A time when "depth" matters more than "speed"
Thorough deliberation and communication are needed

[Reporter's Notebook] M&A Revitalization or Shareholder Equality... A Dangerous False Dichotomy View original image

The debate over reintroducing the mandatory tender offer system for the first time in 28 years shows little sign of abating. The dispute appears to be heading toward an irreconcilable clash over whether to revitalize the mergers and acquisitions (M&A) market or ensure equal treatment of shareholders. The issue has become so contentious that some are asking the president for a "Solomon's judgment." One side argues that buyers should be required to make an offer for all remaining shares, while the other favors a compromise requiring them to acquire only "50% plus one share." There is also fierce debate over whether buyers should be allowed to acquire the controlling shareholder's stake first.


But this is not a matter of choosing between two alternatives. The mandatory tender offer system is a complex policy decision that must take into account the financial burden on acquirers, controlling shareholders' incentives to sell, the rights of ordinary shareholders, and confidence in the capital market. It cannot be decided based on the interests of just one side.


In particular, the provision allowing buyers to acquire a controlling shareholder's stake first is not a simple matter. It is a key mechanism for determining the scope of rights guaranteed to ordinary shareholders. Even raising the minimum tender offer price would not solve the problem of shares being acquired first from the controlling shareholder, leaving no shares to allocate to ordinary shareholders. Once permission for such advance purchases is written into law, it would also be difficult to correct the issue through amendments to enforcement decrees alone. This is why a more cautious approach is needed.


Major capital markets overseas have demonstrated various ways to balance equal treatment of shareholders with the promotion of M&A activity. Japan applies a pro rata allocation principle to partial tender offers, reducing discrimination between controlling and minority shareholders. Its M&A market has continued to grow nonetheless. The United States, the world's largest M&A market, guarantees all shareholders the opportunity to participate in tender offers and applies the equal-price principle, even without a mandatory tender offer system.



This debate is an extension of the capital market reforms the government has been pursuing. If it amends the Commercial Act in the name of strengthening protections for ordinary shareholders, then passes a bill determining shareholder rights in changes of corporate control without sufficiently examining it, the consistency of its policies may itself be called into question. There is a clear difference between taking somewhat longer to introduce the system after thorough deliberation and introducing it without resolving key issues, thereby fueling distrust in the capital market for years to come. It is clear which would be the bigger problem.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing