Why Are Listed VC Stocks Stagnant Despite Abundant Venture Funding? [VCs Today]
Portfolio valuation losses widen amid KOSDAQ downturn
Operating revenue falls at 11 of 17 listed VCs
Share prices plunge amid stock market decline and worsening profitability
In the third quarter of this year, listed venture capital (VC) firms saw their operating performance decline. The downturn in the KOSDAQ market widened valuation losses on investment portfolios, while firms struggled to generate exit proceeds. Industry and academic experts agree that VCs need to diversify their exit channels, which are heavily concentrated on initial public offerings (IPOs), to include mergers and acquisitions (M&A) and secondary transactions.
According to the Financial Supervisory Service's Data Analysis, Retrieval and Transfer System (DART) on November 20, cumulative operating revenue (sales) in the first three quarters of this year fell year over year at six of the 17 listed VCs. Cumulative operating revenue rose at the other 11, making overall performance appear to have improved. However, looking at the third quarter alone, operating revenue actually fell at 11 firms.
This appears to be an optical illusion caused by the sharp increase in performance in the first half of this year. Six firms—DSC Investment, SBI Investment, Lindeman Asia, AJU IB Investment, GMI Venture, and LB Investment—saw cumulative operating revenue for the first three quarters rise even as their operating revenue fell in the third quarter alone. Meanwhile, five firms—HB Investment, Now IB, Mirae Asset Venture Investment, atinuminvest, and Capstone Partners—saw both cumulative and third-quarter-only operating revenue decline, reflecting the cooling venture investment market.
Weak Performance as Investment Asset Valuation Gains and Losses and Performance Fees Decline
Valuation losses on portfolio companies weighed on operating revenue. The downturn in the KOSDAQ market reduced the value of companies in VC investment portfolios. Listed portfolio companies were directly hit by falling share prices, while the valuations of unlisted portfolio companies were also affected by market conditions, as valuation multiples from comparable companies are applied to them. Because investment is the core business of VCs, unrealized valuation gains and losses are reflected in operating revenue. Many VCs recorded negative figures for valuation gains and losses rather than losses from asset disposals.
Mirae Asset Venture Investment, in particular, recorded operating revenue of -KRW 15.8 billion in the third quarter alone this year, after recognizing KRW 23.9 billion in investment asset valuation losses. In the third quarter of last year, the firm's operating revenue was KRW 21.8 billion. AJU IB Investment's operating revenue also fell sharply, from KRW 9.3 billion in the third quarter of last year to -KRW 6.2 billion in the third quarter of this year. It recorded KRW 11 billion in investment asset-related losses.
Exit proceeds were also weak. Unlike management fees, which VCs receive for managing funds, performance fees are earned when exits generate a certain level of returns for limited partners (LPs). Higher performance fees lead to higher operating revenue, but most of the cumulative performance fees recorded in the first three quarters of this year were generated in the first half. The 17 listed VCs recorded a combined KRW 75.63 billion in cumulative performance fees, of which only KRW 12.443 billion (16.4%) was generated in the third quarter alone.
In this environment, 12 of the 17 firms also saw their operating profit in the third quarter fall year over year. Eight firms—DSC Investment, TS Investment, Lindeman Asia, Mirae Asset Venture Investment, AJU IB Investment, Woori Technology Investment, atinuminvest, and GMI Venture—swung to a loss.
Listed VCs' Share Prices Also Waver Amid Downturn in Stock Market and Vicious Cycle of IPO Slowdown
Share prices are also wavering as performance declines. During trading on November 17, the combined market capitalization of the 17 listed VCs stood at KRW 2.2678 trillion, down 28.1% from KRW 3.1528 trillion at the end of the first half of this year. The declines were particularly pronounced at AJU IB Investment (from KRW 583.9 billion to KRW 298 billion), SBI Investment (from KRW 77 billion to KRW 39.6 billion), Daesung Changtu (from KRW 52.3 billion to KRW 33.8 billion), and Now IB (from KRW 141.7 billion to KRW 97.3 billion). VCs have responded with measures such as buying back and retiring treasury shares and share consolidations, but these have failed to turn the situation around.
The downturn in the KOSDAQ market is hurting the share prices of listed VCs. Since all 17 listed VCs are listed on KOSDAQ, their share prices are inevitably sensitive to market conditions. In addition, most of the listed portfolio companies held by listed VCs are on KOSDAQ, so the resulting deterioration in profitability as the index falls is also weighing on their share prices. The KOSDAQ index closed at 650.06 on November 17, down 29.0% from 916.18 at the end of the first half of this year.
Against this backdrop, the VC exit market is tightening further. With share prices falling sharply, it is difficult for IPOs to proceed successfully. According to the Korea Exchange, there were 63 IPOs from January through October this year. The number has been trending downward, from 113 in the same period of 2023 to 98 in 2024 and 68 last year. An official in the securities industry noted, "Companies that had been preparing to go public are also postponing their listings amid the recent market contraction."
Academics and industry experts believe that VC exit channels need to be diversified to improve the KOSDAQ market. Lim Hyeongjun, a research fellow at the Korea Institute of Finance, said, "As VCs are unable to exit through M&A or secondary transactions and instead depend on IPOs, pressure to take companies public quickly has increased." He added, "This often leads to underperforming listings of immature companies and undermines market confidence."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An executive at a large VC said, "Market conditions are so poor that companies that entered the KOSDAQ market in the third quarter of this year are trading below their IPO prices, creating a situation in which performance is deteriorating across the board." The executive added, "Ultimately, specific discussions are needed on how to diversify exit channels to improve the KOSDAQ market."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.