"This incident was caused by a hack targeting a private company's own system, but I sincerely apologize for the worry and inconvenience you have experienced."


On November 14, shortly after the information leak involving Startup for All happened again, the Ministry of SMEs and Startups posted an apology on its official platform with this message. It is difficult to shake the impression that the ministry was shifting some of the responsibility by framing the incident as "a problem with a private company's system." The ministry emphasized this point in an explanatory statement released the same day. To be sure, the ministry's explanation is not wrong. It cannot exercise detailed, complete control over a private company's systems, and the fact that the incident resulted from an external hack means that some aspects were beyond its control.


Even so, the ministry's responsibility for management and oversight does not disappear simply because it is the agency in charge of designing and operating the program. The applicants took on a difficult challenge because of the symbolic significance of the government’s ambitious project, not because they were drawn to the proprietary system of some unfamiliar private company.

Lee So-young, Minister of SMEs and Startups, delivers remarks at the launch ceremony for the second cohort of Everyone's Startup, held at SVC in Mapo-gu, Seoul, on the 20th of last month. Yonhap News

Lee So-young, Minister of SMEs and Startups, delivers remarks at the launch ceremony for the second cohort of Everyone's Startup, held at SVC in Mapo-gu, Seoul, on the 20th of last month. Yonhap News

View original image

There is another reason the ministry's position gives pause. The ministry said that when it selected 50 providers of artificial intelligence (AI) solutions for applicants to use, including the company where the incident occurred last month, experts in AI and software technology had comprehensively assessed the providers' security systems as well. After summaries of 5,000 startup ideas and other information were leaked from the official platform last June, the ministry also promised to prevent a recurrence. Given that the same thing has happened again, it is difficult for the ministry to downplay its responsibility.


The company where the incident occurred is a small startup with annual revenue of 500 million won and around 30 employees. This does not excuse the company's responsibility, but the ministry, which said it had brought in experts to evaluate the providers, announced immediately after the incident that it would consider revoking the company's selection. This could easily be seen as an attempt to cut off the tail. Moreover, its belated move to crack down on the other 49 providers is far from the image of an agency that has long presented itself as a steadfast supporter of startups.


There is no undoing what has been done. The right course is therefore to take full responsibility for this incident, carefully review whether the security assessment standards and criteria used to select participating companies were appropriate and whether proper management and oversight were carried out after selection, and transparently disclose the findings.



The incident took place at a private company, but the Ministry of SMEs and Startups evaluated and selected that company, and it alone held both the authority and responsibility for the assessment. The ministry was also the one that connected companies with applicants and provided support so they could use AI solutions. It will be difficult to preserve the value of government-supported projects and trust in them if the ministry acts as though it can separate authority from responsibility.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing