficult to manage after a policy is implemented, it is important to thoroughly assess its effects in advance and prepare ways to respond.


The same applies to electricity prices. Industry is not unconditionally opposed to electricity rate increases. It understands the need to reflect costs. The problem is that it is difficult to predict the timing and scale of increases.


If electricity rates rise sharply over a short period, it is difficult for companies to manage production costs or adjust investment plans. Predictability in energy costs is particularly important in manufacturing, where equipment investments are made over long periods. A reasonable rate structure based on costs should be established, while also allowing companies to anticipate their future expenses to some extent.


-What is needed to secure public and industry acceptance of the costs of the transition?


▲Director Ahn Gukheon=In discussions about energy policy, it is important to communicate and share fact-based information. The public needs to be given sufficient objective information about why electricity rates are rising, what costs are being incurred and who is bearing how much of the burden.


There are costs required to maintain reliable power supply, as well as issues related to ensuring the sustainability of Korea Electric Power Corporation. We need to consider the costs borne by households and industry together. If people come to believe that the burden is concentrated on one particular sector without a full explanation of these issues, it will be difficult to secure public acceptance of the policy.


The government needs to explain the facts objectively and conduct research and public discussions from a range of perspectives. It is important to transparently disclose the costs and burdens of the energy transition and build social consensus.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jaehoon, Head of External Relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Reporter Heo Younghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jaehoon, Head of External Relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Reporter Heo Younghan

View original image

-Energy-related functions are divided between the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy and the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment. How do you assess the current policy governance structure?


▲Professor Yoo Seunghoon=In a country like South Korea, where manufacturing accounts for a large share of the economy, we need to consider whether it is appropriate to separate industrial and energy policies. Energy is not simply a means of reducing carbon emissions. It directly affects manufacturing costs, investment and national industrial competitiveness. If industrial and energy policies move in different directions, companies will inevitably face difficulties. Other countries have also undergone multiple organizational restructuring efforts over which ministries should handle energy, climate and industrial policies. We need to assess whether the current structure is appropriate for South Korea as a manufacturing-based economy.


▲Professor Kim Jinsu=It is important to strike a balance between the roles of the public and private sectors. The public sector clearly has a role to play in energy security and reliable supply. However, the public sector cannot take responsibility for the entire energy transition and market innovation going forward. Large state-owned enterprises play an important role in South Korea's energy industry. As the power market changes, the areas in which the private sector can participate will also change. We need to redefine the roles of the public and private sectors in response.


Making information public and putting energy data to use are also important tasks. New services and industries could emerge depending on how information accumulated through the operation of the energy system is disclosed and used. We also need to consider how to ensure policy consistency and independence. However, political considerations cannot be completely excluded because energy prices and supply directly affect people's lives.


▲Director Han Byeonghwa=Trying to build a new energy system while maintaining the power market structure centered on Korea Electric Power Corporation as it is could create a number of contradictions. As renewable energy expands and electrification advances, the roles of various participants—including power producers, consumers and energy storage operators—will grow. It is questionable whether the existing monopolistic power market structure can adequately accommodate these changes. Responding to electrification requires not only increasing power generation capacity but also changing the rules so that the market can function properly.


-How should energy sovereignty be defined in the era of the energy transition?


▲Professor Kim Jinsu=Energy sovereignty is not simply about how much energy a country has secured; it is about its ability to make decisions for itself. If traditional energy security focused on preparing for supply disruptions, the focus going forward must encompass the entire supply chain and energy system.


First, resilience to external shocks is important. No country can completely prevent every shock. What matters is how robustly the system can withstand a shock and how quickly it can recover.


Technological sovereignty is also important. As the energy transition advances, technological and manufacturing capabilities in power generation equipment, storage systems and power grids will become increasingly important. South Korea's position in international supply chains may change depending on how it secures and maintains key technologies and manufacturing capabilities.


International negotiating power is another element of sovereignty. Since no country can be entirely self-sufficient, countries must negotiate with one another. Technological and manufacturing competitiveness can serve as bargaining tools. Information and the ability to operate systems are also necessary. A country must be able to forecast electricity supply and demand and operate its energy system reliably.


The ability to set market rules is also important. Industrial competitiveness changes depending on the rules established internationally and the market systems operated domestically. Ultimately, energy sovereignty must be considered comprehensively, encompassing resource security, supply chain resilience, technological and manufacturing capabilities, international negotiating power, system operating capacity and the ability to set market rules.


Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Ahn Gukheon, Director of Sustainability Management at the Korea Petroleum Association. Reporter Heo Yeonghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Ahn Gukheon, Director of Sustainability Management at the Korea Petroleum Association. Reporter Heo Yeonghan

View original image

-Can renewable energy expansion strengthen energy sovereignty by reducing dependence on imported fossil fuels?


▲Director Han Byeonghwa=The most important consideration in energy sovereignty and energy security is how much we can reduce the energy we import from overseas. South Korea spends vast sums importing oil, coal and gas. The challenge is how quickly we can change this structure.


Solar and wind power are energy sources that can be harnessed domestically. Expanding renewable energy facilities can replace some of the fossil fuels imported from overseas. We should assess not only the costs of expanding renewable energy but also the benefits of reducing fossil fuel imports.


▲Director Ahn Gukheon=Discussions about energy sovereignty should not focus exclusively on any one factor. Energy is also a means of improving people's quality of life and maintaining industrial competitiveness.


If efforts to secure energy sovereignty significantly weaken industrial competitiveness or raise the public's burden to an unsustainable level, they cannot be considered sustainable policy. South Korea is a manufacturing-based economy with a range of developed industries. Each industry requires different types of energy and has a different consumption structure.


Expanding renewable energy is necessary, but it cannot solve every energy problem at once. A range of energy sources must be balanced to maintain a stable supply. Energy sovereignty can be meaningfully strengthened only by considering together what kind of energy system is needed to secure industrial competitiveness.


-What is most important for protecting industrial competitiveness and people's livelihoods while strengthening energy sovereignty?


▲Head Kim Jaehun=Energy sovereignty is about securing the ability to meet the energy needs of the public and industry even when external shocks occur. We cannot rule out the possibility of another supply shock like the one caused by the situation in the Middle East. Even in such circumstances, industries must be able to continue production and energy must be supplied to meet people's needs.


Discussions about energy sovereignty must consider industrial competitiveness and costs as well as supply reliability. The direction of policy and the associated costs must be clearly presented so that companies can prepare for long-term investment and business transitions. We need an approach that considers energy security, carbon neutrality and industrial competitiveness together.


▲Professor Yoo Seunghoon=The economic costs of pursuing carbon neutrality and the energy transition must also be explained accurately. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions requires changes to the industrial structure, and those changes incur costs. Some industries and jobs may also be adversely affected.



We should not assume that pursuing carbon neutrality will automatically lead to both economic growth and job creation. We need to examine the conditions under which such outcomes would occur. The public must be given a full explanation of not only the benefits of the transition but also its costs.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing