Nine in 10 SMEs See New Hires Leave Within a Year: "Low Pay and Workplace Culture to Blame"
KCCI surveys companies and young employees on early departures
Only 9.8% of companies systematically operate workplace adjustment programs
Companies favor retention incentives; young people want housing and transportation support
Nine out of 10 small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) have experienced young new hires leaving within a year of joining. Both companies and young employees cited low wages and rigid workplace cultures as major reasons for early departures. As SMEs often lack the staff and budgets to run programs that help new hires adjust, calls are growing for stronger government support to encourage employees to stay longer.
The Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry said on November 22 that, according to its survey on early departures and retention among young employees at SMEs, the biggest hiring challenge was “repeated hiring due to early departures after recruitment” (40.6%). The survey covered 451 SME human resources managers and 366 SME employees aged 19 to 34. Other challenges included “a shortage of applicants because young people avoid SMEs” (36.1%), “candidates declining offers or not showing up after accepting them” (27.5%), and “a lack of applicants with the right job skills” (26.4%).
In fact, 95.6% of HR managers said that, in the past three years, they had seen young new hires leave within a year of joining. The most frequently cited reason for early departures was “dissatisfaction with low compensation, including salary and benefits” (49.9%). This was followed by “difficulty adjusting to a rigid workplace culture” (35.0%), “difficulty maintaining work-life balance due to overtime and weekend work” (24.6%), and “a mismatch between the job described during recruitment and the actual role” (24.4%).
Young employees expressed similar views. Of those currently working at SMEs, 64.8% said they had decided to leave their first job within a year of starting or were seriously considering doing so. The main reasons were “dissatisfaction with low compensation, including salary and benefits” (41.8%) and “a rigid workplace culture” (30.4%). Young employees also cited “a mismatch between the job described during recruitment and the actual role” (30.0%) as a major reason. “Difficulty maintaining work-life balance” (24.6%), which companies ranked as the third most common reason for departures, ranked fifth among young employees, at 17.7%.
Companies’ support systems to help new hires adjust to the workplace were also found to be inadequate. Only 9.8% of companies had systematic programs and manuals in place and operated them on an ongoing basis. The most common response was that they provided “basic guidance, such as assigning a senior colleague or mentor” (38.8%), followed by “having new hires learn on the job by assigning them work right away” (31.3%) and “having no separate program” (20.2%). Among young employees, only 13.9% said they had received support through a systematic program and manual when they started their first job.
The most common reason for not running a separate adjustment program was “a lack of staff means new hires have to be assigned work immediately” (33.6%). This was followed by “a lack of standard manuals suited to SMEs” (30.6%), “concerns that new hires will leave soon after training” (27.6%), “a lack of operating budget” (24.1%), and “senior employees responsible for training are already overloaded with work” (23.3%).
Among government youth employment policies, both companies and young employees considered programs that support asset building and long-term employment to be effective. HR managers most often selected “support for young people’s asset building and long-term employment” (30.4%) as a program that helped with hiring and retention. This was followed by “employment subsidy support” (28.2%) and “government-led work experience programs” (17.5%). Young employees also cited “support for young people’s asset building and long-term employment” (30.1%) and “government-led work experience programs” (19.9%) as policies that had helped them find their first job.
However, a considerable number of respondents said existing policies had not provided practical help. Among young employees, 19.1% described existing policies as “ineffective or unhelpful.” This was higher than the 11.8% of company respondents who gave the same answer, indicating a need to improve the policies so that people can feel their impact more directly.
As the main area for improving youth employment support policies, HR managers most often pointed to “insufficient incentives for long-term employment compared with those offered during the initial hiring stage” (36.8%). Other responses included “the support amount is insufficient to close gaps in wages and benefits” (22.2%) and “the application process and paperwork are burdensome” (22.0%).
To help young people settle into their first jobs, companies most often called for “stronger incentives for workplace adjustment support” (39.9%), including settlement grants or allowances for young new hires and their designated mentors. This was followed by “direct support for housing and transportation infrastructure for young people in regional areas” (37.3%). Young employees, by contrast, selected “direct support for housing and transportation infrastructure for young people in regional areas” (40.2%) as the most urgent priority. This was followed by “stronger incentives for workplace adjustment support” (29.5%) and “preferential tax treatment and asset-building support for young people working in regional areas” (25.1%).
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Yoo Ilho, head of the Employment and Labor Team at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry, said, “Companies should take the lead in offering compensation commensurate with performance, building a workplace culture based on communication, providing accurate job descriptions, and investing in training for new hires.” He added, “The government should also improve its support programs and procedures so that SMEs with limited resources can use them easily, and strengthen incentives that help employees adjust to the workplace and stay longer.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.