[Van Gogh's Stars, 137 Years of Debate] (2) "The Stars Look Alike, but Venus Is Elsewhere"... Experts Point Out Flaws in the July 22 Theory
Aldebaran's brightness differs from that in the actual sky... Venus and the Moon are also said to be out of position
Professor Schaefer: "The similarity of five stars alone cannot prove they were actually observed"
Statisticians say the possibility of a chance match requires further testing
Researchers: "We designated the star arrangement in advance... Our assessment considers the date and celestial positions together"
Observation and imagination may have been combined... Establishing the creation date is a separate issue
An astronomical counterargument has been raised against Korean researchers' analysis that five stars depicted in Van Gogh's "The Starry Night" resemble the actual Hyades star cluster. According to reporting by The Asia Business Daily on Nov. 19, Bradley Schaefer, a professor in the Department of Physics and Astronomy at Louisiana State University in the United States, said the brightness of Aldebaran, which the researchers identified, and the position of Venus do not match the actual sky on July 22, 1889. Statisticians said it is necessary to distinguish morphological resemblance from the possibility of a chance match.
A graphic marking the five stars in Vincent van Gogh’s “The Starry Night” that Korean researchers identified as corresponding to the Hyades cluster. The arrangement of Sn2, Sn3, Sn6, Sn7 and Sn10 was compared with the actual constellation; at right are a drawing modeled on the oil painting and the results of shape analysis. S.Lab·MoMA
View original imageProfessor Schaefer first questioned the brightness of the star the researchers identified as Aldebaran. It is one of the most prominent stars in Taurus. According to his analysis, it is depicted as the third-brightest of the five stars designated by the researchers.
The position of Venus also differs from that in the actual sky, critics say. According to Professor Schaefer, on July 22, 1889, Venus was a considerable distance east of the Hyades. If the stars identified by the researchers are aligned with the actual cluster, Venus should be outside the painting on the right, he said. In the painting, however, it is on the opposite side, relatively close to the group of stars. He also noted that the thin crescent Moon is not in its actual position.
Kim Jeong-hyun, CEO of S.Lab, explained these discrepancies as possibly resulting from Van Gogh's artistic reconstruction. He said Van Gogh may have maintained the basic arrangement of the stars he observed while adjusting the positions and brightness of celestial objects to suit the composition.
It is also well known in art history that Van Gogh did not simply reproduce actual landscapes. "The Starry Night" includes a village and cypress trees that could not be seen from the asylum window. The Van Gogh Museum likewise explains that much of the work was shaped by the artist's imagination.
Dawn skies over Saint-Rémy, France, on May 31, June 23, and July 22, 1889, recreated by Korean researchers using astronomical simulations. Comparing the positions of the Moon, Venus, and the Hyades star cluster on each date, the researchers proposed that the sky at dawn on July 22 resembled Van Gogh's “The Starry Night.” Eseuellab
View original imageHowever, acknowledging artistic transformation and identifying a specific star cluster are separate matters. If the resemblance between the arrangement of five stars and a real cluster is interpreted as evidence of actual observation, while discrepancies in the positions of other celestial objects are explained as the artist having moved them, it becomes difficult to test the hypothesis objectively.
Further questions have also been raised about the statistical analysis. The researchers compared 462 combinations of five stars selected from the eleven stars in the painting. Their result was that the arrangement designated in advance showed the greatest similarity to the actual Hyades.
Ian Dryden, a professor at the University of Nottingham in the United Kingdom, suggested that researchers should check whether not only the shapes but also the orientations of the stars match those in the actual sky. He also proposed randomly arranging the eleven stars and examining how often five of them form a shape resembling the Hyades. The point is to distinguish the fact that two shapes look alike from the conclusion that the chance of such a resemblance is sufficiently low.
Kim said the researchers had not conducted a comparison preserving the orientation of all five stars or an experiment randomly arranging the eleven stars. Instead, they separately verified the tilt of the Hyades and maintain that no other candidate remains when the date and positions of celestial objects are considered together.
Images used by Korean researchers to analyze the arrangement of celestial objects in Vincent van Gogh's nocturnal paintings, comparing photographs of the night sky with actual landscapes. The observation area and star positions were marked on the photos for comparison. The researchers applied celestial-shape analysis not only to "The Starry Night" but also to other nocturnal paintings, including "Starry Night Over the Rhone." SL Lab
View original imageTaken together, experts' analyses show that the measurable resemblance between the arrangement of stars in the painting and the actual cluster alone cannot prove that Van Gogh observed it. Astronomical objections concerning Aldebaran's brightness and Venus's position remain, and the possibility of a chance match requires further examination.
José Luis Aragón, a professor at the National Autonomous University of Mexico who analyzed statistical characteristics resembling turbulence in Van Gogh's paintings in 2008, assessed both the potential and the limitations of the current study. He focused on how the thin crescent Moon in late July could explain the shape of the Moon in the painting.
Professor Aragón also suggested that Van Gogh may have combined skies observed over several days in a single painting. Actual observation and imagination are not mutually exclusive; the landscape an artist observes can become material for artistic imagination, he explained.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Professor Aragón said, "Finding a sky that resembles the painting may be a necessary condition for proposing a specific creation date, but it is not a sufficient condition on its own."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.