'Maximum Drawdowns' Vary by Product
Underlying Assets, Interest Rates, and Exchange Rates Are Key Factors
"Assess Risks and Consider Investment Goals"}

Even bond-mixed and bond exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which are considered safe-asset products, have shown wide differences in losses across products during sharp market corrections like this year’s. An industry expert advised investors to look beyond the label “safe asset,” examine factors such as underlying assets and exchange rates, and invest accordingly.


According to Samsung Securities, bond-mixed ETFs showed varying degrees of resilience depending on their equity holdings from the end of June through this month. An analysis of maximum drawdowns (MDDs) from peak levels found that mixed ETFs tracking the KOSPI 200 had an MDD of -19.6%, about half the KOSPI’s -35.5%. Other index-based mixed ETFs also tended to track the declines of their underlying indexes to some extent.


Bought It as a “Safe-Asset” ETF, but Even Bond ETFs Differ by More Than 20%? View original image

By contrast, mixed ETFs holding a small number of stocks, which have been launched steadily since the first half of this year, showed wide performance disparities across products. For example, an ETF allocating 25% each to Samsung Electronics and SK hynix and 50% to bonds recorded an MDD of -24.9%. Its decline was greater than that of index-based products and substantially larger than those of domestic single-stock (-13.4%) and U.S. single-stock (-5.0%) mixed ETFs over the same period.


Bond ETFs that hold only bonds also saw varying losses depending on interest-rate, credit, and currency risks. From the beginning of this year through early this month, the MDDs of ETFs holding Korean Treasury bonds were -1.6% for three-year bonds, -6.5% for 10-year bonds, and -22.9% for 30-year bonds, with longer-duration bonds suffering larger declines. This is because bond prices move in the opposite direction to market interest rates, so the longer the duration, the greater the valuation losses when rates rise. Long-term bond ETFs can provide meaningful protection during a stock-market correction if accompanied by falling interest rates, but they can instead amplify volatility during periods of inflation and rising rates.


Exchange rates affected U.S. Treasury ETFs. The MDD for short-term bonds, which have shorter durations, was -14.2%, a much wider gap from the -0.1% for domestic short-term bonds. “Given the low interest-rate sensitivity of short-term bonds, this difference can be attributed to currency factors,” said Han Sujin, a researcher at Samsung Securities. “Even if the price of a foreign-currency-denominated bond rises, a stronger won against that currency can result in foreign-exchange losses when the bond is converted into won. When the won weakens, foreign-exchange gains can offset some of the losses from falling bond prices.”



Ultimately, even when choosing safe-asset ETFs to cushion losses in risky assets, investors need to understand and make use of each product’s characteristics. “Changes in earnings expectations for a particular industry can widen performance gaps among mixed-asset ETFs depending on their equity holdings, while interest-rate fluctuations directly affect the prices and returns of bond ETFs,” the researcher said. “Even when selecting safe-asset ETFs, investors should first distinguish the risks inherent in the underlying assets rather than relying on product names or regulatory classifications, and should adopt a strategy of combining products to suit their investment objectives and life stage.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing