"Urging a Cabinet Meeting Before Emergency Martial Law Declaration
Insurrectionary Intent Difficult to Establish"
Other Guilty Verdicts, Including Participation in the Insurrection After the Declaration, Remain Unchanged
Justices Oh Kyungmi, Shin Sookhee and Kim Seongsu Issue Dissenting Opinion

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has vacated and remanded an appellate ruling that sentenced Han Duck-soo (77), a former prime minister indicted on charges of performing key duties in an insurrection related to the December 3 emergency martial law declaration. The court found that Han’s actions “after the martial law declaration” constituted performing key duties in an insurrection, but ruled that the charge concerning his role in creating the appearance of deliberation at a Cabinet meeting “before the declaration” should be acquitted.


The Supreme Court en banc, with Justice Oh Kyung-mi as the presiding justice, sent the case back to the Seoul High Court on Nov. 19 for reconsideration, overturning part of the lower court’s guilty verdict in an appeal involving charges including performing key duties in an insurrection. Han’s detention will continue, as his detention can be extended during the retrial after remand.


The Supreme Court ruled that Han could be considered to have participated in the insurrection by urging Cabinet members who attended a meeting after the martial law declaration to sign documents, and by discussing plans to blockade key institutions, including the National Assembly, and to cut off electricity and water to specific media outlets. However, it found that his actions before the declaration—urging then-President Yoon Suk Yeol to convene a Cabinet meeting and taking part in summoning Cabinet members—were insufficient to establish that he had performed key duties in the insurrection. The reason was that it was difficult to establish the insurrection’s required purpose of “subverting the constitutional order.”


The court upheld the guilty verdict on charges that, after the emergency martial law was lifted, Han signed a cover sheet for a martial law proclamation that Kang Eui-gu, then head of the presidential office’s protocol unit, had drafted after the fact to remedy legal flaws in the original proclamation, along with then-President Yoon and former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun, among others (creation of a false official document); and that Han later asked Kang to destroy it, out of concern that it could become controversial (violation of the Presidential Records Act and damage to public documents).


Justice Kwon Young-jun, who wrote the majority opinion, noted, “The lower court emphasized a series of actions by the defendant to check the Cabinet’s deliberation and treated them as grounds for finding that he intended to subvert the constitutional order.” He added, “A quorum is necessarily required to open a Cabinet meeting,” and said, “It is difficult to conclude that the defendant merely proposed deliberation at a Cabinet meeting to make it appear proper by formally meeting the quorum.”


Justice Kwon said, “Whether the Cabinet deliberated, or how the deliberations proceeded, could not have constrained the emergency martial law,” and noted, “Once a quorum was reached, Yoon immediately distributed the proclamation and spoke unilaterally before the other Cabinet members had arrived, then declared martial law.” The court found that the Cabinet meeting amounted to a mere formality because of Yoon’s unilateral declaration of martial law and the urgent circumstances at the time.


The majority opinion said, “Actions before and after the declaration of emergency martial law must be assessed separately,” and found that it was difficult to conclude that the prosecution had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Han intended to subvert the constitutional order before the declaration. It also stressed, “The fundamental principles of the Constitution and criminal law must not be relaxed on the grounds that a crime is serious.” However, it found that there was room to recognize such intent with regard to some actions taken after the declaration. The court also found no error in the lower court’s legal reasoning on the charges of creating a false official document and perjury.

Supreme Court overturns former PM Han Ducksoo's "15-year prison sentence"; detention to continue (Roundup) View original image

Justices Oh Kyung-mi, Shin Sook-hee and Kim Seong-su issued a dissenting opinion. They argued that Han had been sufficiently aware of the unconstitutionality and illegality of the emergency martial law, yet took part in the Cabinet deliberations, and that his intent to subvert the constitutional order could therefore be recognized. Justice Oh said, “Yoon’s declaration of martial law was seriously unconstitutional and illegal because it failed to meet substantive and procedural requirements and suspended the National Assembly’s powers by mobilizing the military and police.” She went on to characterize it as “an act of insurrection in the form of a so-called self-coup, in which an incumbent leader abuses constitutional powers to neutralize constitutional checks.”


Justice Oh also said, “The defendant was in a position to ensure that presidential powers were exercised lawfully,” and noted, “He foresaw the inevitable danger facing the Cabinet meeting, which would be reduced to a tool amid the desperate crisis of unconstitutional martial law, yet went ahead with it.” She added, “He did nothing to stop the martial law declaration, focused only on securing a quorum for the Cabinet meeting, and did nothing else.”


She also criticized the majority opinion as “reasoning that gives Han Duck-soo a pass.” She noted that, during the emergency martial law, citizens had defended the Constitution by standing in the way of soldiers with their bare bodies.



Following the Supreme Court’s decision to vacate and remand the case, the Seoul High Court will reconsider Han’s criminal liability for some of the charges that he performed key duties in an insurrection.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing