UCCK Pulls the "Public Square Rally" Card over Park Joomin's Equality Bill... 38 Denominations to Respond Jointly
Officially announces collective action nine days after Park Joomin introduces Equality Bill
Joint declaration by 38 denominations: "If our demands are ignored, we will gather outside the National Assembly and in public squares"
Criminal penalties removed, but dispute continues over corrective orders and noncompliance levies
Legislative conflict widens to include measures against collusion between religion and politics and amendments to the Private School Act
Representatives of denominations affiliated with the United Christian Churches of Korea pose for a commemorative photo after announcing the “Declaration of Korean Churches Against Legislation Threatening Religious Freedom” at an executive meeting held at the Korea Christian Center in Jongno-gu, Seoul, on the 20th. The group said it would oppose religion-related legislation, including Rep. Park Jumin’s Equality Act bill, and announced a joint response involving 38 denominations and 65,000 churches nationwide. United Christian Churches of Korea
View original imageOn November 20, Protestant leaders gathered at the Korea Christian Center in Jongno-gu, Seoul, and issued a warning to the government and the National Assembly. They declared that they would shift their opposition to legislation, which they had so far pursued through statements and petitions, to collective action by churches nationwide. The immediate trigger was the "Bill on Equality," sponsored on November 11 by Rep. Park Joomin of the Democratic Party of Korea. The bill's legislative aim of strengthening effective remedies for victims of discrimination is in direct conflict with churches' concerns that it could restrict freedom of religion, conscience, and expression.
The United Christian Churches of Korea (UCCK) held its 9th-7th standing vice presidents' meeting and 9th-2nd executive meeting that day and adopted the "Korean Church Declaration on Legislation Threatening Religious Freedom." The UCCK said it would pool the resources of its 38 member denominations and 65,000 churches nationwide to jointly respond to the legislation.
In its declaration, the UCCK said, "Having already made the Korean church's position sufficiently clear, we will no longer limit ourselves to issuing statements and position papers. Instead, we will take action together with 65,000 churches nationwide." It went on to warn that churches across the country would gather in front of the National Assembly and in public squares if the government and the Assembly ignored their demands.
The bill the UCCK has criticized most strongly is the Equality Bill sponsored by Rep. Park. It would prohibit discrimination without reasonable grounds in employment, education, the provision of goods and services, administrative services, and other areas on the basis of sex, disability, age, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, and other characteristics. The bill aims to extend the system for providing remedies to victims of discrimination to areas not covered by existing individual laws.
The bill differs from the Equality Bill that Rep. Park introduced in the 21st National Assembly in how it imposes sanctions. It excludes criminal penalties and punitive damages, focusing instead on remedies for victims and corrective procedures. Victims of discrimination may file complaints with the National Human Rights Commission of Korea, which can issue corrective orders if its recommendations are not followed without justifiable reason. If a corrective order is also ignored, the commission may impose a noncompliance levy. The bill also sets out civil liability for damages caused by discrimination.
When he introduced the bill, Rep. Park explained, "The Equality Bill is not a law intended to punish people. It is a law that establishes procedures for citizens who have experienced discrimination to seek redress." In response to concerns from religious groups, he stressed that the bill contains no provision regulating sermons from the pulpit and that no one would go to prison because of it.
The UCCK takes a different view. It argues that religious activities expressing faith could be restricted because corrective orders, noncompliance levies, and civil damages remain in the bill, even though criminal penalties and punitive damages have been removed. The key issue is how far church sermons, religious education, and the operations of institutions based on Christian values could be deemed discriminatory.
The UCCK maintains that removing the criminal penalty provisions alone has not resolved concerns over freedom of religion, conscience, and expression. Its declaration emphasized, "The Korean church respects the value of equality, but the freedom of religion and the autonomy of the church guaranteed by the Constitution must also be respected in the process of realizing it."
The difference between the two sides is most apparent not in the values the Equality Bill seeks to uphold, but in their interpretations of the bill's scope and remedies. The bill prohibits discrimination without reasonable grounds while providing exceptions for cases in which it is unavoidable due to the nature of a job or business. Supporters of the legislation argue that a minimum institutional framework is needed to provide remedies for victims of discrimination, while the UCCK insists that religious beliefs and the autonomy of religious communities must be adequately protected.
Jeon Gyuchan, co-chair of the Citizens' Coalition for Media Reform, calls for the passage of the Anti-Discrimination Act during the April extraordinary session of the National Assembly at a press conference held by press and media organizations in front of the National Assembly on the morning of the 25th. Yonhap News.
View original imageThe current conflict is part of a legislative debate over an anti-discrimination law that has continued for nearly two decades. The National Human Rights Commission of Korea recommended enacting a comprehensive anti-discrimination law in 2006. Several legislative attempts followed the government's announcement of a bill the next year, but none passed the National Assembly. This year, in the 22nd National Assembly, related bills have been introduced by Rep. Son Sol of the Progressive Party, Rep. Jung Chunsaeng of the Rebuilding Korea Party, and Rep. Park of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea.
Civil society groups calling for the law's enactment are also mobilizing. The Solidarity for Enactment of the Anti-Discrimination Law, which includes 174 organizations, welcomed Rep. Park's bill and urged the National Assembly to discuss it without delay. There are also differing voices within Protestantism. A representative of the Christian Network for an Equal World Without Discrimination and Hate, who attended a press conference on the Equality Bill on November 11, stressed that opposition from some Christian groups does not represent the position of all Christians.
The legislation the UCCK opposes is not limited to the Equality Bill. It has also identified as targets for its response amendments to the Civil Act aimed at preventing collusion between religion and politics, amendments to the Private School Act that could affect the autonomy of Christian schools, and enforcement decrees under the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act and the Corporate Tax Act related to overseas missionary activities.
The proposed Civil Act amendments concerning the prevention of collusion between religion and politics have also prompted broad concern within Protestant circles. Sponsored by Rep. Choi Hyukjin, the amendments specify violations of the principle of separation of church and state, among other grounds, as reasons to revoke authorization to establish a nonprofit corporation, and strengthen the investigative authority of the relevant government agencies.
The UCCK also issued a statement opposing the bill in February this year. At the time, it said that while it supported strict enforcement of the law against illegal acts by religious groups such as the Unification Church and Shincheonji, caution was needed about measures that would restrict the autonomy of religious groups as a whole.
The National Council of Churches in Korea (NCCK) also said that month that it shared the concerns behind the bill, but that the possibility of arbitrary exercise of authority by administrative agencies and infringement on the autonomy of religious corporations needed to be examined. The issue involves both calls to regulate religious groups' involvement in politics and concerns about excessive state intervention in religious affairs.
Developments within the UCCK have also drawn attention. The heads of the General Assembly of Presbyterian Church of Korea (Hapdong) and the General Assembly of Presbyterian Church of Korea (Tonghap), which had recently clashed over the selection of candidates for the next representative chair, both signed the declaration. On November 18, the two denominations expressed regret over the candidate selection process and announced that they would respond jointly. The denominations, which had differed over the operation of their umbrella organization, joined a joint declaration on legislation concerning religion.
The declaration is significant because it marks a new phase in the UCCK's campaign against the legislation, which has continued since early this year. In February, it called for the relevant bills to be reconsidered and for freedom of religion to be guaranteed. This time, it formally raised the prospect of an organized response by churches nationwide and street rallies.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
At the end of its declaration, the UCCK said, "It is now the government's and the National Assembly's turn to respond," adding, "The Korean church will respect the dignity of all people and fulfill its responsibility to love its neighbors. But we will not back down from defending religious freedom and the autonomy of the church."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.