Busan Councilmember Sung Hyundal Raises Concerns About Contracted Facilities at Administrative Audit

Questions Personnel and Heating and Cooling Spending, as Well as Effectiveness of City Inspections

The Busan City Council has raised concerns that a gap in care lasting about 20 hours occurs at an animal shelter between the end of volunteer activities and the following day.


Reports also cited a case in which an animal that died after being strangled on the day it was rescued was listed as having died of "natural causes," and allegations that 11 cats died during the summer.


At a Busan Metropolitan City administrative audit on November 17, Sung Hyundal, a member of the Busan City Council's Marine City Safety Committee (People Power Party, Nam-gu District 3), questioned the operation of animal shelters and the city's oversight system. He cited visits to the sites, reports from volunteers and people involved, financial statements from contracted facilities, and city inspection materials.


Councilmember Sung presented a case in which an animal that died after being strangled by a leash on the day it was rescued was listed as having died of "natural causes," and questioned whether the circumstances of the death and its documentation were appropriate. He also cited a report that 11 cats died en masse in the middle of summer and that there were no water bowls at the time, as well as a case in which animals were injured during grooming practice for shelter animals.

Busan City Councilor Seong Hyeondal of the People Power Party, representing Nam-gu 3, is raising concerns about the operation of an animal shelter.

Busan City Councilor Seong Hyeondal of the People Power Party, representing Nam-gu 3, is raising concerns about the operation of an animal shelter.

View original image

He also raised concerns about gaps in care. At one shelter he visited, volunteers handled cleaning, feeding and watering, and walks from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on weekdays. This meant there was effectively no one to care for the animals for about 20 hours after volunteer activities ended until the following morning, he said.


Councilmember Sung argued that the setup made it difficult to provide the frequent feeding young cats need, check their water bowls, and manage temperatures during heat waves and cold snaps. "Is this normal operation for an animal shelter, when volunteers are effectively taking the place of staff and care stops when they leave?" he asked.


Spending under the contract also came under scrutiny. The financial statement for one shelter presented by Councilmember Sung listed KRW 194.8 million in personnel expenses for five employees. Annual heating and cooling costs were KRW 3 million. He argued that the city should verify actual staffing and work hours, as well as salary payments. He also pointed out that although heating and cooling expenses had been budgeted, the facility had no heating or cooling equipment.


He also cited a case in which a volunteer bought medicine with their own money and applied it to an animal that needed treatment. Councilmember Sung urged Busan City to review all aspects of contracted spending, including actual work records, salary payments, veterinary treatment records, and documentation of heating and cooling expenses.


Criticism was also voiced that Busan City's inspections had failed to identify problems at the facilities. Councilmember Sung noted that some facilities had been operated under contract for more than 10 years, and that regular and joint inspections as well as an honorary animal protection officer system were in place. Yet, he said, the city's inspection materials described the facilities as being "operated appropriately overall." He argued that the effectiveness of the inspections should be reassessed.


Operating practices that make adoption difficult were also cited as a problem. Shelter opening hours are inconsistent, and arranging visits by phone or in person is not easy, making it difficult for residents to meet the animals, he said. "With shelters operating this way, adoption rates can never rise," Councilmember Sung said.


Councilmember Sung called on Busan City to adjust shelter care funding to reflect actual needs, strengthen medical support, guarantee minimum opening hours, and increase staffing. He also urged the city to move beyond leaving responsibility solely to privately contracted facilities and pursue the establishment of a city-operated animal shelter.


"If we spend hundreds of millions of won each year on pet festivals and the development of parks and playgrounds, yet still have to worry about whether shelter animals are getting water on time, how should we assess Busan's animal welfare policy?" he asked.



The information raised in this audit regarding the circumstances of deaths, mass fatalities, and budget spending is based on cases and reports presented by Councilmember Sung. The actual circumstances of the incidents and the appropriateness of spending under the contracts remain matters to be established through Busan City's review of the records and follow-up inspections.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing