Oil reserve swaps and shipping-cost support prove effective
Petroleum price cap masked the crisis
Naphtha also needs to be designated a strategic security item
"We must break the 'support for big businesses equals favoritism' frame"

Experts gathered to assess the state of South Korea’s energy security in the wake of the Middle East war and explore sustainable energy strategies.


At a roundtable hosted by The Asia Business Daily on the 20th of this month under the theme “In the Era of the Energy Transition, How Can We Safeguard Energy Sovereignty and Economic Growth?”, participants held in-depth discussions. They included Yoo Seunghoon, professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Kim Jinsu, professor in the Department of Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Han Byeonghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; An Gukheon, head of sustainability management at the Korea Petroleum Association; and Kim Jaehun, head of external relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association.


The experts viewed positively the fact that the government had weathered supply-and-demand challenges without major disruption by implementing measures such as diversifying crude oil import sources, swapping oil reserves, and providing compensation for the price gap on naphtha imports. However, they also criticized the confusion caused by the division of energy policymaking between the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy and the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment. They said that by focusing solely on short-term defenses, such as a price cap on petroleum products, the government had missed a golden opportunity to fundamentally improve the country’s industrial structure as it faced the era of carbon neutrality and the energy transition.


They agreed that the government should pursue effective policies, including procedures for responding to energy crises, expanding the range of designated strategic security resources, and production tax credits, while also supporting companies investing in facilities for the energy transition. They said a range of measures would be needed.


The main points from the roundtable will be published in two installments.


Before a roundtable on energy sovereignty held at The Asia Business Daily headquarters, the participating experts posed for a group photo. From left: Kim Jinsu, professor in the Department of Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Ahn Gukheon, director of the Sustainability Management Office at the Korea Petroleum Association; Yoo Seunghun, professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Han Byeonghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; and Kim Jaehun, head of External Relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Photo by Heo Younghan

Before a roundtable on energy sovereignty held at The Asia Business Daily headquarters, the participating experts posed for a group photo. From left: Kim Jinsu, professor in the Department of Resources and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University; Ahn Gukheon, director of the Sustainability Management Office at the Korea Petroleum Association; Yoo Seunghun, professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology; Han Byeonghwa, director at Eugene Investment & Securities; and Kim Jaehun, head of External Relations at the Korea Chemical Industry Association. Photo by Heo Younghan

View original image


-How should the government’s response to energy supply and demand since the Middle East war be assessed?


▲An Gukheon, head of sustainability management= The government’s response to the crude oil supply crisis was generally effective and appropriate. It implemented measures that were effective in the medium to long term or necessary in the short term, including diversifying crude oil import sources, international joint stockpiling, and oil reserve swaps. The system to support the diversification of crude oil import sources was introduced in 1982. Initially, the government directly covered the difference in transportation costs when crude oil was imported from Europe, Africa, the Americas, and other regions, where shipping costs were higher than for crude oil from the Middle East. In 2004, due to budgetary constraints, the system was changed to one that refunds the petroleum import levy.


The government recently decided to provide full compensation for the price difference through the end of this year. If this support continues, it could help reduce dependence on the Middle East and diversify import sources. Both South Korea and Japan engage in joint stockpiling. However, there is a difference: the Japanese government covers the cost of stockpiling, while in South Korea, oil-producing countries bear the cost in the form of lease payments.


To expand international joint stockpiling, the government should consider subsidizing part of the costs with public funds or easing the burden on oil-producing countries. Recently, countries in the Asia-Pacific, including Japan, Australia, and New Zealand, as well as Southeast Asian countries, have asked South Korea to export petroleum products. Our ability to maintain a stable domestic supply while also exporting is due to the sophistication of our refining industry and its international competitiveness.


However, maintaining this competitiveness in the era of carbon neutrality and the energy transition will require business diversification, restructuring, and early investment.  To secure the funding needed for investment, the refining companies hope the government will provide appropriate compensation for their losses.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Yoo Seunghoon, Professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology. Photo by Heo Younghan.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Yoo Seunghoon, Professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology. Photo by Heo Younghan.

View original image

▲Yoo Seunghoon, professor= There were no problems with supply and demand, so I would say the response was very good. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy responded quickly, with the government even going as far as landlocked Kazakhstan to secure crude oil. One disappointing point, however, is that no government agency used the term “energy crisis” officially.


To overcome an energy crisis, the government should have clearly explained to the public that it was an energy crisis and made efforts to overcome it. Despite the crisis in resource and energy security, energy responsibilities were divided between government agencies. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, which is responsible for securing resources, could not even use the term “energy” itself. Meanwhile, the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment, the energy ministry, has no role in oil and gas, so it could only manage demand through measures such as a five-day vehicle rotation system.


We have weathered the crisis well, but I was left thinking that the agencies responsible for energy should be unified so they can act in a coordinated manner.


▲Kim Jinsu, professor= As mentioned earlier, the government successfully used various systems to prevent supply disruptions, and I believe it fulfilled its responsibilities. But if we ask whether the crisis is over, the answer is no: energy costs are still not reflected in prices, and public corporations’ debt continues to grow. In that respect, I believe the crisis is not yet over.


The challenge going forward is how to build our capacity to respond. Until now, we have pursued diversification by region, but the crisis made us realize that transportation routes are far more important. We should discuss where government financial support is needed to secure flexibility in facilities.


Regarding international joint stockpiling of oil, I wonder whether South Korea could also increase its reserves by receiving lease payments from Japan. I also regret that we have not established protocols in advance on the order of response during a crisis or how to allocate our assets. Having such protocols could enable us to make proactive decisions when a crisis occurs. Even if we do not enact them into law, we should at least establish regulations and put measures in place to strengthen the stability of the energy system.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Ahn Gukheon, Director of Sustainability Management at the Korea Petroleum Association. Photo by Heo Younghan.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Ahn Gukheon, Director of Sustainability Management at the Korea Petroleum Association. Photo by Heo Younghan.

View original image

▲Han Byeonghwa, director= We have failed to create a society that is fundamentally sensitive to energy security. When a crisis hits, we should respond effectively, strengthen the country’s resilience, and fundamentally transform industry, but that did not happen this time. We should ensure that the public feels the impact of a crisis and changes its behavior. But by using a price cap to prevent costs from rising, the government kept the public and businesses from feeling the crisis, and I believe this prevented it from leading to reduced demand or improvements in industrial resilience.


▲Kim Jaehun, head of external relations= When problems arose with naphtha supply and demand, the government made a major contribution to securing supplies through the unprecedented “Naphtha Import Price-Difference Compensation Scheme.” In light of this situation, we should consider designating naphtha as a strategic security item, not just crude oil. We would need to assess the economics, but stockpiling naphtha could be considered because it presents no major technical difficulties, even if it is not as straightforward as stockpiling crude oil. Since we import naphtha from a range of countries, another medium- to long-term issue is whether we should invest in facilities that can process crude oil and naphtha at the same time.


-Since we rely entirely on imports for crude oil, there has been growing public sentiment that we should reduce our imports of energy. There are also calls for an energy transition that reduces the use of fossil fuels. The oil and petrochemical industries must have a lot to consider internally.


▲An Gukheon, head of sustainability management= I believe the direction we need to take is clear. The issue is the pace. Major European oil companies are expressing concern that they may have restructured their businesses too hastily. They are now making significant investments to reacquire carbon-related assets. A major challenge in the era of the energy transition is how to use and leverage carbon assets, and how to replace them.


Because our industries rely on fossil fuels as feedstocks and in petroleum products, the biggest question is whether they can coexist with carbon neutrality and the energy transition. Even so, bold investment in facilities is essential to ensure sustainability. This includes expanding into petrochemical materials, as with the Shaheen Project; converting heavy oil cracking facilities into facilities for producing basic feedstocks; and modifying kerosene and diesel desulfurization facilities to produce bio-based sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) or bio-naphtha. As the examples of France’s TotalEnergies and Finland’s Neste show, building a biofuel production system could become a key source of future revenue.


Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jinsoo, Professor in the Department of Resource and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University. Heo Younghan, Reporter

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jinsoo, Professor in the Department of Resource and Environmental Engineering at Hanyang University. Heo Younghan, Reporter

View original image

▲Kim Jinsu, professor= Oil demand is expected to peak in 2030 and then decline. With global demand falling, we need to assess or forecast how much market share South Korea can maintain and align the pace of our response accordingly.


Second, it ultimately comes down to supply chains. We need to consider the role of the refining and petrochemical industries. We must assess the position of the crude oil and petrochemical industries in supply chains that maintain manufacturing capacity and competitiveness, and whether there would be any problems if domestic production in these industries fell or the industries themselves disappeared.


We need to discuss this not simply in terms of fuel for transportation, but from the perspective of essential raw materials. I believe companies seeking to transition to bio-based materials may need conditional support.


▲Kim Jaehun, head of external relations= We are currently restructuring our business around naphtha cracking centers (NCCs). In the short term, we need to complete this process quickly and without disruption; in the medium to long term, we need to support a shift toward environmentally friendly, high-value-added businesses. Biomass and SAF, as mentioned earlier, are often discussed as ways to reduce emissions by replacing feedstocks and fuels. Some even believe that “making high-value-added products reduces greenhouse gas emissions.”

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jaehoon, Head of External Relations at the Korea Petrochemical Industry Association. Reporter Heo Younghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Kim Jaehoon, Head of External Relations at the Korea Petrochemical Industry Association. Reporter Heo Younghan

View original image

However, producing high-value-added products and reducing greenhouse gas emissions are not necessarily inversely related, and using bio-based feedstocks can only solve part of the problem. Ultimately, I would describe this as a highly complex equation with many interrelated variables.


▲Yoo Seunghoon, professor= Demand for petroleum used in transportation and as fuel is expected to decline, but natural gas for power generation may not follow the government’s plans. We need to work to expand supply infrastructure so that we can secure a sufficiently stable supply of natural gas.


The government expects the use of natural gas for power generation to decline as it pursues carbon neutrality. However, if the expansion of renewable energy falls short of the government’s targets, demand for natural gas for power generation could rise as it is needed to make up for electricity shortages. It seems impossible to build semiconductor clusters in the Yongin or Gwangju areas without gas-fired power plants.


-Specifically, what kind of government support is needed?


▲Han Byeonghwa, director= The government needs to change its stance. Many people see even a small amount of support for large companies as preferential treatment. The United States, Europe, and China support not only small and medium-sized businesses but also large corporations. That is necessary to accelerate the transition.


We should maintain certain parts of domestic demand for security reasons, but the government must do everything it can to help global players make a rapid transition. Companies already have too much capacity and need to restructure, but support is severely lacking.

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Han Byeonghwa, Director at Eugene Investment & Securities. Reporter Heo Younghan

Energy Sovereignty Roundtable - Han Byeonghwa, Director at Eugene Investment & Securities. Reporter Heo Younghan

View original image

The government should adopt proactive policies, such as boldly introducing production tax credits or applying contracts for difference (CfDs) to give consumers a choice. Otherwise, the industry could be put at risk because its structure is excessively rigid.


▲Kim Jaehun, head of external relations= The petrochemical industry already knows that it needs to produce environmentally friendly, high-value-added products. As companies have recently begun restructuring their businesses, regional economies and employment issues also need to be discussed. Business restructuring requires full-scale government support, and it should be considered from a range of perspectives, including supply chains, materials, and greenhouse gas reduction, rather than through a one-size-fits-all approach. Individual companies face significant limitations in doing this on their own. This is a crisis unlike anything we have experienced before, and it differs in many ways from previous industrial transitions.



▲An Gukheon, head of sustainability management= Our ability to maintain a stable domestic supply while also exporting is due to the sophistication of our refining industry and its international competitiveness. However, maintaining this competitiveness in the era of carbon neutrality and the energy transition will require business diversification, restructuring, and early investment. The implementation of a price cap on petroleum products has reduced the profitability of refining companies compared with those in other countries, and preparations for carbon neutrality have also lagged in some respects. We hope the government will appropriately compensate for some of the losses so that we can secure funding for transition investments. The government’s plans to expand storage facilities and increase crude oil reserves should also be implemented in concrete and sustainable ways.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing