Uniform Cost Cuts to Match Market Prices Are Not Permitted

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that whether the sale prices of apartments subject to the price ceiling system were inflated should be assessed based on the total amount, rather than by examining each item individually.


According to legal circles on November 23, the Supreme Court’s Second Division, presided over by Justice Oh Kyungmi, recently upheld an appellate ruling that partially favored the plaintiffs in the final appeal of a lawsuit filed by buyers of units in Apartment A in Dasan New Town, Namyangju, Gyeonggi Province, seeking the return of unjust enrichment from Company B, the developer.


Apartment A was subject to the price ceiling system. In 2016, the Namyangju City Sale Price Review Committee set the price ceiling at approximately 525.1 billion won. During the process, it fully approved the approximately 10.3 billion won surcharge for the structural type requested by Company B, while uniformly reducing some other surcharge items.


The buyers filed suit, arguing that the sale prices had been inflated by adding a surcharge even though the apartment did not qualify for a structural-type surcharge. Company B countered that the amounts improperly cut by the committee should also be taken into account.


The first trial ruled in favor of the buyers and ordered the return of approximately 10.3 billion won. The appeals court found that the committee had uniformly cut costs to meet a pre-set ceiling without conducting specific verification. Accordingly, it ruled that the sale contracts were invalid only to the extent of approximately 4.6 billion won, after deducting the amount that had been undercounted.


The issue was whether to examine only the items calculated in excess or to assess the total amount. The Supreme Court held that the total amount should be considered. It said the appeals court was wrong to recognize the contracts as invalid simply by isolating the inflated items, but that its conclusion was justified because the result after deducting the undercounted amount was the same as the result of calculating the total.



The court said of the amounts for each item, “A violation of the price ceiling system occurs, rendering only the excess portion invalid, when the total sale price obtained by adding them together exceeds the legitimate total price ceiling.” It added, “The arbitrary and uniform reduction of the relevant costs to meet a price ceiling set in advance, taking into account market prices for comparable nearby housing, should be deemed impermissible.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing