Min Hee-jin wins first trial in damages suits brought by two HYBE labels
The court: "A subjective assessment of similarities between creative works"
Belift Lab and Source Music: "We will appeal immediately"

Belift Lab, a label under HYBE, lost a KRW 2 billion damages lawsuit against Min Hee-jin, former CEO of ADOR and current CEO of OK Records. The court ruled that Min’s remarks that girl group ILLIT had copied NewJeans were an expression of subjective opinion, not the dissemination of false information.


According to Yonhap News on November 14, the 12th Civil Division of the Seoul Western District Court, presided over by Judge Kim Jinyoung, ruled the previous day against Belift Lab in its damages lawsuit against Min.


BELIFT LAB and Source Music lost their first-instance damages suit seeking 2 billion won from former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin. Yonhap News Agency

BELIFT LAB and Source Music lost their first-instance damages suit seeking 2 billion won from former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The lawsuit began after Min claimed in an April 2024 press conference and in written statements that ILLIT had copied NewJeans’ hairstyles, makeup, choreography, concepts and other elements. Belift Lab, ILLIT’s agency, sought KRW 2 billion in damages, arguing that Min’s claims were false and had damaged the reputations of the company and its artists.


The court, however, viewed Min’s remarks not as statements of specific facts but as a subjective assessment of similarities between creative works. It said the remarks should be judged based on how an ordinary person who had watched the press conference in its entirety would have understood them, rather than by considering isolated expressions from the remarks.


The court also ruled that even if the remarks were interpreted as statements of fact, they fell within the scope of protected freedom of expression, given that the matter was of considerable public interest.


The court also dismissed Min’s countersuit against Belift Lab, in which she sought KRW 5 billion in damages. As a result, neither side’s damages claims against the other were granted.


NewJeans during their activities as a five-member group. ADOR

NewJeans during their activities as a five-member group. ADOR

View original image

The ruling also addressed a lawsuit brought by another HYBE label, Source Music. Source Music, the agency of LE SSERAFIM, sought KRW 500 million in damages, alleging that Min had made false claims about NewJeans’ debut process and the management of its trainees.


The court also dismissed Source Music’s claim. It found that it was difficult to conclude that Min’s statements about the order in which NewJeans members debuted were false. The court acknowledged that Source Music debuted LE SSERAFIM before NewJeans, but said it had found no evidence that Min had exercised decision-making authority over the changes to the debut plans at the time.


Following the ruling, Min’s representatives welcomed the decision, saying the judiciary had reached a common-sense conclusion. Belift Lab, meanwhile, expressed regret over the ruling and said it would immediately appeal. The company said it was difficult to accept that responsibility had not been recognized despite clear evidence of harm, on the grounds that the remarks were expressions of opinion or rhetorical language.



Source Music also expressed regret over the first-instance ruling and said it would appeal. Both companies said they would challenge the ruling’s validity in a higher court.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing