[Reporter's Notebook] Controversial Han Ducksoo Ruling: Both Parties Put Their Own Spin on It View original image

Political circles are once again in turmoil over the Supreme Court’s ruling on former Prime Minister Han Ducksoo’s charge of performing key duties in an insurrection related to the December 3 emergency martial law. The Democratic Party of Korea has called the ruling a “justification of insurrection” and raised the possibility of impeaching the chief justice, while the People Power Party is jubilant, saying the court “dealt a blow to the insurrection witch hunt.” It is the same ruling, yet the reactions are diametrically opposed.


The ruling drew attention because it was the first to address whether the December 3 emergency martial law constituted an insurrection. The Supreme Court said, “There is no room for doubt that martial law itself was unconstitutional and illegal.” It found Han not guilty in connection with his actions before the declaration of martial law, but ruled that his actions afterward constituted participation in the insurrection.


Yet both the ruling and opposition parties appear to have focused only on the parts of the ruling they wanted to see. The Democratic Party, angered by the partial acquittal, has formally announced plans to impeach Chief Justice Cho Heedae. Its argument is that the ruling represents “a historic betrayal that justifies insurrection,” as Democratic Party leader Kim Minseok put it. It is setting aside the fact that the Supreme Court formally declared the martial law unconstitutional and illegal.


The Supreme Court’s decision to acquit Han over his recommendation to convene a Cabinet meeting gives pause. In addressing the government’s second-highest official acting in a bureaucratic manner, the court said it was “a legitimate official act requesting that procedures prescribed by law be followed.” This could be read as giving a “yes-man” a free pass.


Still, it is questionable whether impeachment is an appropriate response for political circles. A lack of a sense of historical responsibility does not, in itself, constitute specific grounds for impeachment. Accepting the judiciary’s decision is also part of the constitutional order the ruling party sought to uphold. And impeachment is not the only possible remedy, just as the prosecution—which once said that “a successful coup cannot be punished”—changed its position in response to public opinion.


The People Power Party is no different. Its initial response was that “the Supreme Court dealt a blow to the insurrection witch hunt.” It offered no comment or apology for the court’s clear finding that the martial law was unconstitutional and illegal, or for its ruling that Han had participated in the insurrection. It has also brushed aside calls within the party for an apology, saying, “That would only divide our supporters” and “We need to prepare for the future now.”



Ultimately, this is because both parties are focused only on their immediate political gains and losses, or on the mood among their hard-line supporters. A serious assessment of and reflection on the December 3 emergency martial law have all but lost their place. If things continue this way, whether through impeachment or evasion of an apology, conflict and division are inevitable. In light of the Supreme Court’s ruling, the ruling and opposition parties should focus on making a clear assessment of the December 3 emergency martial law and developing concrete measures to prevent a recurrence. It is now time for each side to read the other half of the ruling it would rather not see.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing