Korea Zinc: "They cite the plaintiffs' claims as if they were the court's findings"
Young Poong: "We conveyed the ruling as written... The ruling on the merits should be respected"

Korea Zinc criticized MBK Partners and Young Poong, saying they were distorting and overinterpreting the first-instance ruling in a lawsuit seeking to revoke resolutions passed at last year's annual general meeting.

A view of Korea Zinc's Onsan Smelter. Korea Zinc

A view of Korea Zinc's Onsan Smelter. Korea Zinc

View original image

In a statement issued on November 16, Korea Zinc said, "MBK and Young Poong are confusing the market by distorting their own arguments in the ruling as if they were the court's findings."


The lawsuit concerns a dispute over measures taken at Korea Zinc's annual general meeting in March 2025, including restricting Young Poong's voting rights on the basis of a cross-shareholding relationship. Korea Zinc said it would immediately appeal the first-instance ruling.


Korea Zinc emphasized that the Supreme Court had dismissed Young Poong's re-appeal in an earlier case seeking an injunction to suspend the effect of the AGM resolutions. In April 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the lower court's finding that it was difficult to conclude that Korea Zinc's management had committed occupational breach of trust or violated the Fair Trade Act during the management control dispute.


Korea Zinc said that some of the findings in the first-instance ruling in the main lawsuit conflict with existing Supreme Court precedents and the ruling in the injunction case. It said the facts had not changed since the injunction case, despite new disclosures, and that it would fully demonstrate the legal legitimacy of its position during the appeal.


As further grounds, Korea Zinc cited a ruling issued by the Seoul Central District Court last month in a separate lawsuit, which found that Korea Zinc's board had perceived Young Poong and MBK Partners' attempt to take control of the board as a threat.


Korea Zinc said, "They are interpreting a ruling that has not been finalized in a way that favors them and obstructing normal business activities," adding, "We will continue to respond firmly to any attempts to spread distorted claims."


In response, Young Poong issued an additional statement that day, countering, "We simply conveyed the court's findings as stated in the first-instance ruling, and there was no distortion or overinterpretation." Young Poong claimed that the first-instance court had rejected the 2001 Supreme Court precedent cited by Korea Zinc, saying it was "merely an incidental remark and not a key issue."



Young Poong also disputed Korea Zinc's claim that the facts had not changed since the injunction ruling, saying that the main lawsuit had examined new facts, including a 2-hour-and-32-minute delay in opening the annual general meeting in March 2025 and the additional purchase of 1,350 Young Poong shares.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing