Supreme Court En Banc Panel Changes Precedent

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News.

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News.

View original image

The Supreme Court’s en banc panel has ruled that when a party is late in reimbursing the other side for costs incurred in litigation or compulsory execution, it must pay delay damages starting the day after the court’s decision becomes final. The ruling overturns precedent under which delay damages began accruing the day after the debtor learned that the decision had become final.


The Supreme Court’s en banc panel, presided over by Justice Shin Sookhee, ruled unanimously on November 19 in the final appeal of a lawsuit filed by the plaintiff against A Limited Partnership and its general partner, Mr. B, seeking reimbursement of costs. The court overturned part of the lower court’s decision to dismiss the entire suit, specifically the portion concerning the claim for delay damages against A, and ruled directly in favor of the plaintiff on that claim.


In an earlier lawsuit between the plaintiff and A, court decisions recommending settlement became final. Under the decisions, A was to move its goods off the business site by the end of January 2019 and hand over the land. If A failed to do so, it agreed that the plaintiff could remove the goods at A’s expense and take possession of the land. When A failed to fulfill its obligations, the plaintiff obtained a court order and proceeded with substitute execution.


The plaintiff asked the court to determine the execution costs, and the decision fixing the amount of those costs became final in February 2023. A paid the confirmed costs of approximately 1.058 billion won nine days later, but did not pay delay damages for the late payment. The plaintiff then filed a lawsuit seeking the remaining costs and delay damages.


The first-trial court dismissed the suit, finding that the costs sought by the plaintiff constituted execution costs under the Civil Execution Act and that there was no benefit to filing a separate lawsuit. The second-trial court also dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal.


The Supreme Court, however, held that delay damages could be claimed through a lawsuit. The scope of what can be recovered through compulsory execution is determined by the terms of the order, and the order in this case did not include delay damages, the court said. This meant the creditor had no choice but to file a separate lawsuit to recover them. The court upheld the dismissal of the claim for the remaining principal costs, however. Because no special agreement giving the plaintiff the right to claim execution costs through a lawsuit had been established, the principal had to be recovered through execution of the decision fixing the costs.


The court changed its precedent on when delay damages begin to accrue, ruling that they start the day after the decision fixing the amount of costs becomes final. The debtor has already been afforded procedural protections before the decision becomes final and is notified of the final decision, the court said. It therefore would not be unreasonable to hold the debtor liable starting the following day, regardless of whether the debtor knew that the decision had become final. The Supreme Court ruled that A must pay the plaintiff delay damages on the principal amount. It dismissed the remaining appeal against A and the appeal against Mr. B.



The Supreme Court said that in future, if an applicant seeks a decision confirming both costs and delay damages, the order must specify the scope of the delay damages as well as the principal amount of the costs. The panel said that requiring creditors to file another lawsuit to recover delay damages would be “unreasonable because it forces creditors to go through an unnecessary procedure,” and warned that “the additional litigation costs could lead to an endless cycle of disputes.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing