NH Investment & Securities’ 100-Year Life Research Institute Report
"Check Maturities and Early Termination Terms
A Principal-and-Interest Guarantee Is Not the Same as Deposit Protection"

Should investors choose principal-and-interest-protected products, which account for more than three-quarters of retirement pension assets, based solely on their interest rates (returns)? Investors focus on interest rates when selecting products to maximize returns while reducing the risk of losing principal. However, experts advise investors to understand factors such as maturity, early termination conditions, and deposit protection before making investment decisions.


According to the financial investment industry on Nov. 17, principal-and-interest-protected retirement pension assets totaled 378.1 trillion won at the end of last year, accounting for 75.4% of all retirement pension assets. Performance-based products totaled 123.3 trillion won, or 24.6%. In the "THE100 Report," Kim Young-jeong, a research fellow at NH Investment & Securities' 100-Year Life Research Institute, said that although the share of performance-based products has recently increased, principal-and-interest-protected products still have a role to play depending on factors such as when an investor plans to retire. "As retirement assets grow and the range of products available expands, principal-and-interest-protected products are increasingly useful from the perspective of 'which funds within one's total retirement assets should be kept safe, and until when,'" she said.


There are several types of principal-and-interest-protected products. The most common include banks' time and savings deposits, as well as insurance products such as guaranteed-interest and interest-rate-linked insurance. A guaranteed interest contract (GIC) applies the interest rate set at enrollment for a specified guarantee period, while an interest-rate-linked product has a variable rate that reflects the rate announced by the insurer at regular intervals. Principal-and-interest-protected products offered by securities firms include equity-linked debentures (ELBs) and repurchase agreements (RPs). Since September, individual investors have also been able to invest in Treasury bonds for individual investors through defined contribution (DC) and individual retirement pension (IRP) plans.


My Retirement Pension Is “Principal-and-Interest-Guaranteed,” Yet I Lost Money? Here’s Why View original image

Maturity Matters as Much as Interest Rates

With principal-and-interest protection as a given, investors seek out high-interest products among these categories. But "maturity management" is also considered an important factor affecting returns. For individual-investor Treasury bonds held in retirement pension accounts, the coupon rate and an additional rate are combined and compounded annually until maturity, with principal and interest paid in a lump sum at maturity. The coupon rate is the "base interest" determined at issuance based on the winning bid rate for government bonds. It applies whether the investor redeems the bond early or holds it to maturity. The additional rate is an extra rate added as a bonus for holding the bond to maturity. For bonds issued last September, the 10-year bonds had a coupon rate of 4.415% and an additional rate of 0.350%, while the 20-year bonds had a coupon rate of 4.570% and an additional rate of 0.350%.


Most Treasury bonds for individual investors have long maturities of 10 or 20 years, so those nearing retirement should exercise caution. Early redemption is allowed one year after the issuance date, but in that case, the additional rate and the benefit of annual compounding are lost, and only the coupon rate is applied on a simple-interest basis. These bonds also have clear advantages and disadvantages because investors are locked into a fixed rate for an extended period. "When interest rates fall, these bonds can reduce reinvestment risk. However, investors should also consider that if rates rise, they may be stuck with a lower rate for an extended period compared with newly issued products," Kim explained.


Investors should also consider the maturity dates of principal-and-interest-protected products offered by securities firms, banks, and insurers. If they fail to check a product's maturity date, their funds may be left idle as cash or cash-equivalent assets. This is because the introduction of the default option system ended the automatic renewal of time deposits and GICs. When a product matures, investors must check the prevailing interest rate and decide whether to reinvest in the same product or switch to another one. ELBs and RPs also repay the funds in cash upon maturity, so investors should track their maturity dates when managing these products.


The way losses are calculated upon early termination or redemption also varies by product. Time deposits have an early withdrawal rate, while GICs have a product-specific termination rate, so investors should check the terms. In particular, early redemption of an ELB may result in losses due to a decline in the value of its underlying asset, and, depending on the product's terms, could even lead to a loss of principal. The issuer may redeem an ELB early for reasons such as the delisting of its underlying stock, in which case the investor bears any resulting losses.


Kim advised, "Rather than having all principal-and-interest-protected assets mature at the same time, investors can reduce both reinvestment risk from interest rate fluctuations and liquidity risk by staggering maturities to match when they will need the funds, such as at one, three, five, 10, and 20 years."


Principal-and-Interest Protection Is Not the Same as Deposit Protection

My Retirement Pension Is “Principal-and-Interest-Guaranteed,” Yet I Lost Money? Here’s Why View original image

Investors should also check whether the products they have enrolled in are covered by deposit protection. DC and IRP plans protect only the assets invested in products eligible for deposit protection. The protection limit is applied separately from that for ordinary deposits and savings accounts, up to a maximum of 100 million won per person at each financial institution providing the product. For example, if someone deposits 100 million won in an ordinary account at Bank A and another 100 million won in a deposit through an IRP, both amounts are fully protected, for a total of 200 million won. Likewise, if an IRP account holds 100 million won in deposits at Bank B and another 100 million won at Bank C, the full 200 million won is protected.


Most deposit-based principal-and-interest-protected products are eligible for deposit protection, but not all such products are covered. Treasury bonds for individual investors are not covered by the Depositor Protection Act, but the government, as the issuer of the bonds, is responsible for repaying principal and interest. ELBs and RPs issued by securities firms are not covered by the Act. Therefore, the creditworthiness of the issuer and counterparty is crucial when investing in ELBs and RPs. If the issuing securities firm goes bankrupt, investors may not recover their principal or returns, even if the stated return conditions have been met.



"The key is not to focus solely on interest rates, but to match product maturities with when you will need liquidity," Kim said. "It is advisable to divide funds into short-, medium-, and long-term categories, diversify the entities responsible for repayment and the protection structures, and allocate long-term funds intended for use in 10 to 20 years appropriately between these products and growth assets, taking early redemption penalties into account."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing