Applied actual transaction price in the KRW 700 million range instead of officially assessed value in the KRW 400 million range
Court: "A transaction six months earlier can also be recognized as market value"
"The area and officially assessed value were the same, and price changes were minimal"

A court has ruled that even if someone paid gift tax based on an apartment's officially assessed value after receiving it as a gift from a parent, additional tax may be imposed based on the actual transaction price of a similar apartment in the same complex.


According to legal circles on November 22, the Seoul Administrative Court's Administrative Division 6, presided over by Judge Na Jini, ruled against A, who had filed a lawsuit seeking to revoke a gift tax assessment against the head of the Gwanak Tax Office. The court said, "The comparable apartment was similar in terms of area and officially assessed value, and prices had not changed significantly between the transaction date and the date of the gift."


Seoul Administrative Court. The Asia Business Daily DB

Seoul Administrative Court. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

A had received an apartment in Gwanak-gu, Seoul, as a gift from his father in May 2022. He reported and paid KRW 63.05 million in gift tax based on the apartment's officially assessed value of KRW 425 million in 2021. However, tax authorities found that an apartment in another building in the same complex had sold for KRW 730 million in October 2021. After review by an assessment review committee, they recognized that transaction price as the market value of the gifted apartment and reassessed the gift tax in June 2023, issuing a notice demanding approximately KRW 78.56 million. A filed a lawsuit, arguing that the comparable apartment's transaction had taken place more than six months before the gift and that the buildings and floors differed, so its price could not be used to determine market value.


At trial, A argued that prices had changed between the transaction date of the comparable apartment and the date of the gift. The court rejected the argument. It found that, under the relevant enforcement decree, a transaction within two years before the date of the gift could also be recognized as the market value after review by an assessment review committee. The two apartments had the same exclusive area of 83.21 square meters and the same officially assessed value of KRW 462 million at the time of the gift, meeting the requirements for comparable property.



The court also found that prices had not changed significantly. According to the Korea Real Estate Board, the apartment sale price index for Gwanak-gu was effectively unchanged, at 104.88 in October 2021 and 104.87 in May 2022. The court also considered the fact that another apartment with the same building, floor, and area as the gifted apartment had sold for KRW 730 million. Regarding A's claim that apartment prices fell in 2022 and 2023, the court said, "Price changes that occurred after the date of the gift do not affect the determination of market value in this case."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing