South Korean researchers identify July 22, 1889, based on analysis of the Moon, Venus and the Hyades
The Van Gogh Museum counters with 12 canvases, a letter and a drawing from June
The same star pattern appears in a drawing sent on July 2...At the h

South Korean astronomy researchers and the Van Gogh Museum in the Netherlands, a world-renowned institution dedicated to studying Vincent van Gogh, have clashed over when van Gogh painted his masterpiece, "The Starry Night." The Korean researchers analyzed the positions of the stars, the moon and Venus in the painting and identified the sky of July 22, 1889, a month later than the date traditionally accepted as the time of its creation. The museum has held to the theory that it was painted in June, citing 12 canvases made from the same roll, along with letters and drawings from the period. As astronomical calculations reconstructing the night sky 137 years ago collide with physical evidence from the time the work was created, the central question in the debate has become which side has presented the more persuasive evidence.


Vincent van Gogh's "The Starry Night" (1889). Created at an asylum in Saint-Remy, France, the work features a swirling night sky, a slender moon and bright stars. South Korean researchers have found that the arrangement of five stars in the painting resembles the real-life Hyades star cluster. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York.

Vincent van Gogh's "The Starry Night" (1889). Created at an asylum in Saint-Remy, France, the work features a swirling night sky, a slender moon and bright stars. South Korean researchers have found that the arrangement of five stars in the painting resembles the real-life Hyades star cluster. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York.

View original image

According to reporting by The Asia Business Daily on the 23rd, a team of South Korean researchers including Kim Jeonghyeon, CEO of SL Lab, and Professor Jin Ho of Kyung Hee University published findings on October 22 in the international journal Scientific Reports showing that five stars depicted in "The Starry Night" resemble the Hyades star cluster in Taurus. The researchers reconstructed the dawn sky over Saint-Rémy, France, in 1889 and compared it with the arrangement of celestial bodies in the painting. Their findings raised new questions about the theory, long accepted by art historians, that the painting was created in June.


Kim is the founder and CEO of SL Lab, a company that makes astronomical telescopes. The paper also disclosed a potential conflict of interest: the company could use the research findings in publishing, education, exhibitions and video projects to generate economic benefits.


A video overlays a panoramic view of a village in Saint-Rémy, France, filmed in 2019 by Kim Jeonghyeon, CEO of Eseuellab, with landscape sketch F1541v, painted by Vincent van Gogh in 1889. Researchers analyzed the area depicted by comparing the contours of the actual terrain with those of the buildings and ridgelines in the sketch. Eseuellab

A video overlays a panoramic view of a village in Saint-Rémy, France, filmed in 2019 by Kim Jeonghyeon, CEO of Eseuellab, with landscape sketch F1541v, painted by Vincent van Gogh in 1889. Researchers analyzed the area depicted by comparing the contours of the actual terrain with those of the buildings and ridgelines in the sketch. Eseuellab

View original image

◆ Five stars point to July 22... Reconstructing the dawn sky of 137 years ago


The research began with five stars scattered across the center of the painting. Kim noted that they resemble the Hyades, which form a V shape. He judged their arrangement to be closer to the main stars of the Hyades than to Aries, which had been cited in previous research.



The researchers reconstructed the dawn sky over Saint-Rémy for each day in June and July 1889. They compared the slender moon hanging on the right side of the painting, the bright Venus on the left and the cluster of stars in the center. In mid-June, a slender moon like the one in the painting was not visible. On June 23, the moon's shape was similar, but the arrangement of the surrounding constellations did not match the researchers' interpretation.


At dawn on July 22, the slender moon, Venus and the Hyades could all have been observed together. The measured difference between the five stars in the painting and the actual shape of the Hyades was 8.17%. In a drawing van Gogh made based on the oil painting, the difference was smaller, at 6.62%. The researchers concluded that July 22 was a strong candidate, based on the moon's shape and the arrangement of the celestial bodies together.


Kim did not claim that July 22 was the date van Gogh began or completed the work. He suggested that van Gogh may have started the painting in June and incorporated the sky he observed in late July, or combined views from several days in a single canvas.


What the researchers identified was a resemblance between the painting and the actual sky. The measured difference in the shape of the five stars does not represent the probability that van Gogh directly observed the sky that day. This is why astronomical calculations alone cannot establish when the work was created.


A letter sent by Vincent van Gogh to his younger brother Theo around June 18, 1889. In the letter, van Gogh mentioned a newly painted "Study of a Starry Sky." The Van Gogh Museum identifies this work as the present-day "The Starry Night" and considers it important evidence supporting the theory that it was painted in June. Van Gogh Museum and Huygens Institute

A letter sent by Vincent van Gogh to his younger brother Theo around June 18, 1889. In the letter, van Gogh mentioned a newly painted "Study of a Starry Sky." The Van Gogh Museum identifies this work as the present-day "The Starry Night" and considers it important evidence supporting the theory that it was painted in June. Van Gogh Museum and Huygens Institute

View original image

◆ 12 canvases, a June letter and an early-July drawing... The evidence presented by the museum


The Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam said it disagreed with the Korean researchers' interpretation of when the painting was created. In an interview with The Asia Business Daily, senior researcher Teio Meedendorp explained that 12 oil paintings, including "The Starry Night," were made on canvas from the same roll, supplied in early June 1889.


Van Gogh cut the roll of canvas he received from his younger brother Theo to the size he needed. The museum confirmed the connection between the works by analyzing the weave and material of the canvases. It said that a new canvas made of distinctly different material was supplied in early July, and that the earlier canvas was no longer found in large oil paintings made afterward.


Correspondence from the period also supports the theory that the painting was created in June. In a letter sent to Theo around June 18, van Gogh mentioned a new "Study of a Starry Sky" that he had already painted. The museum identifies this work as the present-day "The Starry Night." The letter is dated more than a month before July 22, the date identified by the researchers.


Pen drawing F1540, created by Vincent van Gogh based on his oil painting The Starry Night. The cypress tree, village, swirling sky, and arrangement of the stars are nearly identical to those in the painting. The Van Gogh Museum believes that the drawing was sent to his younger brother Theo in early July 1889. Moscow Museum of Architecture

Pen drawing F1540, created by Vincent van Gogh based on his oil painting The Starry Night. The cypress tree, village, swirling sky, and arrangement of the stars are nearly identical to those in the painting. The Van Gogh Museum believes that the drawing was sent to his younger brother Theo in early July 1889. Moscow Museum of Architecture

View original image

The most notable piece of evidence in the debate is drawing F1540. In a letter to Theo dated July 2, van Gogh said he had sent about 10 drawings based on oil paintings. The correspondence published jointly by the Van Gogh Museum and the Huygens Institute includes F1540 among the works sent at the time.


The drawing features a dark cypress, a church steeple and a swirling night sky, as well as the arrangement of stars the researchers identified as the Hyades. If the museum's identification is correct, van Gogh had already drawn the same arrangement of stars at least 20 days before July 22.


Kim pointed out that the original letter does not directly name F1540. He argued that the date the drawing was sent is based not on an individual list of works left by van Gogh, but on identifications made by later art historians. The list of works in the published correspondence was reconstructed based on relevant catalogs and research. The fact that the work is not named in the letter is not, by itself, enough to disprove the existing identification.



If the canvas provides a way to trace when work began, the drawing shows how much of the composition had taken shape by a certain point. The possibility remains that van Gogh began the work in June and revised it in July. However, if the arrangement of the stars was already present in the early-July drawing, the interpretation that he newly depicted it based on an observation made on July 22 becomes less persuasive.


Vincent van Gogh (left), photographed in January 1873, and his younger brother Theo van Gogh, photographed in May 1878. Letters Vincent sent to Theo in 1889 are key sources for determining when The Starry Night was painted. Van Gogh Museum and Wikimedia Commons

Vincent van Gogh (left), photographed in January 1873, and his younger brother Theo van Gogh, photographed in May 1878. Letters Vincent sent to Theo in 1889 are key sources for determining when The Starry Night was painted. Van Gogh Museum and Wikimedia Commons

View original image

The work was not sent to Theo until September 28. There was time for revisions in the intervening period. Senior researcher Meedendorp also acknowledged that van Gogh sometimes made changes to works before sending them to his brother. However, no evidence has been found that the arrangement of the stars in "The Starry Night" changed in late July.


The evidence available to date weighs more heavily in favor of the theory that the painting was created in June. July 22 is a date based on the resemblance between the painting and the actual sky. By contrast, the June letter and canvas, along with the drawing identified as having been sent in early July, are based on records and materials from the time the work was made. F1540, in particular, is considered the biggest hurdle the researchers' hypothesis must overcome. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York also continues to date the work to "June 1889."



"The oil painting and the drawing are very similar, and both were made before July 22," senior researcher Meedendorp emphasized. "The drawing is evidence that van Gogh did not later change the overall composition of the painting."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing