A system that puts those who disclose AI use at a disadvantage
First, fix the contradiction in "copyright royalty settlements"

Lee Gwangho, Culture and Sports Team Leader

Lee Gwangho, Culture and Sports Team Leader

View original image

Music created by artificial intelligence (AI) has topped music charts, but the royalties have yet to find their rightful recipients. Revenue is generated every time a song is played, yet there are no rules for deciding who should be paid and how much. Unpaid royalties are piling up at music platforms such as Melon and FLO. Technology has changed the market, but the copyright system has failed to keep pace.


Under the current Copyright Act, only works created by humans are protected. Lyrics written by a person can qualify for copyright protection, but melodies generated by AI are not covered. The problem is that there are no clear standards for distinguishing and rewarding human creative contributions to music made with AI. In August, the Korea Music Copyright Association allowed AI-assisted music with substantial human creative input to be registered for collective management, but reversed the decision just 22 days later, citing a lack of social consensus. Registration of such music has been put on hold since then.


The burden of this institutional confusion falls on creators. Disclosing the use of AI can prevent royalties from being settled, while tracks whose AI use is concealed may still be paid under the existing system. This creates a situation in which people who report honestly are penalized. The system's loopholes may encourage people to hide their use of AI and undermine transparency in the market. How to distribute royalties that have already gone unpaid also remains unresolved.


Of course, copyright cannot be granted to every work generated by AI. Careful consideration is needed to determine how much human creative contribution should be protected. But indefinitely delaying royalty settlements in the name of social consensus is no solution either. The government and copyright collective management organizations should establish standards for assessing human creative contributions and improve registration and settlement procedures. They also need to clarify the principles for handling existing unpaid royalties.



AI music is already generating revenue. If the system cannot even establish standards for distributing that revenue to the rightful recipients, its very purpose must be called into question. The contradiction of a system that claims to protect copyright while obstructing creators' compensation must first be corrected.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing