Valid Points Overshadowed by 'Unbridled Scolding'... First Administrative Audit of Integrated Education Office Ends on a 'Bitter Note'
13-Day Marathon Concludes... Widespread Lack of Understanding of Conditions on the Ground Amid Questions on Key Issues
Questions Lacking Facts and High-Handed Attitudes Mar Audit... Assembly Must Build Expertise and Offer Alternatives
The first administrative audit of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Office of Education, which was launched last July, concluded on the 13th.
The audit was intended to review the budget and administration as a whole, reflecting the importance of laying the foundation for the integrated education office. However, the final assessment is that it left deep disappointment, as some lawmakers adopted a high-handed attitude and posed “substandard” questions that disregarded conditions on the ground.
The first administrative audit of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Office of Education concluded its 13-day marathon.
Reporter Lee Jun-kyung
Positive Results in Exposing Budget Leakage, Safety Concerns and Gaps in Career Guidance
The audit covered the integrated education office’s budget planning and major pending issues. Committee Chair Choi Jeonghun criticized the omission of 100 billion won in legally mandated transfers allocated to the former Gwangju Metropolitan Office of Education from the 2026 main budget, as well as education chiefs’ inadequate knowledge of their duties. He also pointed out that teachers’ professional learning communities had lost sight of their original purpose and devolved into social gatherings.
Questions from some lawmakers that reflected the characteristics of the expanded jurisdiction of the integrated office also drew attention. Assemblyman Seo Yeongbae raised the issue of access to career guidance centers for students living far away. He called for practical support measures, including establishing regional hubs, to prevent educational disparities between areas, earning positive reviews.
Assemblyman Kim Jinnam pointed out that survival swimming lessons at schools remained largely formulaic, focused on simply filling class time, and were therefore ineffective. He called for substantive instruction directly related to students’ lives. He also highlighted the extent of drug use and misuse of drugs among adolescents and called for the education office to take action, winning support.
Efforts to uncover administrative blind spots continued, including Assemblyman Jeong Giseong’s raising concerns about ground subsidence at Muan Haengbok Elementary School, now in its sixth year since opening, and Assemblywoman Park Jeongseon’s criticism of the education superintendent’s office for submitting uniform and inadequate materials.
Education Staff Treated as Potential Criminals... Threats of Punishment for Perjury Chill Audit Room
However, the outdated attitude displayed by some lawmakers during questioning left a painful stain on the proceedings. The most serious criticism concerned lawmakers’ high-handed treatment of the institutions under audit.
One lawmaker repeatedly told education staff who were responding to questions during the audit period, “If you lie or give false testimony, I will punish you,” creating an atmosphere that seemed to treat them as potential criminals under interrogation. The bullying, which went beyond creating healthy tension and reached the point of humiliation, drew criticism for undermining public officials’ morale and lowering the dignity of the assembly itself.
Audits conducted in a “armchair theory” style, in which lawmakers raised their voices without understanding the realities and systems of education, also left much to be desired. Some lawmakers demanded forced answers on matters that had been decided autonomously in response to parents’ surveys and requests, or on issues that the education office could not realistically intervene in or mandate. In effect, they imposed their own standards while disregarding the autonomy and limitations of those working in the field.
Moreover, some lawmakers appeared more intent on asking abstract questions disconnected from conditions on the ground, relying solely on the one-sided claims of a few informants without thoroughly analyzing materials or familiarizing themselves with the situation firsthand.
The practice of wasting precious audit time with incomprehensible questions whose point was impossible to grasp, or of dragging things out by demanding unreasonable answers, was criticized for greatly lowering the standard of the administrative audit.
More Than Criticism, Practical Alternatives Are Needed... The Assembly Must Build Its Own Expertise
The Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Office of Education is an unprecedentedly large integrated organization, making sharp oversight and constructive alternatives from the assembly more essential than ever. But bullying, forced logic and indiscriminate questioning without fact-checking cannot set the integrated education office on the right course.
A member of the education community who observed the end of the administrative audit said, “Correcting bad practices is naturally the assembly’s duty, but shouting and lecturing should not become the entirety of an audit.” The source added, “I hope lawmakers will thoroughly study conditions on the ground themselves and show the image of a mature assembly by offering practical alternatives instead of forced criticism.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
One audit alone cannot solve everything, but this first administrative audit, which exposed both a high-handed attitude and a clear lack of expertise, concluded after leaving a weighty challenge not only for the executive branch but also for the assembly itself.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.