Korea's Unique Auditor Designation System... Did It Improve Audit Quality?
At a World Congress of Accountants session
"Auditor designation system significantly improves audit quality"
However, effects diminish after the designation period, raising questions about sustainability
A study has found that the periodic auditor designation system, under which financial authorities periodically appoint auditors for companies, significantly improved audit quality. However, it also found that the improvements were not sustained, with the effect diminishing after the designation period ended.
On the afternoon of November 19, Seoul National University Professor Baek Bokhyun presented his research on “The Impact of the Periodic Auditor Designation System on Audit Quality” during a session titled “When Regulators Appoint Auditors: Lessons from Korea’s Bold Reform” at the World Congress of Accountants (WCOA), held at the Grand InterContinental Seoul Parnas in Gangnam, Seoul.
After the Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering accounting fraud scandal in the 2010s, South Korea ranked near the bottom among 63 countries in an accounting transparency assessment by the International Institute for Management Development in Switzerland in 2017. In response, financial authorities introduced the “6+3” periodic auditor designation system as part of accounting reform. Under the conventional mandatory auditor rotation system used overseas, a company selects its auditor but must replace only the partner in charge. By contrast, under South Korea’s designation system, a company freely selects its auditor for six years, after which the Financial Supervisory Service directly appoints the entire audit firm for three years.
Seoul National University Professor Baek Bokhyun presents on “The Impact of the Periodic Auditor Designation System on Audit Quality” at the World Congress of Accountants (WCOA), held at Grand InterContinental Seoul Parnas in Gangnam, Seoul, on the afternoon of the 19th. Photo by Oh Gyumin.
View original imageAccording to Professor Baek, the auditor designation system significantly improved audit quality. Companies subject to designation saw clear increases in the frequency and magnitude of audit adjustments compared with a control group of companies that freely selected their auditors. An audit adjustment refers to a change made when a company undergoing an audit by a designated auditor and the auditor disagree. Specifically, audit adjustments increased by about 10% in the year before designation and by about 4.4% in the first year of designation. Conservative adjustments that reduced earnings also rose significantly, increasing by 5.8% in the year before designation and by 3.8% in the first year.
The strongest effect was seen when an existing auditor outside the Big Four (Samil PwC, Samjong KPMG, EY Hanyoung, and Deloitte Anjin) was replaced by a Big Four firm: material audit adjustments surged by more than 24%. By account category, the likelihood of adjustments to property, plant and equipment—where management’s accounting judgment plays a major role—increased by about 54%. Among profit-and-loss items, upward and downward adjustments were more pronounced for expense accounts, such as cost of sales, than for revenue. The stricter reviews by newly designated auditors also increased the frequency of financial statement restatements by about 2%.
Professor Baek said, however, that the improvement in audit quality under the periodic designation system tended to weaken as the non-audit fees auditors received from their audit clients increased. He also emphasized that an analysis of companies that returned to freely selecting their auditors after the three-year designation period found that the improvement in audit quality seen during the designation period disappeared.
From left, Seoul National University Professor Baek Bokhyeon, Korea University Professor Jung Seokwoo, IE University Professor Marco Trombetta, and Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) Director Nawid Lallani take part in a panel discussion at the World Congress of Accountants (WCOA), held at the Grand InterContinental Seoul Parnas in Gangnam, Seoul, on the afternoon of the 19th. Photo by Oh Gyumin
View original imageOverseas studies have likewise found that audit quality improves only temporarily just before and after mandatory auditor rotation, with the effect subsequently diluted. “Korea’s system is an internationally distinctive regulatory framework and a hybrid model combining a period of private-sector selection with a period of appointment by the regulator,” said Marco Trombetta, a professor at IE University. “My research similarly finds that the effect of mandatory rotation is temporary, concentrated just before rotation and fading afterward, a pattern that resembles what is seen in Korea.” He said future research should examine why the improvement in quality disappears after the designation period ends and whether the improvement stems from greater independence or from increased mutual checks between outgoing and incoming auditors and greater audit effort.
Overseas supervisory authorities, meanwhile, take the view that regulators should be cautious about directly appointing auditors. Asked whether regulators should also be held responsible if an auditor they appoint fails to conduct an audit properly, Naveed Lalani, a director at the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA), said, “It is precisely because of the issue of responsibility that regulators should not appoint auditors directly.” He added, “It is preferable for companies and auditors to assess each other’s capabilities and internal controls before entering into a contract, while regulators retain the authority to supervise and intervene before, during, and after an audit.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Another issue raised was that audit fees fall when companies switch from mandatory designation back to freely selecting their auditors. “This is based on an analysis of the 2023 sample only,” Professor Baek said, “but we observed that audit fees tended to fall again for companies that returned to freely selecting their auditors.” He expressed concern that renewed competition to lower audit fees following the switch back to free selection could weaken auditor independence and, as a result, reduce audit hours and effort.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.