KFTC Imposes Record-High Fine
Criminal Complaints Shift Focus to Seoul High Court and Serious Crimes Investigation Agency
Seven Major Law Firms Combine Litigation and Financial Regulatory Teams
Mobilize Mammoth-Scale Response Teams
Simultaneously Defend Against Lawsuits to Overturn Fines and Serious Crimes Investigation Agency Probes
Legal Battle Among Seven Major Law Firms Heats Up as They Put Their Reputations on the Line

KRW 1.6 Trillion Government Bond Collusion 'Money War' Enters Its Second Act... Seven Major Law Firms Go All Out to Overturn Fines View original image

The Korea Fair Trade Commission has finalized a record-high fine of KRW 1.6266 trillion against 15 primary dealers (PDs) in government bonds for allegedly colluding on interest rates. The seven major law firms retained in the case are preparing for a legal battle. With lawsuits seeking to overturn the fines and criminal complaints filed with the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency against seven financial institutions, the focus has shifted to the Seoul High Court and investigative agencies. The intense legal maneuvering among the country's leading law firms over this year's biggest catch, involving astronomical fines and sharply contested legal issues, is now underway.


Seven Major Law Firms Bring Their Full Legal, Criminal Defense and Financial Regulatory Teams to Bear


According to legal sources on Nov. 18, the Fair Trade Commission's sanctions have not yet reached the stage at which administrative litigation engagements are finalized, as the commission's written decision has not been formally served on the financial institutions. However, law firms have effectively treated litigation as a certainty and begun reviewing the legal issues. With administrative lawsuits challenging the fines and criminal proceedings to defend executives against legal risks set to proceed simultaneously, the firms are mobilizing large-scale response teams combining their existing antitrust groups with litigation, criminal defense and financial regulatory teams.


Kim & Chang, representing Samsung Securities and Shinhan Securities, has begun developing an all-out defense strategy. Bae, Kim & Lee, representing NH Investment & Securities and Industrial Bank of Korea (IBK), has put at least five key attorneys at the forefront, led by antitrust group head Kim Hongki and attorney Kang Il. The team also includes attorneys Kim Gyusik, Kwon Dohyeong and Kim Youngseok.


Shin & Kim, representing KB Securities, which received the largest fine imposed on a single financial institution at KRW 332.2 billion, as well as Mirae Asset Securities and NH NongHyup Bank, has deployed about 80 antitrust specialists, one of the largest teams in the industry. Its response team is centered on co-head of the group Choi Joonghyuk, foreign attorney; former presiding judge Choi Hansoon (27th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute); and Lee Changhoon (33rd class) and Sung Seunghyun (36th class), co-heads of the Antitrust Investigation Response Team.


Lee & Ko, representing Kyobo Securities, has not announced a separate task force but is operating a joint response team that includes numerous antitrust specialists and criminal defense attorneys. Yulchon, representing Hana Bank, KB Kookmin Bank and Meritz Securities, has brought together its antitrust, litigation, corporate law and financial groups for a coordinated, multifaceted response. Yoon & Yang, representing Kiwoom Securities and Korea Investment & Securities, and Jipyong, representing Daishin Securities, have also joined the case, setting the stage for a legal battle in which the seven major law firms will put their reputations on the line.


Presumed Related Revenue Rule and Criteria for Criminal Complaints Under Scrutiny


The main battleground in the administrative lawsuits is expected to be whether the criteria for calculating "related revenue" are lawful. Citing an enforcement decree provision that treats the contract or winning bid amount as related revenue in bid-rigging and purchase-collusion cases, the Fair Trade Commission used approximately KRW 54 trillion in government bond purchases won by the 15 financial institutions as the base for calculating the fines.


Legal experts, however, argue that higher-level laws require financial businesses to use "operating revenue" as the benchmark, and that the commission applied the law mechanically, disregarding the specific nature of bond trading. For example, if a government bond is bought for KRW 100 and sold for KRW 110, most financial institutions recognize the trading profit of KRW 10, not the KRW 100 principal, as revenue from operations in their accounts. Even the total trading profit across the industry amounts to only several tens of billions of won, and all related costs, including labor and negotiation expenses, must be deducted from that profit before any net income remains.


"Fines are intended in part to recover unjust enrichment. Even if collusion is established, the unjust enrichment would be the margin earned from trading the bonds, not the entire principal amount of the bonds," said an antitrust attorney. "If real estate agents colluded, shouldn't the fine be based on their brokerage fees rather than the entire price of the apartments they handled?" If the court rules that operating revenue, meaning trading profit, should be used instead of the presumed-revenue provision in the enforcement decree, it is highly likely to overturn the Fair Trade Commission's fine in its entirety.


Disputes are also expected over the criteria used to select the seven financial institutions for criminal complaints. The Fair Trade Commission is understood to have selected the targets by considering not only the amount of related revenue but also the duration and number of violations and the extent of information exchange among employees. "Some of the companies facing complaints had relatively small transaction amounts, so it's unclear what objective standard was used to distinguish the targets," said another antitrust attorney, signaling that the defense would focus on raising questions of fairness during investigations and trials.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Restrictions on Competition at Issue; Ministry of Finance and Economy Testimony May Also Be Considered


Whether the Fair Trade Commission can prove that the alleged conduct restricted competition, a requirement for establishing "information-exchange collusion" under the amended Fair Trade Act, is another issue expected to be fiercely contested. The commission maintains that communications among employees helped resolve uncertainty in decision-making and affected bids, arguing, "If the information had no meaning, why would they have exchanged it?" Law firms, in contrast, argue that the commission judged customary practices in the bond market by the standards of the market for general goods.


Legal experts say the value of the information exchanged and its actual impact on the market must be examined rigorously. With the Fair Trade Commission unable to provide figures for the specific rise in government bond yields or estimated losses, the parties are expected to engage in a fierce courtroom examination of whether the evidence meets the high standard required to support fines exceeding KRW 1.6 trillion.


The Ministry of Finance and Economy's request at a full session of the Fair Trade Commission to adjust the severity of the sanctions is also expected to be considered during the trial. Hwang Soonkwan, head of the ministry's Treasury Bureau, appeared at the full session in September 2026 and said there had been a regulatory gap, with no clear standards distinguishing legitimate communications in the government bond market from unlawful collusion. He also warned that harsh sanctions could disrupt government bond issuance and damage the country's international credit standing.



Legal experts, however, believe the ministry's position was largely political in nature. Rather than serving as an independent basis for the court to overturn the finding of illegality, they expect it to be considered as a secondary factor when determining whether the fines violated the principle of proportionality.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing