Government plans to apply rules starting with this year's CSAT
New rules to apply even to review results issued after law takes effect
Retroactive application could lead to lawsuits
AI record investigations clash with privacy protections
Criminal punishment requires proof of use at the exam venue

As cheating involving artificial intelligence (AI) increases, the government is moving to strengthen penalties, but legal disputes are emerging over retroactive application and the detection of violations after the fact. A plan to extend the ban on taking the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) to as long as 10 years raises questions about whether the penalties are proportionate. Investigations based on obtaining AI usage records also hinge on privacy protections and proving whether the AI was actually used.

Officials are controlling access at Yeouido Girls' High School in Seoul, where an exam center was set up for the 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT), as the entrance time passed on the 19th. 2026.11.19 Photo by Kim Hyunmin

Officials are controlling access at Yeouido Girls' High School in Seoul, where an exam center was set up for the 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT), as the entrance time passed on the 19th. 2026.11.19 Photo by Kim Hyunmin

View original image

According to legal circles on Nov. 20, the government announced on Nov. 17 that it would extend the ban on taking the CSAT for serious cheating involving smart devices from the current one year to as long as 10 years, and apply the change starting with this year's test. At the 2027 CSAT held the previous day, 98 people were caught cheating in connection with smart devices.


The first issue is whether tougher penalties can apply to conduct that took place before the law takes effect. An amendment to the Higher Education Act introduced on Nov. 18 would apply the new rules even to this year's CSAT cheaters who are notified of the results of their review after the law takes effect. Article 14 of the Framework Act on Administration stipulates that, in principle, penalties must be imposed under the laws in effect at the time of the violation. Critics say that even if a special provision is introduced, the legitimacy and proportionality of retroactive penalties must be considered separately. Another point of contention is whether extending the ban on taking the test to as long as 10 times its current duration would be excessive relative to the responsibility for the conduct.


Kim Seontaek, a professor at Korea University's School of Law, said, "The principle is that penalties should be based on the rules in effect when the conduct occurred. If the revised rules are applied retroactively based on when the person is notified of the review decision, there will be considerable grounds to challenge it in court." He added, "The severity of the penalty should also vary depending on the type and extent of the cheating. If everyone is barred from taking the test for 10 years, the measure could be challenged as violating the principle of proportionality."


Verifying that cheating took place is also a challenge in applying the tougher penalties. The government and ruling party are pursuing legislation that would require AI companies to submit records of questions and answers related to the exam. Under the Personal Information Protection Act, personal information may be provided for purposes other than those for which it was collected, subject to certain requirements, if there is a specific legal basis in another law. However, the scope of records companies must retain and the retention period still need to be determined.


Choi Jinhyeok, an attorney at Barun Law LLC, said, "A legal basis for submitting records can be established by setting out specific provisions in a separate law." However, he explained, "Users have the right to request the deletion of their personal information, so requiring all records to be retained across the board would be excessive. And identifying only test-takers would ultimately mean having to examine the conversations of ordinary users as well."


The threshold for proof is even higher if the case is to lead to actual criminal punishment, beyond administrative sanctions such as a ban on taking the test. Authorities must prove that the records obtained were used to cheat at the test venue. Police are investigating Mr. Han, the top-ranked candidate who confessed to cheating on the certified tax accountant exam, on suspicion of obstruction of official duties and business obstruction by deceit.



Im Changguk, an attorney at Won Law Firm and a former senior prosecutor, said, "A confession alone is not enough to establish guilt, so corroborating evidence such as records of equipment purchases and searches made in preparation for the crime is necessary." He added, "The success of the investigation will depend on how much objective evidence supporting the actual offense, such as the timing of AI queries or scores far above the person's usual performance, can be obtained through search and seizure."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing