Accused of manipulating SM's share price to block HYBE's tender offer
"Unfair to punish open-market purchases solely for affecting the stock price"

Kim Beom-su, Kakao founder suspected of conspiring to manipulate SM Entertainment's stock price, speaks to reporters as he leaves the Seoul Southern District Court in Yangcheon-gu, Seoul, on Oct. 21 last year after being acquitted at his first-trial sentencing hearing. Yonhap News.

Kim Beom-su, Kakao founder suspected of conspiring to manipulate SM Entertainment's stock price, speaks to reporters as he leaves the Seoul Southern District Court in Yangcheon-gu, Seoul, on Oct. 21 last year after being acquitted at his first-trial sentencing hearing. Yonhap News.

View original image

Kim Beom-su, Kakao founder and head of its Future Initiative Center, was acquitted again on appeal of charges that he manipulated SM Entertainment's stock price during Kakao's acquisition of the company. The court ruled that buying shares to counter a rival company's tender offer does not constitute market manipulation simply because it affected the stock price.


The Seoul High Court's Criminal Division 4-1, presided over by Judges Kim In-kyung, Seong Ji-yong and Jeon Ji-won, dismissed the prosecution's appeal on the 20th in the appellate sentencing hearing for Kim and former Kakao investment chief Bae Jae-hyun, who were indicted on charges of violating the Capital Markets Act.


The key issue was whether Kakao's share purchases were made with the aim of fixing the stock price, which is prohibited under the Capital Markets Act. Prosecutors argued that Kim and others conspired to buy shares to keep the price above HYBE's tender offer price of 120,000 won and thwart its tender offer for SM Entertainment.


The panel said the provision must be interpreted strictly. All securities-market transactions can affect market prices, it said, and punishing people based solely on their intent without considering how the trades were made would result in such an outcome. It also noted that buying shares on the open market to secure a friendly stake during a hostile merger and acquisition (M&A) is a common way to defend management control, and that punishing all such purchases would make the scope of criminal liability unlimited.


Applying this standard, the panel found it difficult to conclude that Kakao had placed high-priced buy orders or otherwise acted to artificially prop up the stock price. It also said the prosecution's evidence alone did not prove either an intent to fix the market price or a conspiracy.


Kim was indicted and detained in August 2024 on charges of manipulating the market in February 2023 to derail HYBE's tender offer. Prosecutors sought a 15-year prison sentence at the final hearing in September.



Meanwhile, the court also dismissed the appeals by Ji Chang-bae, CEO of One Asia Partners, and the prosecution. Ji had been indicted alongside the others and was sentenced at trial to three years in prison, suspended for four years, for embezzlement under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing