UK-Based Asset Manager AVI: "We Oppose Daou Technology's Acquisition of JoongAng Ilbo"
Daou Technology shareholder with a 2.2% stake
"High acquisition price and lack of strategic rationale"
Asset Value Investors (AVI), a UK-based asset manager that holds approximately 2.2% of Daou Technology, has issued an open letter opposing Daou Technology's acquisition of JoongAng Ilbo. It cited three reasons for its opposition: a high acquisition price despite the unknown scale of potential liabilities; the lack of a strategic rationale for pursuing the investment; and the possibility of a wider discount in the share price.
On November 16, AVI said, "We are issuing an open letter so that all shareholders and market participants can assess the merits of this investment." It asked Daou Technology's board to issue a public response by November 30 at the latest.
Daou Technology, along with Saramin, CJ and Shinsegae, has been selected as the preferred bidder for the acquisition of JoongAng Ilbo. Its board subsequently resolved to acquire 38 million newly issued shares in JoongAng Ilbo for KRW 190 billion. The consortium as a whole signed a conditional share subscription agreement worth a total of KRW 520 billion.
AVI sent a private letter to Daou Technology's board on October 21. It received a response from the board on October 30, but concluded that "the response did not address our key concerns."
AVI said, "The acquisition price should be assessed in light of JoongAng Ilbo's low profitability and deteriorating financial condition." It added, "The company should disclose the valuation methodology and assumptions underlying the acquisition price, the post-investment equity value implied by that price, the expected and minimum rates of return on the capital invested, and the investment recovery period."
AVI also called for a "transparent explanation" of why the consortium's KRW 520 billion bid substantially exceeded the KRW 300 billion to KRW 400 billion range for competing bids initially reported in the media.
"No connection to existing businesses; concerns over a wider discount"
AVI argued that "Daou Technology has failed to present a substantive and valid rationale to support its investment decision." It added, "The newspaper industry has no connection to Daou Technology's existing businesses, such as financial IT, messaging and groupware, and diversification alone cannot be considered sufficient to create shareholder value."
Under current law, large business groups are limited to holding a 50% stake in a newspaper company. AVI said, "If additional funding is needed in the future, Daou Technology will have to share management control with CJ while also bearing the associated responsibility." It added, "Apart from any group-level objectives, we have not received a sufficient explanation of what reasonable returns this investment will provide to Daou Technology shareholders."
AVI expressed concern that "the acquisition of JoongAng Ilbo could further complicate Daou Technology's corporate governance and widen the discount in its share price." As of October 30, Daou Technology's share price was, according to AVI's estimate, trading at a 62% discount to its net asset value (NAV, the value of assets held minus liabilities).
AVI explained, "This discount reflects investors' concerns about capital allocation and the complex intermediate holding-company structure, rather than the quality of Daou Technology's assets." It added, "If the burden of jointly managing a loss-making newspaper company with uncertain future funding needs is added to these concerns, they will intensify and the discount on the share price will widen further."
AVI calls on Daou Technology to buy back shares and establish a special committee
AVI argued, "If Daou Technology buys back and cancels its shares while they are trading at an approximately 62% discount, it could cancel shares worth an estimated KRW 2,630 in NAV for every KRW 1,000 spent on the buyback, excluding transaction costs." Daou Technology's investment commitment of KRW 190 billion represents approximately 14% of its market capitalization. Including the investment in Saramin, the Daou Group's total investment amounts to approximately KRW 261.4 billion.
AVI recalled that Daou Technology's management said last September that it would consider a share buyback after its data center became operational. It stressed, "If funds cannot be used for a share buyback at this point, they should not be used to invest in a newspaper company undergoing a workout either."
AVI said Daou Technology should clearly explain the rationale for pursuing the investment and the results of the board's independent review. In particular, it called for three reviews: valuation; financial and legal due diligence; and review and assessment by independent directors.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
AVI said, "A special committee composed of independent directors should be established and supported by external advisers free of conflicts of interest to independently review this investment based on the legitimacy of the transaction's purpose, the fairness of its terms and the appropriateness of the decision-making process." It added, "The special committee should review all remaining key decisions through the closing of the transaction and report its findings and recommendations to the board."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.