Lin Law Firm's APT Group

Related law took effect in January

Scope of obligations remains unclear

High-impact AI is the most contentious issue

Little time and few precedents remaining

The AI team at Lin Law Firm poses for a photo before an interview with The Asia Business Daily at the firm’s conference room in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 18th. Photo by Kang Jinhyung

The AI team at Lin Law Firm poses for a photo before an interview with The Asia Business Daily at the firm’s conference room in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 18th. Photo by Kang Jinhyung

View original image

"Everyone knows you must not cross the center line, but what should you do when a car is illegally parked on a one-way, single-lane road? When you get into the details, you always encounter questions about these boundaries. In the field of artificial intelligence (AI), in particular, there are no precedents. It is our job to determine which lines can be crossed and which cannot."


Koo Tae Eon, who heads the AI, Platform and Technology (APT) Group at Lin Law Firm, made the remarks in an interview with The Asia Business Daily on November 18. The AI Basic Act, which took effect in January, sets out requirements such as labeling generative AI outputs and obligations for high-impact AI providers. But when the law is applied to actual services, there can be differing views on exactly what is required, he said.


There are reasons the boundaries remain unclear. "When a technology the world has never seen before suddenly emerges, gaps are bound to arise when we try to regulate it under the existing legal order or system," said attorney Choi Hong Seok, who passed the first Korean bar exam. He explained that the government has therefore chosen to prohibit activities at first and then gradually allow exceptions.


The question of whether an AI system qualifies as high-impact AI is where the boundaries are most contested. Classification as high-impact AI entails obligations such as risk management, providing explanations and protecting users. "Just because a service is broadly related to medical care or lending does not mean it is automatically subject to regulation in every case," said attorney Ahn Seo Yeon, a member of the 37th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute. "In many cases, a system is not considered high-impact AI or subject to regulation if there is a certain degree of human involvement." That is why companies need to determine in advance whether their services fall under the regulations, she said.


There is little time, and few precedents. Once the grace period ends, during which the government has postponed imposing administrative fines and conducting fact-finding investigations for more than a year, fines may be imposed. Attorney Lee Sang Kang, who passed the third Korean bar exam, noted that companies are finding it difficult to determine how to meet labeling and disclosure requirements, or even whether they are subject to them. "The problems will become real when the grace period ends and companies face regulation one after another," he predicted.


To address this gap, the team recently launched the AI Compliance Certification (AICC) program with Deloitte Anjin LLC. It offers one-stop support, from an initial assessment to determine whether an AI system is subject to regulation, through compliance consulting and review by a certification review committee that includes outside experts. "Regulation is not just an onerous penalty; it can also be an opportunity for companies to earn the trust of the market and customers and gain a competitive edge," said attorney Seo Bo Mi, who passed the fourth Korean bar exam.


The team has also contributed to designing the regulatory framework, beyond advising companies. "The AI Basic Act is also a law designed to promote AI," said Ahn. Under the act, when purchasing products and services, national and local governments and public institutions must give priority consideration to AI products and services that have received government confirmation. Lin advised the Korea Artificial Intelligence and Software Industry Association (KOSA) on developing the standards and procedures for this "AI Product and Service Confirmation System," which took effect in July.


Koo said he aims to help overcome situations in which existing regulations obstruct new industries. "If the Wright brothers had invented the airplane when laws banning flight and aviation laws were already in place, aviation would not have developed," he said. "We will become a frontier law firm that helps resolve regulatory issues facing new industries."




From Identifying the AI Basic Act’s "Gray Areas" to Certification... Lin APT Group Offers One-Stop Advisory [Top Law Firm Teams] View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing