"Passed the Certified Appraiser Exam After Just Six Months of Study?" ... Account of Passing Deleted Amid AI Cheating Allegations
Questions Mount After Account of Passing the Exam Is Deleted or Made Private
Concerns Spread to National Professional Qualification Exams, Including Labor Attorney and Real Estate Agent Tests
After the top scorer in the certified tax accountant exam admitted to cheating with artificial intelligence (AI) and turned themselves in, allegations of cheating have now been raised about a candidate who said they passed the certified appraiser exam after just six months of preparation. The controversy has grown after it emerged that the candidate’s online account of passing the exam had been deleted or made private.
A success story posted online by a person identified as A, who said they passed the certified appraiser exam after just six months of study. The post was deleted or made private after allegations of AI-assisted cheating recently emerged. Screenshot from an online community.
View original imageAccording to online communities for certified appraiser exam candidates and other sources on November 17, the account of passing the exam posted by Candidate A, who passed this year’s certified appraiser exam, was recently deleted or made private. A drew attention after saying they had passed both the first and second stages of the exam in about six months, despite having no prior knowledge of accounting or economics. A said they prepared for the exam from January through July this year, focusing on the first-stage exam for about three months before beginning intensive study for the second stage. A said they studied an average of about nine hours a day.
The second-stage exam preparation process has drawn particular scrutiny. The second-stage certified appraiser exam requires candidates to write essay-style answers within a time limit across three subjects: appraisal practice, appraisal theory, and appraisal and compensation laws and regulations. In the account of passing the exam, however, A said, “For theory and laws and regulations, typing or simply planning the answer in my head is enough,” and added, “I didn’t even fill five practice answer books, and I used only four pen refills.”
A said they did not take part in cram-school mock exams and studied the theory subject independently. They also wrote that they continued with everyday activities during the preparation period, including taking part in a marathon and going on a family trip. Some candidates questioned whether it was possible to pass in such a short time without sufficient handwriting practice, given that the exam requires candidates to write essay-style answers within a time limit. The controversy spread after claims emerged that A had revised the account of passing the exam and blog posts several times before deleting them or making them private.
Reference materials for the second-stage certified appraiser exam, released by a person identified as A, who said they passed the exam after just six months of studying. Controversy over alleged AI-assisted cheating arose after A said they solved materials that could not be answered by visual inspection alone using only mental arithmetic. Screenshot from an online community.
View original imageYoon Cheolsin, CEO of Study Fighter and a former certified appraiser exam passer, also questioned A’s path to passing. In a post, Yoon wrote, “I don’t believe the six-month claim,” adding, “I think one of two things happened: either the preparation period was misrepresented, or there was cheating.”
He stressed that for the second-stage certified appraiser exam, practicing how to write answers in the required format within the time limit is as important as acquiring knowledge. “Knowing the material isn’t enough; you need time to practice putting what you know into the required format within the time limit,” Yoon said. He added that preparation periods of around a year for professional qualification exams already count as exceptionally short.
However, Yoon left open the possibility that someone could pass in six months under exceptional circumstances. “It’s possible that someone really did manage it in six months,” he said, while arguing that investigative authorities should review relevant records to resolve the allegations.
The testimonial said the candidate used fewer than five practice answer books and only about four pen refills, yet passed the certified appraiser exam on the first attempt while juggling multiple commitments during a short preparation period. Screenshot from an online community.
View original imageA certified appraiser is a nationally licensed professional who assesses the economic value of real estate, including land and buildings. According to the Human Resources Development Service of Korea, 2,614 people took this year’s second-stage certified appraiser exam, and 189 (7.23%) passed. No evidence has been confirmed to date that A actually cheated by using an AI device. The allegations raised so far are based on online users’ speculation and questions prompted by the short preparation period, the contents of the account of passing the exam, and the deletion of posts.
Concerns about AI-assisted cheating are spreading to other national professional qualification exams, including the certified labor attorney and licensed real estate agent exams. Last year, 80,387 people took the first-stage licensed real estate agent exam and 33,247 took the second stage, prompting concerns that there may be limits to monitoring electronic devices among such a large number of candidates. An official from the Korea Association of Realtors expressed concern that various qualification exams administered by the Human Resources Development Service of Korea are conducted in similar ways and are therefore exposed to similar risks of cheating. Industry observers say the essay-based second-stage certified labor attorney exam is no exception.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Exam administrators are also reviewing the possibility of cheating. The Human Resources Development Service of Korea plans to investigate national qualification exams overall, including the certified labor attorney exam, while financial authorities have launched a separate review of the certified public accountant exam. Since the certified public accountant exam is not included in the Human Resources Development Service of Korea’s investigation, financial authorities are independently checking this year’s exam results for any unusual signs.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.