Muan Sarang Elementary School's 1.7 Billion Won Construction Balance Deposited in Full... What's Behind the Rift Between Contractor and Education Office?
Dispute over subcontract increases and deductions after project completion
Prime contractor: "Agreement effectively made a settlement a condition for payment"
Office of Education: "Difficult to determine direct-payment recipients and amounts"
Lawsuit over 85.96 million won in progress payments and late-payment interest
The contractor and the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Office of Education are locked in a sharp dispute over the full deposit in court of the approximately 1.7 billion won balance for the construction of Muan Sarang Elementary School. The contractor argues that the Office of Education effectively made an agreement with the subcontractors a condition for paying the balance, thereby withholding construction payments unrelated to the dispute. The Office of Education, by contrast, says it followed legal procedures.
◆ Construction costs increased after completion; dispute over subcontractor settlements
The construction of Muan Sarang Elementary School, commissioned by the former Jeollanam-do Office of Education in June 2024, was undertaken by A Construction and B Construction, which held 51% and 49% stakes, respectively. The two companies formed a joint venture that signed a construction contract with the Office of Education. During the project, A Construction and B Construction entered into subcontracting agreements with C Construction and D Construction for site preparation and paving, as well as rebar and concrete work.
An amended contract increasing the project cost was signed on March 17, after the school opened on March 2, 2026. As of June 17, 2026, the final contract amount, as shown in a project settlement table released by A Construction, was 19,065,540,000 won.
The dispute began after the total construction cost increased following completion. The central issues were how much of the increase should be reflected in the subcontracting payments and how to handle costs that had already been paid or should be deducted.
The subcontractors are reportedly of the view that the prime contractor did not reflect the increase in the subcontract amounts in a timely manner, despite additional work having been carried out.
A Construction, however, says that it and B Construction reviewed and revised the change-order documents at the request of the client, the Office of Education, and its supervisory team, through to the final post-construction settlement, and that the resulting increases were included in the settlement. Specifically, A Construction says the amount of the joint subcontract involving C Construction and D Construction, another subcontractor, was increased from an initial 7,059,200,000 won to a proposed revised amount of approximately 7,162,900,000 won.
However, it was confirmed that tax invoices for some materials and equipment included in both the original and amended contracts were also issued to the prime contractor. A Construction reportedly argued that these costs should be settled together with labor costs initially advanced by the principal contractor.
As the dispute escalated, C Construction reportedly proposed first changing the contract amount with A Construction and discussing the deductions afterward. However, B Construction, the other member of the joint venture, is said to have indicated that duplicate claims should be identified as items under the subcontract and could not be allocated by cost apportionment, which means distributing costs shared by multiple projects or tasks according to set criteria and assigning them to each project's or task's costs.
The companies' positions were sharply divided.
◆ Deepening rift between prime contractor and Office of Education
Regarding the dispute over payments for the Sarang Elementary School project, the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Office of Education says it deposited the construction payments with the court because the prime contractor and subcontractors failed to reach an agreement.
The Office of Education added that there was a large gap between the payment amounts claimed by the prime contractor and the subcontractors, and that some payments exchanged between the companies were difficult to verify with supporting documents.
It also cited an agreement for direct payment of subcontracting costs, under which the client agrees to pay the subcontractor directly, without routing the construction payment through the prime contractor, as the reason it did not pay the construction costs to the prime contractor.
The Office of Education considered the existing direct-payment agreement terminated after a guarantee was issued during the advance payment process for A Construction, the prime contractor. However, it says it could not determine the final payment amount because no formal termination procedure had taken place among the client, the prime contractor and the subcontractor.
The Office of Education also said it tried to coordinate the matter for nearly a month, including by holding two meetings attended by its facilities department, the supervisory team and both companies. However, the parties disagreed over the amounts previously paid and the amounts actually received, and failed to reach an agreement.
A Construction, meanwhile, says it feels unfairly treated because the Office of Education delayed payment of the entire balance while demanding that the prime contractor and subcontractors agree on a settlement.
Before the school's completion was confirmed, the dispute between the prime contractor and subcontractors reportedly cast doubt on whether the school could open, prompting the Office of Education to strongly urge A Construction to complete the project.
A Construction is confirmed to have completed the project by the deadline after first putting in more than 2 billion won of its own funds.
A Construction says that once the project was completed, the Office of Education effectively decided not to pay the remaining construction balance because of the dispute between the prime contractor and subcontractors, leaving the company in a position where it first had to obtain the subcontractors' consent.
A Construction believes this had the effect of strengthening the subcontractors' bargaining power. It criticized the Office of Education's decision to withhold the entire balance after accepting the subcontractors' claims unilaterally, calling it effectively an abuse of power.
The company says it repeatedly asked for the legal basis for withholding the full payment and also requested disclosure of the legal advice during a meeting, but received no specific explanation.
◆ Dispute over provisional seizure and scope of direct payments
According to the contractor's settlement table, the amount claimed for the final payment upon completion was 1,705,280,000 won. A Construction claimed approximately 1,497,690,000 won, while B Construction claimed approximately 207,590,000 won. After deducting approximately 289,330,000 won in direct payments to subcontractors from the two companies' claims, based on the settlement table, the amount scheduled to be paid to the contractors was approximately 1,415,950,000 won.
The amount of claims provisionally seized and filed with the Office of Education was approximately 660 million won. A separate item relating to B Construction listed a provisional seizure of approximately 1,035,340,000 won, along with details of a deposit made to cancel or release the seizure.
A Construction asked the Office of Education to identify the portion that could not be paid because of provisional seizures and other measures filed with it, and to pay the remainder.
However, the Office of Education argued that, given the agreement to make direct payments to the subcontractors, it could not pay the contractors first without determining the subcontractors' share. With the parties also at odds over the increased construction costs and amounts already paid, and provisional seizure claims having been filed, the Office of Education deposited the full balance of approximately 1.7 billion won with the Gwangju District Court in September 2026.
The key issue surrounding the court deposit is likely to be whether the Office of Education could have determined the amount eligible for initial payment by comparing the direct-payment agreement, the provisional seizure order and the record of payments already made.
◆ Dispute over progress-payment settlement heads to court
A complaint obtained by The Asia Business Daily shows that A Construction filed a lawsuit with the Gwangju District Court against the Office of Education, seeking payment of 85,961,524 won in unpaid progress payments, meaning payments from the client to the contractor for work already completed, and late-payment interest. The issue in the case is how the Office of Education calculated deductions for advance payments when distributing progress payments between the two joint-venture companies during construction.
Of the 2.8 billion won in advance payments, A Construction received 800 million won and B Construction received 2 billion won. A Construction argues that the Office of Education did not account for the actual advance payment received by each company. Instead, it deducted the advance payment and directly paid labor costs from the total progress payment, then distributed the remaining amount according to the companies' 51-to-49 stake ratio, resulting in an underpayment of progress payments to A Construction.
The claim includes approximately 42.92 million won in late-payment interest due to the underpayment of progress payments in each installment, as well as progress payments for the ninth and 10th installments and related interest, which A Construction says were not included in the court deposit.
A Construction is also considering an additional lawsuit concerning the withdrawal of the completion balance deposited with the court. Withdrawal refers to a claim made by a person entitled to receive the deposited funds by applying to the court deposit office for payment.
An A Construction representative said, "As we worked on the school project, we were earnestly asked to complete it in time for the children to start school. We set aside the situations that we foresaw could become problematic in the future and used the company's own funds to finish the work. Now the Office of Education is effectively saying it cannot pay us unless we settle our dispute among ourselves, and we do not know what a powerless construction company is supposed to do. The construction industry is already struggling, and having our money withheld has made things even harder."
In response, the Office of Education said, "The settlement was affected by the fact that the two joint contractors had different proportions of advance payments received and progress payments claimed," adding that it "deeply regrets the lawsuit."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Muan Sarang Elementary School passed its completion inspection in February 2026 and opened on March 2.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.