③ Money Pours into Private-Company Stock ETFs and Perpetual Futures

"Massive amounts of money are flowing into exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that invest in shares of private company Anthropic."


A foreign media outlet made the observation while describing the investment frenzy surrounding the initial public offering (IPO) of Anthropic, the developer of the artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot Claude. Investors who had no opportunity to invest directly before the company goes public are pouring money into ETFs, it said. The news is noteworthy as more people in South Korea seek to invest in Anthropic.

Anthropic's "Claude" logo. Reuters-Yonhap News

Anthropic's "Claude" logo. Reuters-Yonhap News

View original image

However, one pitfall is that actual returns may vary depending on how much of Anthropic each ETF holds, even if the company's share price surges after its listing. Perpetual futures based on Anthropic's share price are also gaining attention as an alternative investment, but experts warn that investors should exercise particular caution given the products' extreme volatility.


22 Private-Company Stock ETFs See $11.3 Billion in Net Inflows

According to Bloomberg Intelligence (BI) on November 19, a total of $11.3 billion flowed into 22 ETFs investing in private companies such as Anthropic last week, net of outflows. This was the largest amount in more than a year. These ETFs account for less than 0.2% of total U.S. ETF assets. However, late last week, more than one-third of net inflows into all ETFs went to these funds. BI estimates that a large amount of the inflows came from hedge funds seeking to profit from the listing.


The biggest beneficiaries of the inflows are U.S. asset managers ARK and Alger, among others. During this period, ETFs managed by ARK received about $10 billion, while Alger and T. Rowe Price each attracted about $2.5 billion. BI, however, expects a substantial portion of these funds to flow out after Anthropic goes public. Around the time of SpaceX's IPO in June, ARK's flagship product, the ARK Innovation ETF (ARKK), received about $4.6 billion in inflows before the money flowed back out.

ETFs, Perpetual Futures: A Chance to Cash In? Returns May Fall Short [Anthropic IPO] View original image

If Anthropic goes public, the value of ETFs holding its shares will also rise. ETFs typically assign conservative valuations to private-company shares and reflect them in their prices. BI's analysis of funds holding Anthropic shares found that the funds' average estimated valuation for the company was about $1.07 trillion. That was about 31% below the estimated IPO valuation of $1.4 trillion at the time. Anthropic set its offering price at $83 per share on November 18, implying a company valuation of about $1.5 trillion.


However, investors are unlikely to earn large returns by investing in ETFs based on this calculation. Even if investment inflows increase, the amount of Anthropic equity available for purchase is limited. If the funds cannot increase their holdings of Anthropic, a private company, in proportion to the issuance of additional fund shares as new money comes in, their existing allocations could be diluted. In that case, even if Anthropic's share price surges on its first day of trading, ETF investors' returns are likely to fall short of the increase.


Among ETFs that currently hold Anthropic shares, the fund with the largest allocation is the Theme Photonics & Optical ETF (LAZR), with 13.9% of its portfolio invested in Anthropic. The KraneShares Artificial Intelligence & Technology ETF's allocation is just 3.3%. Assuming the prices of the other holdings do not change, even a 30% increase in Anthropic's value would contribute only about 4.2% and 1.0%, respectively, to the increase in each ETF's total asset value.

ETFs, Perpetual Futures: A Chance to Cash In? Returns May Fall Short [Anthropic IPO] View original image

In particular, Anthropic generally makes up only a small share of individual funds. According to BI, listed ETFs, mutual funds and closed-end funds hold only about 1.7% of Anthropic's shares. BI therefore expects that the increase in the valuation of these holdings following Anthropic's IPO could boost ETF returns and trading volumes in the short term, but would be unlikely to drive sustained inflows.


Some ETFs do not hold Anthropic shares directly, instead investing indirectly through special-purpose vehicles (SPVs) or derivatives. This can entail additional costs from using an intermediary. Investors may also face risks if they cannot sell the assets promptly or if the creditworthiness of a counterparty comes into play. John Cole Scott, chief investment officer (CIO) of CEF Advisors, said of investment structures using SPVs, "Think of it as an additional layer of fees. It's essentially a fund investing in another fund." Morningstar has warned that it is not advisable to buy an ETF solely to invest in a particular private company.


Perpetual Futures Also Gain Popularity... Volatility Poses a Challenge

Perpetual futures linked to Anthropic and offered through cryptocurrency trading platforms are also drawing attention. However, high volatility is a concern. One prominent product is the Anthropic-linked perpetual futures contract (xyz:ANT), traded on TradeXYZ, a futures trading platform built on Hyperliquid. It was trading at $100.03 as of 12:23 p.m. Korea time on November 19. xyz:ANT began trading at $138 on October 26 and closed at $114.35 on its first day. It has since fluctuated sharply, at one point falling to the low $90s.


Contracts traded before a listing are derivatives, not actual shares, and convert into perpetual futures that track the share price after the listing. Unlike conventional futures, perpetual futures have no expiration date, allowing investors to bet on price movements without owning the underlying shares. The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) described them as "essentially derivatives of derivatives," adding that "the ability to trade 24 hours a day, seven days a week, including weekends and holidays when traditional financial markets are closed, is one reason they have gained popularity this year."


ETFs, Perpetual Futures: A Chance to Cash In? Returns May Fall Short [Anthropic IPO] View original image

However, the price of a pre-IPO derivative does not guarantee the direction of the share price after the actual listing. A perpetual futures contract based on SpaceX's share price, launched in June, traded at about $176 on the morning of its listing day. But the actual shares began trading at $150, slightly above the $135 offering price. Kelly Ye, head of research at Talos, said, "Pre-IPO perpetual futures are not crystal balls that let you see the future."



Bloomberg described this trend as "an expansion of Wall Street's efforts to turn private-company shares and popular investment assets into products accessible to retail investors." It added that "although these investment structures are complex and involve substantial costs and risks, many investors believe the potential returns outweigh the drawbacks."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing