"A 40% Premium Still Won't Stop Share Price Suppression"... Rep. Lee Hoonki Slams Finance Ministry Plan
"Taxing Based on Depressed Share Prices Leaves Tax-Avoidance Incentives Intact"
Calls for a Floor of 80% of Net Asset Value
Proposes In-Kind Tax Payments and Exceptions for Companies in Financial Distress Amid Constitutionality Debate
Lee Hoonki, a Democratic Party of Korea lawmaker, criticized the Ministry of Finance and Economy's proposed revisions to the "Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act," saying they would not fundamentally eliminate controlling shareholders' incentive to artificially depress share prices to reduce inheritance and gift taxes. He argued that instead of applying a fixed premium to undervalued shares, the government should set a floor for taxable value based on a company's net asset value.
On November 17, Lee pointed out problems with the Ministry of Finance and Economy's proposed revisions to the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act. His remarks were a rebuttal to the supplementary measures presented by a government representative at a public debate held on November 9.
Earlier, Lee Hyo-seop, head of the Financial Industry Division at the Korea Capital Market Institute, which conducted a research project for the Ministry of Finance and Economy, proposed expanding the definition of companies suspected of suppressing their share prices to include those whose price-to-book ratio (PBR) was in the bottom 25% of their industry in at least three of the past six half-year periods. He also proposed raising the minimum premium applied when valuing shares from the current 30% to 40%.
Lee, however, argued that this approach was still limited because it used market share prices as the basis for taxation. If a company's share price has fallen far below the actual value of its assets, he said, even a 40% premium could leave its inheritance and gift tax burden sufficiently low.
He stressed that the underlying structure, in which keeping share prices low reduces taxes, must be changed. His proposal is to value controlling shareholders' stakes in companies with a PBR below 0.8 using the method applied to unlisted shares, and to set 80% of net asset value as the minimum taxable value. Under this approach, the assessed value would not decrease even if the share price fell further, as long as the company's PBR remained below 0.8.
Lee also raised concerns about the relative valuation method proposed by the ministry. If only companies in the bottom 25% of their industry by PBR are covered, companies outside that group would be excluded even if the entire industry were undervalued. Conversely, if a company's share price rose but its PBR remained in the bottom 25%, its tax burden could increase in line with the higher share price, he said.
Lee's office cited office equipment manufacturer Sindoh as an example. Sindoh has net cash of KRW 420 billion, excluding its debt. That is about KRW 110 billion more than its market capitalization of KRW 310 billion, excluding treasury shares slated for cancellation. The company also owns real estate in Seongsu-dong, Seoul, and Tokyo, Japan, estimated to be worth more than KRW 1 trillion. Given its substantial assets, Sindoh's PBR was just 0.28 as of the closing price on November 11. The PBR threshold for the bottom 25% of the information technology (IT) sector, to which Sindoh belongs, is around 0.58. Even if Sindoh's share price doubled, it would not exceed that threshold, while the value used to calculate inheritance and gift taxes would double. In effect, the paradox is that efforts to raise the share price would lead not to exemption from the rules, but to a higher tax bill.
Lee said the principle of valuing shares at 80% of net asset value should be maintained, while proposing five supplementary measures. These include exempting companies facing financial difficulties, such as capital impairment or restructuring, and allowing exceptions for companies that remain in the top 50% of their industry by PBR for a specified period. His proposals also include allowing controlling shareholders to pay inheritance tax in kind using their listed shares and applying simplified valuation to small affiliates.
Lee also proposed applying the same valuation principle to indirectly held stakes to prevent circumvention through subsidiaries and sub-subsidiaries, and abolishing the current 20% premium applied to controlling shareholders' stakes. "The success of a good law to prevent share price suppression should not be measured by how many cases a committee uncovers or how much additional tax it collects. It should be measured by whether companies increase their own value and consequently become less likely to fall within the scope of the law," he stressed.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.