For candidates who took the second round of the 63rd Tax Accountant Examination

Class action against exam administrator HRD Korea

Seeking compensation for emotional distress over compromised exam fairness

As police investigate after Han, who ranked first in this year's tax accountant exam, turned himself in for cheating with artificial intelligence (AI), a major South Korean law firm has begun recruiting plaintiffs for a class-action lawsuit seeking damages from the agency responsible for administering and supervising this year's second-round tax accountant exam.


According to legal sources on November 19, YK Law Firm is accepting applications from candidates who took the 63rd Tax Accountant Examination's second round to join a class-action lawsuit seeking damages from the Human Resources Development Service of Korea (HRD Korea), the agency that administers the exam.


Han, the top scorer on this year's tax accountant exam who allegedly cheated using artificial intelligence (AI), appears at the Public Crimes Investigation Unit of the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency's Metropolitan Investigation Unit in Mapo-gu, Seoul, on the 17th as a suspect. Yonhap News

Han, the top scorer on this year's tax accountant exam who allegedly cheated using artificial intelligence (AI), appears at the Public Crimes Investigation Unit of the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency's Metropolitan Investigation Unit in Mapo-gu, Seoul, on the 17th as a suspect. Yonhap News

View original image

YK plans to seek compensation for the emotional distress candidates suffered as the fairness and credibility of the tax accountant exam were undermined. For those who failed, it will examine whether their opportunity to take and be evaluated on the exam under fair conditions was compromised. For those who passed, it will also consider whether they suffered harm because the controversy over cheating diminished the value of their legitimate efforts and achievements. Applications to join the group of plaintiffs can be submitted through YK's official website.


Han previously admitted to cheating in both the first and second rounds of the 63rd Tax Accountant Examination using a miniature camera, a smartphone and generative AI, and turned himself in. He said he took photos of the exam questions, sent them to generative AI and checked the answers on his smartphone.


YK considers whether HRD Korea provided adequate supervision and oversight as the alleged cheating continued into the second round to be a central issue in the lawsuit. As one basis for its case, the firm is focusing on the unusual scores and distribution of high scores in the first round.


Han scored 397.5 out of a possible 400 points in the first round. In particular, the average score on Introduction to Tax Law was 30.18 among 16,856 candidates, and 74.21% of candidates failed to meet the minimum score. Han was the only candidate to score 100.


The unusual figures were not limited to Han's individual score. The number of candidates who scored at least 90 in Introduction to Accounting in the first round rose to 66 this year from two last year. YK said these statistics do not in themselves indicate cheating, but it will examine whether the exam administrator should have conducted additional checks for irregularities.


HRD Korea said on November 13, after allegations of cheating emerged, that it had reviewed the exam's administration and grading but had found no specific evidence supporting the allegations or any unusual circumstances up to that point. The agency said at the time that it had found no irregularities related to cheating in either the proctors' reports or the computerized grading data for the first round.


However, controversy over whether HRD Korea provided adequate supervision and oversight grew after Han later admitted to actually cheating in both rounds. Two proctors were assigned to the exam room where Han took the test, but the cheating was not detected during the exam.


After confirming the cheating, HRD Korea filed a criminal complaint against Han on suspicion of obstructing business and began procedures to invalidate his exam and suspend his eligibility to take the test. The agency is also working to review cheating involving AI across national qualification exams and improve its exam management system.


Exterior view of Law Firm YK’s main office in Gangnam. Law Firm YK

Exterior view of Law Firm YK’s main office in Gangnam. Law Firm YK

View original image

YK plans to examine whether HRD Korea conducted sufficient checks and took appropriate action in response to the warning signs in the first round. Since the cheating also went undetected in the second round, the firm will ask the court to determine what level of supervision and oversight is required of the agency administering the exam.


For the second-round tax accountant exam, if the number of candidates who meet the qualifying standard falls short of the minimum number of successful candidates, those who do not fail to meet the minimum score are ranked by score, and the highest scorers pass. YK will also examine how Han's cheating affected the rankings and pass-or-fail outcomes of other candidates.


The lawsuit is not aimed solely at obtaining monetary compensation. YK says it is necessary to bring public attention to the scope of supervision and oversight required to prevent cheating involving new technologies such as AI in national qualification exams.


Hyun Minseok, the YK lawyer who will represent the plaintiffs in the lawsuit, said, "In this case, we need to examine not only whether the cheating methods using new technology could have been anticipated in advance, but also whether the agency responsible for managing the exam appropriately checked for and responded to warning signs during the exam."



He added, "I hope this lawsuit will help clarify the legal standards for the level of supervision and oversight required of agencies administering national qualification exams," and said, "I also hope it will serve as an opportunity to establish clearer management standards for responding to new forms of cheating involving AI."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing