Accounted for Half of Global Channel Removals in Q3
Indonesian Government Demands Disclosure of Removal Criteria

The Indonesian government has pushed back after Google removed more than 19,000 YouTube channels that supported it, demanding that the company disclose specific evidence.


Visitors tour a preview exhibition marking YouTube's 15th anniversary. Yonhap News

Visitors tour a preview exhibition marking YouTube's 15th anniversary. Yonhap News

View original image

According to Bloomberg and other outlets on Nov. 21 local time, Google shut down 19,372 YouTube channels in Indonesia in the third quarter of this year, judging that they were involved in “coordinated influence operations.”


That accounted for about half of the channels removed worldwide for the same reason during the period. Indonesia had the highest number of channel removals, surpassing China and Russia. The total also rose sharply from 3,598 in the first quarter and 437 in the second quarter.


The closed channels mainly posted content supporting Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto and his government. Among the 10,134 channels removed in August, some were found to have posted content criticizing groups critical of the government. Google, however, did not disclose specific criteria for its removal decisions, who operated or funded the channels, or whether they had any direct connection to the Indonesian government.


In response, Indonesia’s Ministry of Communication and Digital Affairs called on Google to explain its removal criteria and review process in writing. The authorities said Google’s announcement could cause misunderstandings without a sufficient explanation.



In Indonesia, removals of pro-government YouTube channels surged after large-scale anti-government protests in August last year. According to Google, about 99% of the 27,516 Indonesia-related channels removed over the past five years were shut down after September last year. Local experts have suggested that the large-scale removals may have resulted from the organized mass production of channels rather than voluntary expressions of support.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing