More Than 10 Million Women in Over 250 Cities Worldwide
Share Information on Men, Including Infidelity and History of Violence
Community Moves Toward Shutdown Amid Controversy Over Privacy Violations and False Information

A popular U.S. online community where women can post photos of their boyfriends or dates and ask other women about possible infidelity and their past behavior is moving toward a shutdown. It began as a space for women to share information to keep one another safe, but amid growing controversy over privacy violations and the spread of false claims, it has stopped accepting new posts.

AI-generated image to help readers understand the article; not related to any specific content. ChatGPT

AI-generated image to help readers understand the article; not related to any specific content. ChatGPT

View original image

Post a Boyfriend's Photo to Check for Cheating... 10 Million Women Join

According to the New York Post on November 14, the women-only Facebook community "Are We Dating the Same Guy?" decided to stop accepting new posts after about four and a half years.


The community was first established in New York in 2022 and grew into a large network with more than 10 million women participating in over 250 cities worldwide. Women posted photos of their boyfriends or dates and asked other members whether the men were dating other women at the same time or had ever behaved violently.

Are We Dating The Same Guy group page. All current posts are private, and you can subscribe for $5 a month. Patreon.com

Are We Dating The Same Guy group page. All current posts are private, and you can subscribe for $5 a month. Patreon.com

View original image

The community was created in response to the so-called "West Elm Caleb" incident, which made headlines in New York in 2022. At the time, several women shared that they had each dated the same furniture designer before he abruptly stopped contacting them, sparking online controversy. Similar cases followed, including one in which a married man was found to have dated multiple women, increasing the need among women to share information.

"My Boyfriend Was Dating 12 Women at Once"... Helped With Criminal Investigations

There were also a number of cases in which women discovered their boyfriends were cheating through the community. In 2023, Mikala Mizianowski, who lives in Florida, drew attention after posting a video on social media when she found evidence that her boyfriend was seeing another woman. The video showed her sitting on the couch drinking wine while her boyfriend did the dishes. At the time, he did not know that she had discovered evidence of his infidelity, and the video received millions of views.

The dating information community describes itself as “a space where women protect, support, and empower one another.” According to its website, more than 150 crimes, including romance scams, have been reported through the community to date. Screenshot of the AWDTSG website.

The dating information community describes itself as “a space where women protect, support, and empower one another.” According to its website, more than 150 crimes, including romance scams, have been reported through the community to date. Screenshot of the AWDTSG website.

View original image

Writer and chef Alyssa Fitzgerald also discovered through the community that a Welsh information technology (IT) worker she had gone on two dates with, after he said he wanted a serious relationship, had been seeing other women. A post had said that the man was dating at least 12 other women at the same time.


Chris, a 35-year-old woman living in New York, also learned that her ex-boyfriend had been involved in inappropriate relationships with at least seven other women while they were together. She even became friends with one of the women who had dated the same man. "For the first time, I felt that I wasn't the only one who had suffered the emotional pain he caused me," Chris said.


The community served not only to share information about infidelity but also to alert people to criminal victimization. In Oregon, information shared by members helped police with an investigation. Nicholas Michael Donahue, 47, pleaded guilty to charges of coercion and assault related to domestic violence. On November 4, he was sentenced to 70 days in prison and three years of probation. The community also claimed that tips from members helped expose crimes by U.S. Army Major Jonathan Batt, who was charged with sexually assaulting and assaulting multiple women. Batt was sentenced to 53 years in prison in 2025.

Controversy Over Privacy Violations and False Claims... New Posts Halted

However, as the community grew, backlash from men intensified. There were repeated claims of privacy violations and defamation, with men saying their photos and names had been posted without their consent or false information had been shared about them. In 2024, Nico D'Ambrosio, who lives in Chicago, sued community founder Paola Sanchez, Facebook operator Meta, and dozens of members after a post described him as excessively obsessive. The lawsuit was dismissed in 2025, and he also lost his appeal in May 2026.


Some women said they received threatening messages after posting information about men in the community. Fitzgerald said that after a screenshot of a post about a man was leaked outside the community, the man accused her of disclosing his personal information, and she subsequently received several threatening messages.


Some members also acknowledged the community's harmful effects. Member Jenny Sena pointed out that women who had been hurt in past relationships might post about someone to get revenge, and that it was difficult to objectively verify the facts.



Amid the controversy, founder Sanchez recently announced that the community would be shut down. On October 29, administrator Coraline Lotz said in an announcement that existing posts would remain searchable and members could continue commenting, but no new posts would be accepted. She explained that the move was intended to preserve the information already collected, as some groups had been deleted following reports from men.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing