Saemangeum Airport Project at Risk as Appeals Court Upholds Cancellation of Basic Plan
Court: "Insufficient review of bird-strike risks and environmental impacts"
Jeonbuk State and local business groups: "Put the project back on track"
Whether the Land Ministry appeals and safety issues are addressed likely to determine the project's future
The construction of Saemangeum International Airport, a long-awaited project for Jeonbuk, is at risk of being derailed. The project has suffered a major setback after an appeals court upheld a lower court ruling that the basic plan for the airport development project must be revoked.
Environmental groups welcomed the ruling, saying it affirmed the importance of aviation safety and ecosystem conservation. Jeonbuk State and local economic and civic groups, meanwhile, expressed concern that the project could remain stalled for years and called on the government to come up with measures.
On November 18, a panel of the Seoul High Court's Administrative Division 4-2, comprising Presiding Judge Lee Gwang-man and Judges Moon Gwang-seop and Park Yeon-uk, ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, as the lower court had, in an appeal brought by 1,296 citizens affiliated with the Saemangeum New Airport Nullification Joint Action against the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, seeking to revoke the basic plan for the Saemangeum International Airport development project.
The court recognized the public interest in revitalizing the local economy through airport construction, but found that aviation safety and environmental conservation had not been adequately considered.
The court said, "It appears that greater weight was given to the benefits of development without reviewing and assessing the public interest in protecting life and physical safety and conserving the environment to a degree commensurate with their importance."
In particular, the court took issue with the failure to properly account for the risk of bird strikes during the airport site selection process.
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport evaluated 13 potential airport sites in 2019 and selected the Saemangeum site as the optimal location. However, the court pointed out that bird-strike risks were not assessed at the time. A subsequent strategic environmental impact assessment found that the risk of bird strikes was far higher than at other airports in South Korea and abroad, yet the risk was assessed as low without adequate review, the court said.
The ruling has cast doubt not only on the schedule but also on the future of the project, which was intended to build a runway, passenger and cargo terminals, and other facilities on a 3.4 million-square-meter site in the Saemangeum area, with completion targeted for 2028.
Reactions to the ruling in Jeonbuk were mixed.
The Saemangeum New Airport Nullification Joint Action held a press conference in front of the Seoul High Court that day and welcomed the ruling, saying, "The Jeju Air disaster at Muan Airport, which killed 179 people, was a warning that Saemangeum International Airport must be canceled."
It added that the ruling was "a stern rebuke of politicians who have pushed ahead with the project in the name of regional development despite the high risk of bird strikes," and called on the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport to drop its appeal and preserve the Sura tidal flat.
Jeonbuk State, on the other hand, said it respected the court's decision but expressed regret that a long-awaited project for local residents had been halted.
Jeonbuk State maintained that Saemangeum International Airport is a key infrastructure project for balanced national development, attracting corporate investment, and strengthening industrial and logistics competitiveness. It plans to analyze the ruling with the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and discuss legal responses, including whether to appeal, as well as ways to address the project's shortcomings.
Choi Jeong-il, head of Jeonbuk State's Construction and Transportation Bureau, said, "We will carefully examine the intent of the ruling and take the necessary follow-up measures as we continue our efforts to open up air routes for Jeonbuk."
The Saemangeum International Airport Early Construction Alliance, which comprises 209 organizations in Jeonbuk, also expressed deep regret and called for the project to be put back on track.
The alliance voiced concern that a prolonged delay in airport construction could increase uncertainty around corporate investment and efforts to attract partner companies, as well as negatively affect job creation.
Kim Jeong-tae, the alliance's chief committee member, stressed, "The government must carefully review the intent of the ruling and promptly present concrete, effective solutions to get the project back on track."
The project's future is expected to depend on whether the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport appeals and whether the safety and environmental issues can be addressed.
If the ministry appeals, the legal dispute will continue at the Supreme Court. If the ruling becomes final, the existing basic plan will lose its legal effect, making it highly likely that administrative procedures for advancing the project will need to be reconsidered. Since both the first and second trials identified inadequate review of bird-strike risks as a key legal violation, a fundamental reassessment of the site's suitability and environmental impact is likely to be unavoidable even if the project is relaunched.
There are also concerns about the impact of delays to the airport's construction on efforts to attract investment to Saemangeum and build a "tri-port" system linking the airport with ports and railways.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Ultimately, the fate of Saemangeum International Airport is likely to hinge on whether the government can find a solution that meets the court's requirements for aviation safety and environmental conservation while achieving the project's goal of balanced regional development.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.