Youngone Wins Three Straight in International Arbitration, Secures 'SCOTT'
Concluded after more than four years against second-largest shareholder
Collaboration between Kim & Chang and Swiss law firm proves decisive
Youngone Corporation was confirmed to have won all three rulings in late October in an International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) arbitration that it had pursued for more than four years against the second-largest shareholder of Swiss premium bicycle brand SCOTT.
The case marks the successful completion of a strategic investment aimed at expanding a Korean company's business model to directly own and manage a global sports brand. It is considered highly unusual, particularly because Youngone won the case in full under Swiss law in an arbitration seated in Switzerland against a prominent Swiss businessperson.
Kim & Chang, which represented Youngone, is credited with bringing the dispute to a swift close using a three-stage arbitration strategy developed with Swiss law firm Lenz & Staehelin.
Procedural Bifurcation Strategy Brings Early Resolution
The dispute began after Youngone acquired a 20% stake in 2013 and a further 30.01% stake in 2015, becoming the largest shareholder, and then entered into a shareholders' agreement with Swiss entrepreneur Beat Zaugg, who was the second-largest shareholder and chief executive officer (CEO). The agreement included a "call option" clause allowing one party to buy the other party's shares if that party materially breached the agreement. After Zaugg materially breached the agreement in September 2022, Youngone decided to acquire his 46.7% stake by exercising the call option and filed for arbitration with the ICC.
Under the agreement, the arbitration was structured to first determine whether the call option could be exercised and then calculate the purchase price of the shares. In its first ruling in February 2025, the arbitral tribunal found that Zaugg had materially breached the agreement and confirmed Youngone's call option right.
The issue was the share purchase price. The agreement contained a provision, in the nature of a penalty, allowing the price to be reduced by up to 25% if the other party materially breached the agreement. Youngone sought a price reduction, but Zaugg argued that reducing the price by the full 25% would be excessive. Waiting for the dispute to be resolved would inevitably delay the transaction.
Kim & Chang proposed splitting the proceedings. Youngone would first pay the undisputed 75% and take over the shares, while the disputed 25% would be placed in escrow, a third-party safekeeping arrangement, with the tribunal to determine who was entitled to it in the third arbitration. The tribunal accepted the proposal, and in December 2025, Youngone received 5,837,500 of Zaugg's shares, raising its stake to 96.71%.
The third ruling upheld Youngone's claim for a 25% price reduction in full. The 4.77 million Swiss francs (approximately KRW 7.6 billion) held in escrow was to be returned to Youngone, and the final acquisition price was set at 14.31 million Swiss francs (approximately KRW 23 billion at current exchange rates), down from the initially calculated 19.08 million Swiss francs. The dispute was fully resolved on October 27, 2026.
Yang Youngjun and attorney Kim Seyeon of Kim & Chang, who are members of the firm's litigation team and graduated from the Judicial Research and Training Institute in its 7th and 23rd classes, respectively, are said to have personally overseen every aspect of the case, from selecting Swiss counsel to preparing for arbitration and developing the strategy. Kim said, "The significance of this case is that a Korean investor effectively secured full control of a foreign company, where the overseas founder had been deeply involved in its management, based on its contractual rights." He added that the case showed how protections such as call options can be effective in international arbitration as Korean companies increase their overseas investments.
"A Decision to Stand by Principle"
Sung Raeun, vice chairman of Youngone Group, is said to have played a decisive role in the victory through her leadership and involvement. The second daughter of Chairman Sung Kihak, she joined Youngone in 2002, became president overseeing sales and management in 2020, and was appointed group vice chairman in November 2022. Resolving the dispute over control of SCOTT was the first challenge she faced around the time she became vice chairman.
Sung reversed the company's previous approach to resolving disputes with overseas companies, which had relied on lukewarm settlements or reconciliation to smooth things over. Her position was that "we must respond in accordance with principle." With Sung leading the effort, the team handling the case was reportedly nicknamed the "Sung Raeun Team."
Sung told The Law Times, "I had to make big and small decisions every day. I had to anticipate the other party's way of thinking and how it would respond, carefully consider the legal implications and repercussions, and then make a measured decision. I vividly remember how intensely and meticulously we worked from the early stages of arbitration. I was determined to stay closely connected around the clock with the situation rooms in Korea and Switzerland, and we devoted tremendous effort to seeing this through."
The final rulings resolved the legal dispute over the acquisition of the SCOTT stake and the related financial settlement, also eliminating uncertainty surrounding SCOTT's ownership structure.
Youngone is reportedly planning to continue investing in SCOTT following the resolution of the dispute. SCOTT is a premium sports brand known globally for its high-performance bicycles, which feature proprietary suspension technology and lightweight designs. A Youngone representative said, "Through continued investment, we will further strengthen SCOTT's technological capabilities and product competitiveness, and contribute to job creation in Switzerland."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Jisu, The Law Times reporter
※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.