Reflecting survey results from 1,336 sixth-grade civil servants
... An overwhelming 84.5% support abolition

Changwon Special City in Gyeongsangnam-do has decided to completely abolish the "fifth-grade promotion competency assessment pass" system, which has drawn criticism for focusing sixth-grade civil servants on test-taking skills and causing excessive stress and a waste of administrative resources as they seek promotion to fifth grade.


As part of its "overhaul of customary and unnecessary programs," an innovation initiative being pursued under its ninth popularly elected administration, Changwon Special City will completely revamp the system for sixth-grade civil servants at the team-leader level, replacing it with a "competency training completion system."

Changwon Special City Hall. [Photo courtesy of Changwon City]

Changwon Special City Hall. [Photo courtesy of Changwon City]

View original image

The "Fifth-Grade Competency Assessment PASS System" was introduced to assess the job performance capabilities of candidates for promotion to administrative officer. However, it has faced criticism for prioritizing the acquisition of "test-taking skills" over practical job capabilities. It has also led to adverse effects, including excessive psychological stress and work disruptions during assessment preparation, as well as losses in administrative capacity and budget due to travel to training institutions far from the workplace.


In response, the Changwon City civil servants' union surveyed 1,336 sixth-grade civil servants among its members from October 1 to 6. The results showed that 84.5% of respondents supported abolishing the PASS system. In addition, 81.6% said it was inefficient in terms of the time and budget involved, underscoring the urgent need for a complete overhaul of the current system.


In particular, respondents cited the system's limited contribution to improving job capabilities (71.3%), its focus on test-taking skills (56.3%), and psychological fatigue and lowered morale among those who did not pass as key problems.


To address civil servants' dissatisfaction and administrative waste, Changwon City plans to abolish the competency assessment PASS system and incorporate promotion requirements into the "annual mandatory hours for ongoing learning (80 hours)" framework under the local government officials' education and training guidelines, easing the burden of exams on civil servants.


At the same time, the city will establish a "tailored competency training program for fifth-grade managers" within its recognized ongoing-learning courses to strengthen the essential leadership and policy-planning skills expected of fifth-grade managers. The program will be available to those who wish to apply and participate voluntarily, rather than requiring completion or assessment through an exam, creating an environment for competency development centered on voluntary growth rather than evaluation and stigma.


Changwon City plans to continue operating the existing competency assessment PASS system through 2027 and introduce the new "competency training completion system" after a one-year grace period.


Lee Yujeong, Director of the Autonomous Administration Bureau, said, "Abolishing the fifth-grade competency assessment PASS system is a good example of personnel reform that has decisively eliminated unnecessary administrative procedures that had become customary and the psychological burden on employees. We will continue to identify and overhaul unnecessary, customary programs and systems to energize the organization and further improve administrative productivity in ways that citizens can feel."



Changwon City's sweeping reform of the unnecessary system previously used for promotions from sixth to fifth grade is expected to bring renewed energy to the civil service.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing