A "Fee Increase" Not Provided for in the Terms, Announced in a One-Line Notice
Franchise Owners Bear Delivery Costs; Baedal Minjok Takes Credit and Reaps the Benefits
Baedal Minjok: "A Distorted Claim That Is Contrary to the Facts"

The Korea Franchise Owners Council (KFOC; Chairman Jo Cheolhyeon, hereinafter “the Council”), an alliance of franchisee groups representing different franchise brands, is demanding that Baedal Minjok (hereinafter “Baedal Minjok”) refund fees it says the delivery platform collected from franchise owners since July under its “combined discount” policy, despite the fees not being provided for in its terms and conditions.


Baedal Minjok has countered that the claim is “a distortion,” saying it has reimbursed partners for their share of the “delivery fee discount costs” incurred under the combined discount program through cashback, ensuring franchise owners did not suffer losses from the discounts. The dispute is therefore expected to continue for the time being.


According to the Council on November 18, it issued a statement the previous day titled “Baedal Minjok’s ‘Combined Discounts’ Were a Fee Increase Not Provided for in the Terms and Conditions,” demanding that Baedal Minjok: calculate and refund, for each franchise owner, the additional fees collected through the combined discount program from July 13 through November 18; immediately exclude from fee calculations the amount of discounts applied to delivery fees, without waiting for changes to the terms and conditions; disclose how much in fees will be newly excluded from the 110 billion won total and how much in additional fees it has collected to date; stop requiring discounts to be applied to delivery fees first and let franchise owners choose how to use them; and cover the costs itself if it wants to offer free delivery.


Baedal Minjok's "Combined Discount" Controversy: Council Says "Refund the Fees" vs. Baedal Minjok: "Fully Reimbursed via Cashback" View original image

The Council said it would send Baedal Minjok a formal notice demanding that it explain the basis for the policy under its terms and conditions, adding, “If we do not receive a satisfactory answer, we will respond by requesting a review of the terms and conditions and filing a complaint with the Korea Fair Trade Commission.”


In July, Baedal Minjok introduced a “combined discount” marketing program that applies a single discount amount set by a franchise owner to both customers’ delivery fees and food prices. For example, if a franchise owner sets a combined discount of 3,000 won, the discount is first applied to the delivery fee for orders placed through Baedal Minjok’s Alttul Delivery or One House Delivery services. Any remaining discount is then applied to the food price. Baedal Minjok said the program would increase the perceived benefit for customers and help franchise owners gain more exposure in the app and increase their order volume.


The Council objected that applying the discount to the delivery fee before the food price means the food price does not decrease, potentially increasing the amount used to calculate Baedal Minjok’s intermediary service fee. In response, on November 12, Baedal Minjok announced that it would revise its terms and conditions to exclude discounts paid for by franchise owners from the calculation of intermediary commissions and payment settlement fees, regardless of the type of discount. The change was intended to exclude discounts applied to delivery fees as well as discounts on food prices from fee calculations. Baedal Minjok estimated that this would reduce franchise owners’ burden by about 110 billion won a year.


In its statement, the Council said, “On November 12, Baedal Minjok announced that it would revise its terms and conditions to exclude delivery fee discounts paid for by franchise owners from fee calculations. It also said it would ease their burden by 110 billion won a year. Several merchant groups issued statements welcoming the move.” It added, “But the Council cannot applaud. What Baedal Minjok has announced is not a benefit; it is merely saying that, from now on, it will stop collecting fees it should never have charged in the first place.”


Attendees, including Chairman Cho Cheolhyeon (fifth from left), pose for a commemorative photo at the founding general meeting of the Korea Franchise Owners Council (KFOC), held on April 27 in the main conference room on the 10th floor of the Inchun Foundation Building in Yeoksam-dong, Seoul. Korea Franchise Owners Council (KFOC)

Attendees, including Chairman Cho Cheolhyeon (fifth from left), pose for a commemorative photo at the founding general meeting of the Korea Franchise Owners Council (KFOC), held on April 27 in the main conference room on the 10th floor of the Inchun Foundation Building in Yeoksam-dong, Seoul. Korea Franchise Owners Council (KFOC)

View original image

The Council claimed that after Baedal Minjok introduced combined discounts, franchise owners paid more in fees even though they gave customers the same discount.


The Council said, “Because Baedal Minjok made franchise owners’ discounts apply first to customers’ delivery fees rather than food prices, consider an order with a food price of 20,000 won and a delivery fee of 3,000 won. If the franchise owner gives a 3,000 won discount, the agreed fee used to be charged on 17,000 won. After the combined discount was introduced, the fee was charged on 20,000 won. The amount customers pay and the amount franchise owners cover are the same, but Baedal Minjok collects a higher fee.”


The Council said, “Franchise owners set discounts to lower food prices. They never wanted that money used to cover delivery fees,” adding, “But Baedal Minjok blocked them from choosing discounts on food prices alone.”


It continued, “Customers see a screen showing that the delivery fee has disappeared and assume Baedal Minjok is providing free delivery. Franchise owners cover the entire cost, while Baedal Minjok takes the credit and collects even more in fees. This is a ploy to raise the fees charged to merchants on the platform.”


The Council also said Baedal Minjok’s actions violated its own terms and conditions. It added that Baedal Minjok’s announcement that it would revise the terms was an attempt to avoid refunding fees it had collected unfairly.


The Council said, “Baedal Minjok’s terms and conditions stipulate that discounts paid for by franchise owners must be excluded from fee calculations. Whether Baedal Minjok applies a discount set by a franchise owner to the food price or the delivery fee, it is still a discount paid for by the franchise owner. Baedal Minjok failed to exclude the amount that its terms required it to exclude and collected additional fees for four months. It changed the fees without revising its terms and conditions, simply by posting a notice.”


It continued, “That is why there is no need to change the terms and conditions. Baedal Minjok only needs to follow the terms as they stand. Calling this a ‘change to the terms and conditions’ is a way to make it seem as if the past four months were in compliance with the terms and avoid refunding the additional money it collected.”


Baemin Notice Regarding "Integrated Discounts"

Baemin Notice Regarding "Integrated Discounts"

View original image

In response to the Council’s claims, Baedal Minjok said, “Participation in the combined discount program is optional for merchant partners and is intended to increase order volume. It makes it easier for business owners to offer delivery fee discounts within the amount they can afford to discount themselves.” It countered, “The portion related to delivery fee discounts has been fully reimbursed through cashback until the terms and conditions are revised, so the claim that merchant partners paid additional fees is plainly untrue.”


Baedal Minjok also said, “We have consistently worked to ensure that fees are not charged on discounts paid for by merchant partners. For the same reason, we have excluded from fee calculations not only discounts on food prices offered through coupons issued directly by individual business owners, but also discounts paid for by franchise owners after consultation with their franchisors.”



It added, “The revision to the terms and conditions on delivery fee discounts is likewise a measure to expand and institutionalize this principle of mutual growth by clearly incorporating our existing reimbursement policy into the terms.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing