'Verbal Abuse' Controversy: Criminal Complaint Filed Against Choi Minhee, Followed by Human Rights Commission Petition Calling for Assembly Discipline and Committee Reassignment
"Character assassination of journalists, violation of freedom of the press"
'Calls for recommendation urging the National Assembly and Democratic Party to initiate disciplinary proceedings'
Should step down from the National Assembly's Culture, Spor
Choi Minhee, a Supreme Council member of the Democratic Party of Korea, came under fire for “harsh remarks” after writing “a pack of hyenas” about photo and video journalists in a KakaoTalk group chat that included members of her constituency. After being criminally accused of defamation, she also faced a petition to the National Human Rights Commission of Korea calling for disciplinary action by the National Assembly and the Democratic Party, as well as a recommendation that she be removed from or reassigned on the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee, of which she is a member.
Lee Jongbae, a former Seoul city council member, said on the morning of November 13 that he had submitted a petition to the National Human Rights Commission of Korea through the e-People portal, alleging that Supreme Council member Choi’s disparagement of journalists violated their human rights.
Choi Minhee, a Supreme Council member of the Democratic Party of Korea embroiled in controversy over her “harsh remarks,” skipped the party’s open Supreme Council meeting on the morning of the 13th and held a press conference at the National Assembly Communication Hall alongside fellow Supreme Council members Lee Seongyun and Han Minsu, who are considered part of the pro-Jeong Cheong-rae faction. Photo by Yoon Dongju
View original imageOn November 5, Supreme Council member Choi posted in a KakaoTalk group chat for Democratic Party members in Namyangju, including local party members, a photo of photo and video journalists covering a Democratic Party lawmakers’ meeting. She wrote, “a pack of hyenas” and “They’re doing that to film footage that will somehow drive a wedge between people.”
On November 11, after a media outlet published a screenshot of the Namyangju party members’ group chat containing the controversial photo and comments, Supreme Council member Choi posted an apology on Facebook, writing, “I acknowledge that my wording was excessive and inappropriate, and I apologize.” That same day, she also held an apology press conference at the National Assembly Communication Hall.
In his petition, former council member Lee claimed, “Supreme Council member Choi’s outrageous remarks, calling journalists who went to the scene at the request of reporters ‘a pack of hyenas’ and saying ‘They’re doing that to film footage that will somehow drive a wedge between people,’ are a horrific form of character assassination that tramples on those journalists’ dignity and sense of purpose.” He added, “Her remarks inflicted indelible humiliation and hurt on journalists who work in the field with a sense of duty to serve as the eyes and ears of the public, and violated their constitutional right to personal dignity by undermining that dignity.”
He also said, “If supporters of a particular political camp go so far as to attack journalists, that could deter journalists from freely reporting. Supreme Council member Choi’s criticism of journalists therefore violated press freedom.”
Former council member Lee said, “Supreme Council member Choi mocked and disparaged innocent journalists, violating the affected journalists’ constitutional right to personal dignity and deterring legitimate reporting activities, thereby infringing on press freedom. I ask the National Human Rights Commission of Korea to recommend that the Speaker of the National Assembly take strong measures, including initiating disciplinary proceedings under the National Assembly Act and related regulations; that the Democratic Party take responsible action, including disciplinary measures under its constitution and rules; and that the Speaker and the Democratic Party establish effective human rights education and institutional reforms to prevent a recurrence.”
Former council member Lee also took issue with the apology Supreme Council member Choi posted on Facebook after the controversy erupted.
He said, “After the controversy broke out, Supreme Council member Choi posted on Facebook on November 11 and reportedly apologized, saying, ‘I acknowledge that my wording was excessive and inappropriate, and I apologize.’ The implication is that the content was not wrong, but the way it was expressed was problematic. This is not an apology; it is secondary victimization.”
He continued, “The act of making outrageous remarks to journalists engaged in legitimate reporting, calling them ‘a pack of hyenas’ and saying ‘They’re doing that to film footage that will somehow drive a wedge between people,’ was itself seriously wrong. The issue is not that the wording was excessive or inappropriate.” He added, “An apology saying ‘the wording was excessive’ or ‘inappropriate’ is a sordid excuse that refuses to acknowledge any wrongdoing and further victimizes the journalists.”
Former council member Lee also argued that Supreme Council member Choi should resign from the National Assembly’s Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee or be assigned to another standing committee.
He said, “Supreme Council member Choi has an arrogant and hostile view of the media and is an extremely dangerous person to serve on the National Assembly’s Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee, which reviews laws and policies related to newspapers, news agencies and online media.” He added, “If this view is reflected in legislative activities, there is a risk that laws will be enacted that extinguish press freedom and undermine the media’s watchdog and critical functions.”
He continued, “She will use ill-conceived laws that suit her preferences to block the media from serving as the eyes and ears of the public, suppress it and extinguish press freedom. I therefore ask that the National Assembly be urged to remove the respondent from the Culture, Sports and Tourism Committee or reassign her, in order to protect press freedom and independence.”
Finally, former council member Lee said, “I urge the National Human Rights Commission of Korea to conduct a thorough investigation, confirm the human rights violations and recommend strong measures to the National Assembly and the Democratic Party so that the affected journalists’ reputations can be restored and press freedom protected.”
Choi Minhee, a senior member of the Democratic Party of Korea, bows in greeting during a press conference at the National Assembly's Communication Hall on the 11th to announce her position on remarks about reporters. Photo by National Assembly Press Photographers Group.
View original imageOn November 12, after the controversy erupted, former council member Lee filed a complaint against Supreme Council member Choi with the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency through the e-People portal, accusing her of defamation by spreading false information under the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection.
Lee said the grounds for his complaint were that Supreme Council member Choi had claimed, without any basis, that journalists covering the event were “trying to film footage that will drive a wedge between people,” which he said constituted the presentation of false information, and that her use of the phrase “a pack of hyenas” showed an intent to disparage them.
Meanwhile, regarding Supreme Council member Choi’s “harsh remarks,” the Korea Press Photographers Association and the Korea Video Journalists Association issued a statement condemning them on November 11 and announced plans to take legal action.
Democratic Party leader Kim Minseok ordered the party’s Ethics Inspection Team on November 12 to investigate Supreme Council member Choi. The Democratic Party’s Public Relations Bureau said, “Leader Kim views the various controversies surrounding Supreme Council member Choi’s recent conduct and remarks as serious.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.