Sustainvest releases corporate ESG assessment results
CP adoption rate among companies sanctioned for collusion: 58.2%
Twice the rate among non-sanctioned companies in the same industries
Compliance and anti-corruption certification rate also 2.9 times higher
"Effective sanctions needed"

"Companies That Colluded Have Better Compliance Systems... Raising Questions About the Effectiveness of Sanctions" View original image

Six out of 10 companies sanctioned for collusion had adopted a Compliance Program (CP), a voluntary fair trade compliance program. They had more compliance management systems in place than companies with no history of collusion-related sanctions. Although the government offers benefits such as reduced fines to companies that adopt a CP, some say companies should be evaluated based on how effectively they prevent actual violations, rather than simply on whether they have adopted programs like the CP.


According to the "Second-Half 2026 ESG Assessment Results" released on November 17 by ESG (environmental, social and governance) rating agency Sustainvest, 58.2% of companies with a history of collusion-related sanctions had adopted a CP, twice the rate of companies in the same industries that had not been sanctioned (28.9%). This was nearly three times the rate among companies in industries with no reported collusion (19.4%).


A CP is an internal management system that companies adopt to voluntarily comply with fair trade laws and regulations. It involves appointing a compliance officer and operating procedures for employee training, internal monitoring and controls.


Sustainvest conducted ESG assessments of 1,328 domestic companies and compared their fair trade management systems according to whether they had been sanctioned for collusion, using data from 2023 to 2026. Over the past four years, 94 companies received a total of 125 sanctions for collusion. An analysis of 332 companies in 12 industries where collusion is frequent found that 79 had a history of sanctions.

"Companies That Colluded Have Better Compliance Systems... Raising Questions About the Effectiveness of Sanctions" View original image

The higher CP adoption rate among sanctioned companies was not a temporary phenomenon. Their adoption rate rose from 53.3% in 2023 to 58.2% this year. Over the same period, the rate among companies in the same industries with no sanctions increased only from 26.5% to 28.9%. Sanctioned companies had a higher adoption rate than non-sanctioned companies throughout all four years.


A similar pattern emerged in compliance-related certifications. The rate of certified compliance and anti-corruption management systems among companies sanctioned for collusion was 35.4%, or 2.9 times the rate among non-sanctioned companies in the same industries (12.3%). The certification rate among sanctioned companies rose 10.9 percentage points in one year, from 24.5% last year.

"Companies That Colluded Have Better Compliance Systems... Raising Questions About the Effectiveness of Sanctions" View original image

Among companies sanctioned for collusion, 96.2% had established fair trade principles, 14 percentage points higher than the rate among non-sanctioned companies (82.2%). In other words, companies sanctioned for collusion had more fully established formal compliance management systems.


This has raised questions about the effectiveness of compliance management systems such as CPs in practice. CPs are linked not only to internal corporate management but also to government regulatory incentives. The Fair Trade Commission evaluates the level of CP implementation and assigns ratings. Companies rated highly can receive benefits, including reductions in fines and exemptions from ex officio investigations, subject to certain requirements.


Sustainvest emphasized the need to distinguish between whether a company has a compliance management system and whether it actually prevents violations. "The fact that companies with a history of collusion have the highest rates of CP adoption and ethics management certification highlights a gap between having these systems in place and actually managing compliance," said Ryu Youngjae, chairman of Sustainvest.



He added, "Adopting a CP should not, in itself, be considered an achievement in compliance management. Companies must demonstrate the program's effectiveness through tangible results in preventing and controlling violations, and the government should limit CP-based fine reductions to cases where the program's effectiveness has been verified."

ESG Leaders Selected by Sustainvest for the Second Half of 2026

ESG Leaders Selected by Sustainvest for the Second Half of 2026

View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing