Comparison of approval ratings and KOSPI closing prices
They do not rise and fall in tandem,
yet the ruling camp treats them as one and the same

President Lee at capital markets policy meeting
"If the valley is deep, perhaps the mountain will be high again"
Remarks that glorify "extreme volatility"

The Kim Dae-jung administration faced a similar situation
"I feel truly remorseful for the pain of so many investors"

Grow exports, revitalize domestic demand, and expand businesses
Strengthen fundamentals rather than prop up the index

How closely are presidential approval ratings correlated with the KOSPI (Korea Composite Stock Price Index)? Do they move in a directly proportional relationship, with approval ratings rising when stock prices rise and falling when they plunge?


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

I analyzed 204 weeks during the Yoon Suk Yeol and Lee Jae-myung administrations, from May 2022 to November 2026, excluding periods when an acting president was in office. The analysis compared Realmeter's regular weekly presidential approval ratings with KOSPI closing prices.


The correlation coefficient (r) between the weekly change in stock prices during the week of an approval poll and the change in approval ratings from the previous week was just 0.017. Conversely, the correlation between changes in approval ratings and stock-price movements in the week after the poll results were announced was only -0.046. A correlation coefficient closer to an absolute value of 1 indicates that two variables move together in a directly or inversely proportional relationship, while a value closer to 0 indicates little or no relationship. By this measure, presidential approval ratings and the KOSPI do not appear to move together on a weekly basis.


Yet the current ruling camp seems to accept “rising stock prices = rising approval ratings” and “falling stock prices = a crisis for the administration” as formulas. During last year's presidential election, President Lee Jae-myung pledged to bring the KOSPI to 5,000, and while he was a candidate, he bought KRW 40 million worth of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tracking the KOSPI and KOSDAQ. He also continued to make optimistic remarks about stock prices. At a press conference marking his 100th day in office, he said, “Even if things just return to normal, stock prices will rise much further from here.” The day after the KOSPI crossed 5,000 intraday, he said, “It seems we may no longer have to worry about the pension fund running out.” The ruling party went further. In February, then-Democratic Party of Korea leader Chung Cheong-rae said, “A KOSPI of 6,000, 7,000, 8,000, 9,000, or even 10,000 is by no means a dream,” invoking the prospect of a “10,000-Point KOSPI.”


Policy has also tilted toward boosting stock prices. President Lee directed officials to consider increasing the National Pension Service's allocation to domestic stocks, and the Fund Management Committee raised its target allocation for domestic equities. The Financial Services Commission allowed the domestic listing of leveraged ETFs that aim to deliver twice the returns of individual stocks such as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix.


The results have been poor. After reaching a record closing high of 9,114.55 on June 22, the KOSPI reversed course and fell to 5,100.50 on November 16. That was a 44.0% plunge in just five months. The National Pension Service, which increased its allocation to domestic stocks, was also hit hard. The value of its holdings in 287 listed companies in which it owned stakes of at least 5% fell by KRW 182 trillion in about 100 days, from KRW 516 trillion at the end of June to KRW 334 trillion on October 15. Samsung Electronics and SK hynix alone accounted for KRW 131 trillion of the decline.


Individual investors have suffered even more directly. Individual investors' total losses on the “Samjeonnikseu” single-stock leveraged ETF, which was listed on May 27, reached KRW 6.3 trillion, with investors aged 70 and older recording the largest average loss per account. The product was criticized for amplifying market volatility through rebalancing just before the market closed, causing it to rise more on up days and fall more on down days.


Even so, the president still seems fixated on the index. On November 13, President Lee attended a capital-markets policy meeting at the Korea Exchange wearing a red tie, a color associated with a rising market. Regarding the recent sharp decline, he said, “The higher the mountain, the deeper the valley,” adding, “Conversely, if the valley is deep, perhaps the mountain will be high again.” With the KOSPI plunging and the National Pension Service and retail investors facing heavy losses, his message amounted to an expression of hope that the market would rise again.


The belief that stock prices are a report card on the administration and a barometer of presidential approval appears unshaken. Three months ago, Bloomberg identified extreme volatility as the biggest problem facing the South Korean stock market, warning that “South Korea is becoming an uninvestable market.” It is disheartening that the president's “high mountains, deep valleys” analogy can be interpreted as glorifying the extreme volatility of the South Korean stock market.


Studies of presidents suggest that they tend to manage public approval by talking about the economy. Every U.S. president who served between 1945 and 2004 sought to justify their performance by touting their record on the economy, unemployment, inflation, and the federal deficit. But with the exception of Donald Trump, few presidents have used stock prices as a measure of their performance. Stock prices are difficult for governments to predict or control. If a president cites them as evidence of the administration's performance, the president's authority will be shaken every time prices fall. Presidents keep their distance from stock prices to protect the stability of their symbolic standing as heads of state.


[Heo Manseop's Deep Learning] The President and Stock Prices, 'A Dangerous Partnership' View original image
[Heo Manseop's Deep Learning] The President and Stock Prices, 'A Dangerous Partnership' View original image

For example, after the U.S. credit rating was downgraded from AAA to AA+ following the close of the stock market on Friday, August 5, 2011, the New York Stock Exchange plunged when it opened on Monday, August 8. Then-President Barack Obama addressed the nation on television in an effort to calm the markets. But after his speech, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell by about another 200 points, eventually closing down 5.6%. Some scholars interpreted the episode as showing that the U.S. president had brought about a decline in his own authority and exposed his powerlessness. The point is that a president need not—and should not—take the risk of being held responsible for falling stock prices.


From the second half of 1998, during the Kim Dae-jung administration, to early 2000, the so-called venture boom drove the KOSDAQ (KOSDAQ Composite Index) up 4.7-fold and the KOSPI up 3.8-fold. But in less than a year, the dot-com bubble burst, and the indices plunged to between one-fifth and one-half of their peaks. The pattern resembles how the KOSPI soared and then sank during the current Lee Jae-myung administration, fueled by the AI semiconductor boom.


But there are three differences between Presidents Kim Dae-jung and Lee Jae-myung. First, unlike President Lee, President Kim did not set a target such as a KOSPI of 5,000. Second, while the Lee administration used the National Pension Service as fuel for a stock-market rally, the Kim administration used pension funds as a safety net to defend the index. Third, after the market crashed, President Lee again voiced hopes for a rebound, saying, “If the valley is deep, perhaps the mountain will be high again.” President Kim, by contrast, apologized, saying, “Whenever I hear reports that many people have suffered heavy losses from stock investments, with families being torn apart or people left with nowhere to go, I feel truly remorseful.”


The Lee administration must break the link it has made between stock prices and its performance or approval ratings. If exports grow, domestic demand is revitalized, and businesses expand, stock prices will follow as a result.



[Heo Manseop's Deep Learning] The President and Stock Prices, 'A Dangerous Partnership' View original image

Heo Man-seop, professor in the Department of Digital Media and Communication at Kangwon National University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing