[Friendly Predators] 2: The Myth of the Invincible Pop-Up Sales Outlet... 'Shut Down' When Raided, Get a 'Suspended Sentence' When Caught
Even Elderly Victims Avoid Reporting to Save Face
Unmarked, Closed-Off Operations Hamper Crackdowns
Even After Pocketing Hundreds of Millions of Won, 85% Receive Suspended Sentences or Fines
A "tteottabang" near a traditional market in Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul. When we visited on the 15th of last month, it was luring seniors with free daily necessities worth 70,000 won.
"Do you know what day October 25 is? It's the day pensions are paid. Just pay a small amount 10 times. That's 48,000 won each time. You don't need a contract. Just write down your name and phone number."
On the 15th of last month, an employee of a tteottabang was attracting customers at the entrance to a traditional market in Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul, with free daily necessities worth 70,000 won. Photo by Park Jaehyun
View original imageThe staff member handing out free gifts soon ushered the seniors into an area screened off by a tent. With more than 30 people packed tightly together, the staff member stoked fears about their health, saying, "We live in a world where even CEOs of large corporations collapse from cerebral infarctions." The staff member went on to claim, "If you take concentrated pine needle extract for six months, blocked blood vessels will be cleared, preventing strokes, dementia and cerebral hemorrhages." After being told that customers would get an extra product worth 480,000 won during the promotional period, several seniors wrote their names and contact information on a piece of paper.
A tteodabang near a traditional market in Seoul’s Dongdaemun-gu last month. After drawing a crowd by handing out free gifts, a staff member ushered attendees into an area screened off by a tent. The staff member then gave a 40-minute presentation promoting health supplements.
Photo by Park Jaehyeon
Tteottabangs have survived for decades, changing only their form, because their operators skillfully exploit the psychological vulnerabilities of older people. Using free gifts and a friendly manner to lower their guard, operators then play on feelings of obligation ("I got a free gift, so I should buy something"), fear about their health and a desire to keep up with their peers to get them to open their wallets.
Seniors stay silent for fear of shame and exclusion... Only 14.9% seek redress for their losses
A "structure of silence," in which harm is not easily brought to light even when it occurs, also helps these businesses endure. Seniors who have been victimized may keep quiet because they are ashamed to tell their children they were scammed, or hesitate to report staff members who had usually treated them kindly. Some even accept their losses out of concern that they might be excluded from the only place they go out to socialize.
According to the Korea Consumer Agency, a total of 2,134 consultations related to promotional showroom sales tactics were received by the 1372 Consumer Counseling Center from 2022 through October 2026. However, only 317 cases involved applications for redress, or 14.9% of the total. Among applications for redress, the most common issue was "contract termination and penalties," with 136 cases (42.9%), in which consumers canceled their contracts and sought refunds but were denied. Cases related to "withdrawal from purchase," including refusals to issue refunds when consumers simply changed their minds within the legally prescribed period, totaled 60 (18.9%).
Enforcement is also difficult. Most promotional showrooms operate without signs, in basements or on upper floors, and have closed-door setups that admit mainly people aged 70 and older, making it difficult to catch illegal activity on site.
A police official said, "Even when a 112 report comes in, it is often difficult to establish on the spot that a crime has occurred," adding, "In most cases, we identify the parties involved and begin an investigation after the victim files a complaint or accusation."
An official from a local government in Seoul also said, "Administrative measures may be considered if violations such as failure to file a business notification or failure to draw up a contract are confirmed." However, the official added, "It is difficult to impose meaningful sanctions unless actual harm is established, and if a business closes or disappears while we are verifying the damage, it is effectively impossible to take action."
Only 4 prison sentences among 26 rulings over the past 10 years... "Lenient punishments"
An analysis of 26 court rulings related to promotional showrooms targeting seniors over the 10 years from 2015 found that only 4 cases (15.4%) resulted in prison sentences. Of the remaining 22 cases, 9 (34.6%) resulted in fines and 13 (50.0%) in suspended prison sentences. Even when cases go to trial, the punishments tend to be light.
Kang Bongcheol, secretary-general of the Korea Senior Consumer Protection Solidarity, said, "Some tteottabangs operate for only five or six months at most before closing or moving to another area." He added, "Even after a complaint is filed, investigations take a considerable amount of time, and businesses often disappear before any action can be taken."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.