KB Real Estate Trust Wins Another Lawsuit Over a 15 Billion Won Completion Guarantee; Appellate Ruling in Focus
"Actual losses incurred due to failure to fulfill the obligation must be compensated"
An opposite ruling was issued in July in a case involving the same matter
Amid conflicting lower-court rulings over the scope of liability for damages borne by real estate trust companies that entered into completion-guaranteed management-type land trust agreements, KB Real Estate Trust has won a lawsuit seeking more than 15 billion won. This is its second victory, following its win in a lawsuit seeking more than 4 billion won this past September.
As in the previous case, the court ruled that a clause in which the trust company agreed with the lenders to pay the loan principal and interest, as well as overdue interest, if construction was not completed by the guaranteed completion deadline could not be considered an agreement on liquidated damages. Instead, it should be viewed as a provision requiring compensation for actual losses incurred as a result of the failure to fulfill the completion obligation.
KB Life Tower in Yeoksam-dong, Gangnam-gu, Seoul, where KB Real Estate Trust is headquartered. KB Life
View original imageAccording to legal sources on November 12, the 21st Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court, presided over by Judge Jeong Yong-shin, dismissed the plaintiff’s claim on November 5 in a lawsuit filed by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. against KB Real Estate Trust Co., Ltd. seeking more than 15.696 billion won, plus interest, in damages under an agreement.
Defendant KB Real Estate Trust entered into a management-type trust agreement with lenders in connection with a project to construct and sell a knowledge industry center and neighborhood commercial facilities in Segyo-dong, Pyeongtaek, Gyeonggi Province. The plaintiff, Korea Investment & Securities, was a lender that succeeded to the position of the original Tranche B lender, which had loaned 20 billion won to Woojeong Development, the project developer and borrower.
In July 2021, Woojeong Development signed a construction contract with the builders, Samyang Construction Industry and ES Development, for the construction of the building. To secure the funding needed for the project, Woojeong Development entered into a loan agreement with Meritz Securities, Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance, and the builders, under which Woojeong Development would borrow 135 billion won from the lenders, with Meritz Securities acting as the agent financial institution.
Two months later, in September 2021, Woojeong Development entered into a management-type land trust agreement with KB Real Estate Trust, the builders, and the lenders. Under the agreement, Woojeong Development was the settlor, KB Real Estate Trust was the trustee, and the lenders were jointly designated as first- to third-ranking preferred beneficiaries.
On the same day the loan agreement and trust agreement were signed, the builders separately entered into a completion undertaking with the lenders. Under its terms, the builders would not suspend or delay construction for any reason other than force majeure, such as natural disasters or war; would complete the building within 23 months of the initial loan disbursement; and, if they failed to do so, would assume, in addition to and alongside Woojeong Development, its loan debt to the lenders. The builders delivered a completion undertaking bearing their signatures as “builder and debt assumers.” On the same day, KB Real Estate Trust also entered into a completion undertaking with the lenders and delivered a completion performance undertaking bearing its signature as the “undertaking party.”
The builders’ completion deadline was September 1, 2023, 23 months after the initial disbursement, but the building was not completed by then. Amendments were signed twice to extend the deadline, first to December 28, 2023, and then to February 20, 2024. However, the defendant KB Real Estate Trust’s completion deadline, defined as “the date 29 months after the initial loan disbursement,” was not changed.
When the builders failed to complete the building by the twice-extended deadline, KB Real Estate Trust put in its own funds to continue construction, but still failed to complete the building by its own deadline of March 1, 2024. The building did not receive approval for use until May 28, 2024, 88 days after the completion deadline.
The issue at trial was how to interpret a clause in the special provisions of the management-type land trust agreement and in the completion performance undertaking stating that “if the defendant fails to fulfill its completion obligation, the defendant shall compensate the lenders for losses incurred as a result of that failure, including the loan principal and interest and overdue interest.”
The plaintiff argued that KB Real Estate Trust had breached its completion obligation by failing to complete the building by the deadline, as required under the special provisions of the trust agreement or the completion undertaking. It therefore claimed that the company should pay the plaintiff, a lender, more than 15.696 billion won, comprising more than 15.1 billion won in outstanding loan principal and more than 590 million won in overdue interest, together with interest or damages for delay.
The plaintiff also argued in the alternative that, even if the obligation to pay the amount under the agreement was not recognized, the clause at issue could be viewed as an agreement on liquidated damages, making the defendant liable for the same amount. Under Article 398 of the Civil Act, liquidated damages are an amount agreed upon in advance by the parties to a contract as compensation payable in the event of a breach. This allows a creditor to claim the agreed amount by proving only the debtor’s failure to perform, without separately proving whether actual losses occurred or how much they amounted to.
The court, however, rejected the plaintiff’s arguments.
First, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s primary claim, stating: “In light of the wording and payment requirements of the clause, it is reasonable to view it as establishing liability for damages arising from the defendant’s failure to fulfill its completion obligation. It is difficult to conclude that the defendant agreed to provide security for the lenders’ losses or to pay them a fixed amount under the agreement.”
The court also rejected the plaintiff’s alternative claim, setting out detailed reasons for its decision.
The court said: “The purpose of imposing a completion obligation on the defendant under a completion-guaranteed management-type land trust is to increase the likelihood that the lenders will recover their loans by ensuring that the building is completed. It is difficult to conclude that the purpose is to have the defendant directly guarantee repayment of the loan principal and interest and overdue interest to the lenders, regardless of whether the building is completed or how it is disposed of or operated.”
The court added: “If the defendant were required to compensate the plaintiff for the full amount of the outstanding loan principal and interest and overdue interest, the claimed losses would include not only losses caused by delays in completion, but also losses arising from risks inherent in the project itself, such as sluggish sales or a decline in collateral value. It would therefore be difficult to view them as losses having a sufficient causal relationship with the defendant’s failure to fulfill its completion obligation.”
The court noted that the defendant’s trust fee, approximately 1.24% of total sales, was lower than the average fee rate of approximately 2.48% for borrowing-type land trusts carried out over the five years from 2018 to 2022. It stated: “If, as the plaintiff argues, the defendant were required to bear the risks described above and also pay the plaintiff the full amount of the outstanding loan principal and interest and overdue interest if it failed to fulfill its completion obligation, that would mean the defendant was bearing greater risks while receiving a lower fee than for a borrowing-type land trust. This interpretation is difficult to accept without further consideration.”
Finally, the court noted: “If the defendant’s completion undertaking were interpreted as the plaintiff argues, it would be highly likely to constitute an act by a trust business operator to make up for losses or guarantee profits, which is prohibited under Article 103(3) of the Capital Markets Act and Article 104(1) of its Enforcement Decree.”
In the trial, YK Law Firm, which represented defendant KB Real Estate Trust, argued that ▲if the clause at issue were treated as liquidated damages, as the plaintiff contended, it would violate not only the Capital Markets Act but also various provisions of the Trust Act, the Insurance Business Act, and Article 103 of the Civil Act; ▲the essential purpose of a real estate development project is to complete and sell a building, but accepting the plaintiff’s argument would instead allow the lenders to recover their loans by seeking damages from the trust company rather than through completion of the building, contrary to the purpose of the project; and ▲the clause should be interpreted narrowly because the plaintiff’s interpretation would impose an excessively harsh liability on the defendant. During the proceedings, YK Law Firm also pointed out that the defendant’s alleged obligation to pay damages was not an independent debt of its own. It based this argument on Korea Investment & Securities’ acknowledgment that, when it acquired the loan claim through an asset transfer agreement with the original lender, it had “transferred the claim for damages against the defendant as a right ancillary to the loan claim.”
Park Jaewan, an attorney at YK Law Firm, said: “The significance of this ruling is that it is another first-instance decision, following the one in September, holding that the liability clause in a completion-guaranteed trust agreement cannot be treated as liquidated damages. In particular, although KB Real Estate Trust lost in a case with identical facts in which a third-ranking lender was the plaintiff, the outcome was reversed in this case. We believe this indicates that the overall trend in the courts’ decisions is changing.”
Attorney Park said: “YK is currently handling two appeals, and the appellate courts have been watching closely to see how the first-instance rulings turn out. This decision is likely to have a significant impact on the appellate courts’ judgments as well.”
Attorney Park added: “Compared with earlier rulings against trust companies, this decision is much stronger and more persuasive in its legal reasoning and rationale. If this conclusion is upheld on appeal, it could become an important precedent regarding the nature of completion-guaranteed management-type land trusts and the interpretation of trust agreements.”
Earlier, the 28th Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court, presided over by Judge Shin Yong-mu, issued the opposite ruling in July in a case involving the same circumstances as this one.
In that case, the court granted the claims of Shinhan Capital Co., Ltd. and Orix Capital Korea Corporation, which had each acquired a 5 billion won loan claim from a third-ranking beneficiary and sued KB Real Estate Trust for payment of 5 billion won each, plus interest.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
With lower courts issuing sharply conflicting rulings, the industry is closely watching to see what decision the appellate court will make.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.