Supreme Court vacates and remands former PM Han Ducksoo's case
Guilty verdict for joining insurrection after martial law declaration upheld
Supreme Court divided over Han Ducksoo's "participation in insurrection"

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court overturned an appellate ruling sentencing former Prime Minister Han Ducksoo to 15 years in prison for allegedly performing a key role in the insurrection related to the illegal December 3 martial law declaration. The Court found it difficult to conclude that Han intended to commit insurrection when he recommended convening a State Council meeting before the declaration of martial law. However, it upheld the guilty verdicts for his actions in joining the insurrection after martial law was declared.


The Supreme Court en banc (with Justice Oh Kyungmi presiding) on November 19 at 4 p.m. overturned the guilty portions of the lower court ruling that sentenced Han to 15 years in prison and remanded the case. The decision came about one year and three months after the special counsel team led by Special Counsel Jo Eunseok, appointed to investigate insurrection and foreign-exchange-related crimes, indicted Han on August 29, 2025. Han did not attend court that day.


Han was put on trial on charges of knowing in advance about former President Yoon Sukyeol's plan to impose martial law but failing to fulfill his duty as deputy chair of the State Council to stop it, instead aiding or endorsing it. He was also charged with signing a proclamation document that had been falsely prepared to conceal procedural defects in the martial law declaration and then having it destroyed. He was additionally charged with perjury for testifying, at former President Yoon's impeachment trial before the Constitutional Court on February 20, 2025, that he had "never seen or received any documents related to martial law."


In January 2026, the first-trial court found most of the charges proven and sentenced Han to 23 years in prison, a heavier sentence than the 15 years sought by the special counsel team. In May, however, the appeals court reduced his sentence to 15 years, finding it difficult to hold him criminally responsible for failing to take any action.


The special counsel team argued that Han had performed a key role in the insurrection by failing to fulfill his duty to assist and check the president. The appeals court, however, found it difficult to establish liability for the offense of performing a key role in an insurrection based solely on an omission—failing to do something one is obligated to do.


Justices Oh Kyungmi, Shin Sookhee, and Kim Seongsoo dissented. Justice Oh said, "Yoon's declaration of martial law failed to meet substantive and procedural requirements, and its use of the military and police to suspend the National Assembly's powers made it gravely unconstitutional and illegal. It was an act of insurrection in the nature of what is known as a self-coup, in which an incumbent leader abuses constitutional powers to neutralize constitutional checks."



She continued, "The defendant was in a position to ensure that presidential powers were exercised lawfully. Even while foreseeing the inevitable danger posed by a State Council meeting that would become a mere instrument in the face of an unconstitutional martial law declaration, he went ahead with it. He did nothing to stop the declaration of martial law, focused only on meeting the quorum for the State Council, and did nothing else."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing