Case processing delayed by abolition of prosecutors' investigative authority
Supplementary investigations take more than three months... with no end in sight

Attorney Na Gi-eop (6th bar examination), who recently represented a victim in a child abuse case, said he was notified on November 3, 2026, that the Suwon Metropolitan Public Prosecution Office had issued an “order to resume and supplement the investigation” to the Anyang Branch of the Suwon District Public Prosecution Office. After the Public Prosecution Office dismissed the case in June following a police investigation, he appealed and asked for the decision to be reconsidered. As a result, the case has returned to the police for the first time in six months.


Before the Criminal Procedure Act was amended, when someone appealed a prosecutor’s decision not to prosecute, a high prosecutors’ office prosecutor could investigate the case directly and indict the suspect, or order a district prosecutors’ office prosecutor to reinvestigate and supervise that investigation. But since prosecutors’ investigative authority was abolished, the only action a prosecutor at a metropolitan Public Prosecution Office can take is to issue an “order to resume and supplement the investigation,” directing the police to conduct a supplementary investigation. From the victim’s perspective, there is no choice but to wait for the police who began the investigation to reinvestigate and possibly overturn their earlier findings. “Unlike appeals that could be resolved within a month in the past, now, even when prosecutors and investigators are willing to act, delays are inevitable as the case moves back and forth before the police can investigate it again,” Attorney Na said.


The Public Prosecution Office Case Management Rules stipulate that supplementary investigations must be completed within three months. This means they must be completed within three months even after extending once the one-month period for conducting a supplementary investigation under the Criminal Procedure Act and adding the time required for prior submission, the prosecutor’s comments, and final notification. However, cases subject to an order to resume and supplement the investigation are an exception because they require consultation with the appellate prosecution office. There is no telling when the appeals process will reach a conclusion.


Swift investigations are especially important in crimes targeting vulnerable members of society, such as domestic violence, stalking, and abuse, both to prevent secondary victimization and to secure evidence. In the case Attorney Na represented, the police investigation was thrown into disarray as the abusive parents pressured the child victim to recant. The case was ultimately referred to prosecutors with a recommendation not to prosecute.


Another problem is that a case is closed without change if the police who initially investigated it ultimately do not change their conclusion. In 2024, 49.7% of orders to resume investigations issued by six high prosecutors’ offices nationwide led to indictments (806 of 1,622 cases), a rate that had remained close to 50% each year. The number of appeals filed rose steadily, from 17,338 in 2022 to 22,622 in 2024. By contrast, in 2025, only 21.3% of cases in which prosecutors requested reinvestigations of cases the police had declined to refer were subsequently referred to prosecutors (2,749 of 12,898 cases).


Since the launch of the Public Prosecution Office, these problems have also been reflected in various indicators. In October, 11,209 requests for supplementary investigations were made, 1.4 times the 2025 monthly average of 7,801. The implication is that case processing is slowing because prosecutors can no longer conduct supplementary investigations, while the police must take on that much more investigative work. As of the end of October, the Public Prosecution Office had approximately 183,800 pending cases, nearly twice the approximately 96,200 at the end of December 2025.


Requests for supplementary investigations during prosecution also rose to 88 in October, more than eight times the 2025 monthly average of 10.3. This change has occurred because prosecutors can no longer accept and submit as evidence materials that victims discover and provide at a later stage.


The situation is also reflected in the number of prosecutors leaving the Public Prosecution Office. By the end of October 2026, 236 prosecutors had retired, a record high. The previous record was 175 in 2025. Including 111 prosecutors on leave, there are 347 vacant positions. The statutory number of prosecutor positions is 2,292.



Park Seongdong, reporter for the Legal Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing