Retirement Pension Providers Offered High-Yield Products to Large Companies First... FSS Warns Against Short-Term-Focused Sales Practices
Inspecting 'self-defeating' unhealthy business practices... Firm response to violations
FSS urges providers to strengthen their role, including by developing long-term asset allocation products
"If you take only the short-term fruit and do not water the tree, the tree itself will eventually wither and die."
Financial authorities have warned retirement pension providers against business practices focused on short-term results and excessive competition to attract funds. They said practices that run counter to the spread of a long-term investment culture have recurred year after year, including offering different products based on company size and offering higher interest rates to only some subscribers.
The Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) said on November 19 that it had held a meeting at its headquarters in Yeouido with executives from retirement pension providers and the four major financial associations: the Korea Federation of Banks, the Korea Financial Investment Association, the Life Insurance Association of Korea, and the General Insurance Association of Korea.
Seo Jaewan, Deputy Governor of the FSS, said, "Providers play an important role in establishing sound market practices for retirement pensions and spreading a long-term investment culture among subscribers." He urged providers to "put subscribers' interests first from a long-term perspective and fulfill their responsibilities, rather than focusing on short-term business results or competition to attract funds, particularly when market conditions are unfavorable."
He stressed that providers should not focus solely on the quantitative growth of the retirement pension market, but should faithfully carry out their fundamental role of managing subscribers' retirement assets. "If providers emphasize long-term investment in words but, in practice, take only the short-term fruit from the tree and do not water it, the tree itself could eventually wither and die," Deputy Governor Seo said. They must not undermine market confidence and the foundations for long-term growth by becoming fixated on short-term business results.
One of the main practices the FSS took issue with was offering different products based on company size. It found that some retirement pension providers gave large companies and major customers priority access to high-yield products with limited availability, while giving relatively little attention to small and medium-sized enterprises. An examination of subscriptions to high-yield time deposit products offered by some providers from December 2022 to December 2024 found that large companies accounted for as much as 90% to 94.5%. Given that small and medium-sized enterprises with fewer than 50 employees make up about 20% of companies enrolled in defined benefit (DB) retirement pension plans, the FSS said the supply of high-yield products was concentrated among large companies.
In addition to offering unusually high interest rates to only certain subscribers by taking advantage of the year-end concentration of maturities for principal-and-interest-protected products, providers also came under scrutiny for offering promotional benefits to attract new subscribers. According to the FSS, 14 providers offered benefits ranging from KRW 10,000 to as much as KRW 3 million, depending on net deposits, to attract subscribers to pension savings funds. The FSS said such practices were irresponsible, as they encouraged subscribers to pursue short-term financial gains and providers to compete for funds.
"These unhealthy, 'self-defeating' business practices, which are not competition to promote sound market development, such as improving returns, pour cold water on efforts to spread a long-term investment culture," Deputy Governor Seo said. He urged the industry to regulate itself, noting that such conduct undermines sound business practices. He also stressed that the commitment of company executives, including chief executive officers (CEOs), was particularly important. The FSS plans to closely monitor such unhealthy business practices and respond firmly when violations are identified.
The FSS also plans to encourage providers to develop products and services that promote long-term asset allocation and prioritize subscribers' long-term interests, as well as to strengthen the provision of investment information and investor education.
The FSS also plans to improve the accuracy of disclosures on its Integrated Pension Portal so subscribers can make informed comparisons between providers and products. The portal recorded 302 disclosure errors over the past five years. In some cases, leveraged and inverse exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which cannot be invested in through pension savings plans, were incorrectly listed as being available for sale. In another case, a calculation error overstated pension savings balances by KRW 1.8 trillion.
Participants at the meeting also expressed support for the financial authorities' policy direction, including establishing sound business practices in the retirement pension market and fostering a long-term investment culture. They also said they would strengthen internal sales management and inspections to prevent unhealthy business practices, and continue developing products and services related to long-term investment and providing guidance and education to subscribers.
Direct subscriber participation in managing retirement pensions is currently on the rise. The number of subscribers switching to defined contribution (DC) plans, in which subscribers directly instruct how their assets are managed, reached 340,000 from January through July this year, up 118.1% from 156,000 during the same period last year. However, retirement pension assets under management fell by KRW 11 trillion from the previous quarter to KRW 547.3 trillion in the third quarter, while the return over the preceding year dropped sharply to 6.6%, from 17.9% in the second quarter.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An FSS official said, "We plan to strengthen our monitoring of providers and continue supervision to protect subscribers and foster a long-term investment culture." The official added, "Through continued communication with retirement pension providers, we will promote substantive growth commensurate with the market's quantitative expansion and pursue improvements to the disclosure system and the provision of transparent information from the subscribers' perspective."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.