AI-Sung Song Tops Melon for First Time... Despite Hit, Royalties Are "0 Won"
Human-Written Lyrics, AI-Composed Music
Listeners in Their 30s and 40s Make Up 66%
Lyrics Capturing the Anxieties of Adulthood Resonate
Gap in Standards for Copyright Royalty Payments
A song composed and sung by artificial intelligence (AI) has topped Melon, South Korea's largest music streaming platform, for the first time. Listeners in their 30s and 40s have embraced it, propelling it past new releases by idol groups. Yet the creators behind the hit have not received a single penny in royalties. While AI is reshaping the music market, critics say systems to protect creators' rights are failing to keep pace with technological advances.
According to the music industry on November 17, "Did You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of?" by the AI music project MEOMURU ranked No. 1 on Melon's Top 100 chart as of 9 a.m. that day. It first reached the top spot at 5 p.m. on November 13 and remained there for its fourth consecutive day. This is the first time music created with AI-assisted composition and vocals has reached No. 1 on Melon's Top 100.
Released on June 23, the song is a rock ballad about the gap between the adult someone dreamed of becoming as a child and the reality they face after growing up. It sings of the reality of still living with financial pressures and anxiety about the future, despite having believed that everything would get better upon becoming an adult. After spreading as background music on social media platforms such as Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts, it entered the top ranks of major music charts. Without the backing of a large fan base, it surpassed new releases by idol groups such as RESCENE and ILLIT.
Listeners in their 30s and 40s have driven the song's success. By age group, listeners in their 30s made up the largest share on Melon at 36%, followed by those in their 40s at 30%, 20s at 19%, and 50s at 11%. Listeners in their 30s and 40s accounted for 66% of the total. The lyrics, "Did you become the adult you dreamed of? The worries I didn't know as a child are quietly settling on my shoulders one by one, weighing me down," appear to have resonated with a generation grappling with concerns about work, making a living, and the future.
MEOMURU is an AI music project, not an actual singer. It was conceived by the production team Glorywave, comprising composer and producer Lee Yongseok (Martin East) and Choi Seonghyeok (Bitjaru). The two have worked on ballad productions for artists including Hwang Chiyeul, Gilgu Bonggu, and Kim Junsu.
Humans and AI shared the work during production. Glorywave set the lyrics and the song's overall direction, then used the music-generation AI SUNO to create the melody, arrangement, and vocals. After comparing multiple AI-generated versions, the team revised the song's structure, melody, and chord progression in the music production software Cubase. They repeatedly adjusted the lyrics and syllables and generated the vocals again when the AI's Korean pronunciation or emotional delivery sounded awkward.
Although AI created the music, the human creators' judgment determined the song's quality. AI reproduced human vocal delivery and emotional expression with precision, but people decided how to express in lyrics the dreams of childhood and the anxieties of adulthood. The creators also had to intervene to select and refine, from among the melodies and voices generated by AI, the results that suited the song's intent.
"AI can quickly generate a variety of melodies and voices based on the conditions entered, but it does not always accurately convey the emotions intended by the creator," said a music industry source. "If you generate it again to revise a particular section, other parts you were satisfied with may also change."
The arrival of AI is also lowering barriers to entering music production. Previously, production required multiple steps, including composition and arrangement, recruiting musicians, and recording guide vocals. Generative AI can greatly reduce the time and costs needed to produce music. However, as music becomes easier to generate, the ability to decide what story to tell and which results to select and develop from among countless options is emerging as a key competitive factor.
The problem is copyright. Glorywave, which produced "Did You Become the Adult You Dreamed Of?," has been unable to register the song with the Korea Music Copyright Association for collective management and therefore has not received royalties for lyrics, composition, or arrangement. The song has become popular enough to top the music charts, but no copyright revenue is going to its creators.
Current copyright law recognizes only works created by humans as eligible for protection. Lyrics written directly by a person may be recognized as copyrighted separately from an AI-generated melody, but no specific standards have been established for distinguishing and compensating the human creative contributions in AI-assisted music. In August, the Korea Music Copyright Association allowed AI-assisted music to be registered for collective management if it had been substantially created by a human, but withdrew the criteria just 22 days later, citing the need for further public discussion. Registration of related music for collective management is currently on hold.
With royalty payments stalled, money that cannot be distributed is accumulating at music platforms. At a National Assembly forum on September 22, Shin Jiyoung, a director at Kakao Entertainment, which operates Melon, called for standards for calculating payments, saying, "There is no way for music sites to handle copyright royalties on their own." Revenue is generated when music is played, but the money remains undistributed because there are no rules determining who should receive royalties or how much.
Experts warn that the regulatory gap could work to the disadvantage of creators who transparently disclose their use of AI. "As the lack of standards drags on, people who report their use of AI honestly are being disadvantaged," said Kim Hyunsook, director of the Digital Intellectual Property Research Institute, at a National Assembly forum on October 27.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim stressed, "We need to find solutions to questions such as what standards are needed to ensure that creators who disclose their use of AI are not disadvantaged, what roles collective management organizations and the government should each play, and how to handle the undistributed royalties that have already accumulated."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.